Board 8 > Persona 5 Mafia Topic 3 - The Museum of Vanity

(+) Yeah! (+)

Plum, Chris, red

I dont recall reg meta how much of a busser was he
---

Patr of me thinks he could have been bussing Terra
But he seemed to get genuinely frustrated with Terra too..
---

htaeD posted...

Patr of me thinks he could have been bussing Terra
But he seemed to get genuinely frustrated with Terra too..

Insert paranoia of scum terra saying they would need to be replaced in night phase but informed team before eod and set up spot for Chris
---

Rolls eyes.
---

ScareChan posted...

Plum, Chris, red

I dont recall reg meta how much of a busser was he

Dont recall.
---

I was driving home and had time for that vote. I had said all day that eaed was my lynch target and couldn't get an answer from anyone why we should lynch reg over eaed, I didn't see it. I asked multiple times and never got an answer. I was wrong, but I was consistent.

But please enlighten me why your lynch "isn't happening today" plum.
---

(btw countervoting and calling someone better than to vote him is also another example of scum plum)
---

Shaduln posted...

I was driving home and had time for that vote. I had said all day that eaed was my lynch target and couldn't get an answer from anyone why we should lynch reg over eaed, I didn't see it. I asked multiple times and never got an answer. I was wrong, but I was consistent.

But please enlighten me why your lynch "isn't happening today" plum.

Answering for him: because we had a town vs scum lynch and the first place we look isnt to the guy who voted scum
---

Don't care, he's scum.
---

I mean, you can say you don't care all you want but the smart play is to look into the votes on the counterwagon to see where scum lies.

Shad, you could be right. Really. But let's organize.
---

I'm gonna have to do some serious re-evaluation now because I thought that lynch was town-town all night and I was wrong on Han. Scare and Neab are both confirmed and we have Chris for a day at least so that's nice. Since it was a close lynch, chances are there actually were quite a lot of scum on Ed as well. Doubt I'll be around much til late tonight and I'll try and read through everything again with a more correct perspective. I agree that we should be looking at the people on the Ed vote primarily, although I also want to look at the ones who weren't voting either at the end That means Corrik and Chris, who're funnily enough wrong about me, and considering them being wrong is a sign of them being scum... Though Chris does have the excuse of following Han and that the dude he replaced was completely inactive. I would say Red as well but I still townread him, although I don't know if that's gonna change with re-reading.
---

Do not fear sheep I am just honoring han for the moment since no one ever does. My Thursday is slammed but Friday afternoon I can go in depth day 1.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Reg posted...

And even then, I'm not just randomly shitposting here. I was planning to revisit IGCD once we got out of the pleasantries phase to see how serious his post #33 was. Neablis seems to have called it out rather bluntly though so I don't know how much value there is in that with him being able to think about it.

Does anyone else think this is extremely scummy? I've never played with Reg before, so I'm not gonna pretend to know him, but it sounds totally made up on the spot to say that he was planning on revisiting a post later. Like it was thrown out defensively to reassure us that he is looking for scum right now

Ben still not scum yay
---

Also @garetha200 needs to do something today or if its too much for him to participate ask to be replaced
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Do not fear sheep I am just honoring han for the moment since no one ever does. My Thursday is slammed but Friday afternoon I can go in depth day 1.

And I just realised you replaced Terra rather than Gareth so my non-voting point against you was invalid ._.

I'll have to go through the end of yesterday again as I said, but at the time I felt like Death and Shad had the better progression towards voting Ed when compared with DYL and IGCD. IGCD was on my townlist for his start of day though and that's before the votes became a big factor so I'll stick with that.
---

Okay maybe mu is getting to my meta too much. I know gravy himself doesny like conversion roles

But not ruling out an aligned role

red13n posted...

i actually probably didnt know that town was called town in this game. Truthfhully, I only glanced at my PM and have the important words memorized.

I also know there unfortunately wasnt a scumboard link.

But it is getting late. You should all go to bed.

