I think case 2 is worse than case 3, honestly.
Yes, the logic in case 3 is probably the worst in the series and watching the video over and over again is annoying. But I like a lot of the characters. I like the scenario of the murder taking place at a concert. I like the ridiculousness of the Gavinners.
Case 2 is so fucking boring. The characters are all awful (Trucy's alright), the mystery is stupid and not entertaining and every time the defendant talks its like nails on a chalkboard. Never mind the fucking panty sniffer thing that is spent way too much time on.
I'd take the the obnoxious case solving of the third case over that shit any day.
"That thick shaft that causes women to
shudder
!"