LogFAQs > #979100103

UltimaterializerX posted...

You and Justin are 100% lock town. Reds logic, not mine, but I agree with it.

Basically all 3 of you two + Peaf have to be scum and a town/scum pair with you and Justin isnt possible, and that logic doesnt track. Ergo, town.

I'll wait for red's explanation then because I don't track that.

I agree that Dumey is town, I don't see any universe where Peaf leaves a scum/scum pair with so little time left in the day for them both to line up something new. I started the evening by trying to determine the answer why Peaf confirmed his breakup with Dumey. I have a few theories, but none of them perfectly make sense with the way the day ended and ultimately had to conclude that Peaf's decision to break his pairing was most likely something he decided to do alone and not in consultation with scummates.

The first thing Peaf did was throw a request at Kirby "Cause i can be your hero baby". It could simply be that one of the unpaired individuals at that moment was scum. At that moment it was just Kirby, JC and Lea. So it was either to pair with Kirby, who was the presumptive day 1 death at that point, or to pair with either JC or Lea after being rejected by Kirby. Kirby, to his credit did not respond to Peaf's pair request and was instead in the process of Pairing with Lea before I sniped the date using the open request he'd sent to me hours earlier. It's still possible that makes Kirby scum that Peaf was trying to save, but again they were clearly not operating from the same playbook if that's the case. So then maybe just Peaf badly misreading his odds of pairing with Kirby and thinking he'll look more towny for being willing to die to save a town kirby.

But it's all very messy from a logical perspective. But the fact that Peaf's first order of business was attempting to save Kirby meant I trusted him quite a bit less last night that I otherwise might have.