My first answer is always gonna be Tales of Symphonia! I like to say that, before Symphonia, I was just someone who liked to play games, and after it, I was a gamer. When I first played it, I replayed it about a dozen times in a row just for the enjoyment of it, which remains my wildest gaming memory~
But if I added a few more, let's say a top five, I think I would pick Pokemon Sapphire, Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance, Suikoden V, and Genshin Impact. Sapphire and PoR just have a lot of pure nostalgia power, and SV has a "wild gaming memory" story of its own. Genshin is obviously the odd one out here, but I'm genuinely in love with it and fully intend to stick with it until the end~
EDIT: How in the
world
did I forget Sonic 3 & Knuckles, the very first game I ever truly played/beat? As much as it pains me, I'm taking SV off that top five list for S3&K.
Master Duel (373-244-752) | FGO (960,463,298)
Let's be friends~