This post with him also trying to curry reg to Join him early on. If red isn't just straight scum he may be scum aligned

Which lines up with him breadcrumbing so much as well
---

Sheep007 posted...

I agree that we should be looking at the people on the Ed vote primarily, although I also want to look at the ones who weren't voting either at the end

I suggest looking at Johnbobb, who even said he didn't like eaed and that the Reg lynch felt like scum pushing a mislynch. Yet he didn't vote for eaed because he didn't want to get his hands dirty

It seems to be working because everyone else is ignoring him
---

MZero11 posted...

Sheep007 posted...

I agree that we should be looking at the people on the Ed vote primarily, although I also want to look at the ones who weren't voting either at the end

I suggest looking at Johnbobb, who even said he didn't like eaed and that the Reg lynch felt like scum pushing a mislynch. Yet he didn't vote for eaed because he didn't want to get his hands dirty

It seems to be working because everyone else is ignoring him

wouldnt this speak in his favor?

Again, I cant see scum abstaining from a vote when one scum is involved in the decision making.
---

Fine, I just want to make sure it's out there and we should kill plum tomorrow.
---

Also red parked on igcd from beginning of game for igcd shading him and red never really showed any progression and kept his vote there
---

ScareChan posted...

Also red parked on igcd from beginning of game for igcd shading him and red never really showed any progression and kept his vote there

This is very true.
---

conversion roles??

also we need a new topic
---

I keep forgetting neab is vig because I want to bury him everytime I see his posts
---

htaeD posted...

MZero11 posted...

Sheep007 posted...

I agree that we should be looking at the people on the Ed vote primarily, although I also want to look at the ones who weren't voting either at the end

I suggest looking at Johnbobb, who even said he didn't like eaed and that the Reg lynch felt like scum pushing a mislynch. Yet he didn't vote for eaed because he didn't want to get his hands dirty

It seems to be working because everyone else is ignoring him

wouldnt this speak in his favor?

Again, I cant see scum abstaining from a vote when one scum is involved in the decision making.

Have you not noticed everyone looking at the eaed lynch to find the scum?

There's almost certainly scum on the eaed lynch but I doubt all of them jumped on. That would be way too obvious
---

htaeD posted...

conversion roles??

also we need a new topic

Gravy does not like conversion roles and this is is game. In a previous game he gave scum a make your own role role but didnt allow us to recruit anyone

But i think an aligned player that's not on the board would be in play. Is there a flavor character that fits with that?
---

I vaguely remember liking a John post but that doesn't say a lot. Some pressure there might be nice. But, MZero, I gotta say you kinda fall in that category as well with everything I can remember from you being about John.
---

Flavorwise everyone in the Velvet Room can be unaligned.
The one who gave Regs character his power also gave the same power to the good guys.

Have you not noticed everyone looking at the eaed lynch to find the scum?

There's almost certainly scum on the eaed lynch but I doubt all of them jumped on. That would be way too obvious

I suppose from that angle I get the approach. And perhaps scum didnt even think the lynch was feasible until the end... (and they apparently had a secret vote in reserve anyway)
---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/77319516
---

Sheep007 posted...

I vaguely remember liking a John post but that doesn't say a lot. Some pressure there might be nice. But, MZero, I gotta say you kinda fall in that category as well with everything I can remember from you being about John.

well I posted several times about John and was ignored every time so I'm going to keep beating that drum

just like in that Game of Thrones game when everyone kept ignoring my posts about dowolf being scum for like 3 days and then lynched me... and dowolf was scum of course
---

MZero11 posted...

Sheep007 posted...

I vaguely remember liking a John post but that doesn't say a lot. Some pressure there might be nice. But, MZero, I gotta say you kinda fall in that category as well with everything I can remember from you being about John.

well I posted several times about John and was ignored every time so I'm going to keep beating that drum

just like in that Game of Thrones game when everyone kept ignoring my posts about dowolf being scum for like 3 days and then lynched me... and dowolf was scum of course

I didn't ignore it but he was tunneling me and managed to get me lynched so I was also ignored >_>
---