If GF made a Pokemon with all regions, all Pokemon and the game had great visual

Current Events

Current Events » If GF made a Pokemon with all regions, all Pokemon and the game had great visual
SocialistGamer
10/14/2025
11:23 AM
#1
and performance, would fans still complain?
Capcom is the best developer ever!
Steam ID: SocialistGamer92
CRON
10/14/2025
11:24 AM
#2
Yes. They'd just start nitpicking miniscule changes in battle stats and mechanics.
It is what it is, man.
Nemu
10/14/2025
11:25 AM
#3
I'd see people complaining that the scope is too large, but it wouldn't be many if they actually were to somehow make a balanced and fun game out of all that. It's amazing we live in the timeline where Nintendo's biggest franchise is the worst managed game-wise.
ssb_yunglink2
10/14/2025
11:26 AM
#4
Some fans would, just as any series has fans that are impossible to please.

Lets get game freak to make a modern 3d game with good graphics, frame rate, and function before we cross that bridge though. So far LGPE is the best performance and arguably graphics wise and that was a gen 1 tile based remake with only the og 151
Hee Ho
zinformant
10/14/2025
11:26 AM
#5
Nobody over ten years old wants this. While it's not a fundamental game design tenet, most roleplaying games can support eight to thirteen dungeons and something around that many bosses (often less).
our sins return to the stars 'til the end of time
ai123
10/14/2025
11:28 AM
#6
Most of them would be delighted.

But a not insignificant number of Pokmon fans are terrible people who will always find something to moan about.
'Vinyl is the poor man's art collection'.
30-50% of those arrested at anti immigration protests in the UK have convictions for domestic abuse.
gikos
10/14/2025
11:28 AM
#7
SocialistGamer posted...
and performance, would fans still complain?
yes. cuz even if a game is perfect people will still nitpick
tho i do nitpick on GF myself. my fav pokemon game will always be my first one and that is diamond on GBA so seeing that meh remake still irks me to this day
"You can pretend to be serious; you can't pretend to be witty." - Sacha Guitry (1885-1957)
NoxObscuras
10/14/2025
11:33 AM
#8
Some would still complain, but overall most would be ecstatic. The "leak" said they're making a game with Kanto, Johto, Hoenn, and Sinnoh, but I'm taking that with a grain of salt.

gikos posted...
my fav pokemon game will always be my first one and that is diamond on GBA
Diamond and Pearl were on the DS
Steam/Xbox/PSN = NoxObscuras
snake_5036
10/14/2025
11:35 AM
#9
all the complaints would be about how "bloated" the game is or the level curve being reset for each region or whatever
You felt your sins weighing on your neck.
gikos
10/14/2025
11:59 AM
#10
NoxObscuras posted...
Diamond and Pearl were on the DS
....man how did i confusing it with GBA
"You can pretend to be serious; you can't pretend to be witty." - Sacha Guitry (1885-1957)
UnsteadyOwl
10/14/2025
12:17 PM
#11
A game like that would probably be at least $80 so people will complain about the price.
"It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose. That is not a weakness. That is life."
ai123
10/14/2025
12:29 PM
#12
UnsteadyOwl posted...
A game like that would probably be at least $80 so people will complain about the price.
And it would take 5+ years to make, do they'd complain about that too.

Also:
The new Pokmon are all lazy designs
The rival isn't a total prick
The tutorial is too hand-holdy
They didn't bring back [MECHANIC I LIKED]
They brought back [MECHANIC I DIDN'T LIKE]
The new mechanic is shit
Landorus-T is still OP
Too many bipedal Pokmon
Charizard still isn't a Dragon

'Vinyl is the poor man's art collection'.
30-50% of those arrested at anti immigration protests in the UK have convictions for domestic abuse.
CARRRNE_ASADA
10/14/2025
12:39 PM
#13
CRON posted...
Yes. They'd just start nitpicking miniscule changes in battle stats and mechanics.

But thats not something that would reflect on scores so much. Thats more like people compaining they didnt get their favorite character in a new ssb game.
SEXY SEXY!
Jerry_Hellyeah
10/14/2025
01:13 PM
#14
The fans would love to get a half decent game. The idea that disliking the horrible garbage they've made billions off of is "nitpicking" is some serious apologist behaviour and not appreciated.

The Pokmon Fandom talks about how brutally outdated Red and Blue are but its STILL THE SAME GODDAMN GAME.
This is a cool sig
Trumpo
10/14/2025
01:23 PM
#15
It would need a real budget instead of what they get now to release slop.
Lancool II | Z690 Tomahawk | 12700K | Fuma 2 | RTX 3070Ti | 32GB 3600MHz | FireCuda 530 1TB | Inland NVMe 1TB | P3 Plus 4TB | RM750x
BucketCat
10/14/2025
01:35 PM
#16
tbh, I'd be super happy if they did a completely revamped Kanto + Johto

make it somewhat open-ended like Pokemon Crystal Clear (idk how much we're allowed to discuss things like romhacks, but crystal clear did a really great job making gen2 feel more open-ended)
?
badjay
10/14/2025
01:36 PM
#17
Closest you're gonna get is pokemon seed.

Seed a new kind of RPG that takes place all the Japanese based regions (Kanto, Johto, Hoenn, and Sinnoh) potenitally a 2029 release.

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/3/306aadca.jpg
[05:45:34] I bought an American L and it was like a tent
Philip027
10/14/2025
01:37 PM
#18
Is this even a question? Of course they would
ssb_yunglink2
10/14/2025
01:53 PM
#19
ai123 posted...
And it would take 5+ years to make, do they'd complain about that too.

Also:
The new Pokmon are all lazy designs
The rival isn't a total prick
The tutorial is too hand-holdy
They didn't bring back [MECHANIC I LIKED]
They brought back [MECHANIC I DIDN'T LIKE]
The new mechanic is shit
Landorus-T is still OP
Too many bipedal Pokmon
Charizard still isn't a Dragon
I mean some of these are pretty legitimate things to complain about though. When a mechanic you like is gone and one you didnt is back in a series you enjoy, the youre gonna complain about it. Hand holdy tutorials are just problems in a lot of games in general

I feel like some of yall take the over the top hatred Pokemon gets and loop back around to all complaints are dumb accept your slop
Hee Ho
Jerry_Hellyeah
10/14/2025
02:11 PM
#20
UnsteadyOwl posted...
A game like that would probably be at least $80 so people will complain about the price.

"Nintendo would still fuck us" is a piss poor excuse to make for the millionaire ding dings at the Pokmon Company.

It wouldn't be an $80 game if we stop accepting slop from arguably the most beloved franchise on earth.
This is a cool sig
UnsteadyOwl
10/14/2025
02:14 PM
#21
Jerry_Hellyeah posted...
"Nintendo would still fuck us" is a piss poor excuse to make for the millionaire ding dings at the Pokmon Company.

It wouldn't be an $80 game if we stop accepting slop from arguably the most beloved franchise on earth.
I didn't say the price should be that high, just that it would be and that would be a source of complaints.
"It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose. That is not a weakness. That is life."
Smiffwilm
10/14/2025
02:26 PM
#22
There are literally people who nitpick games they've never even played, ever. So, yeah.
My Mario Maker 2 ID is 6RG-5XK-JCG
DodogamaRayBrst
10/14/2025
02:27 PM
#23
To be honest, I don't want to go back to a pre-dexit world.
Evening_Dragon
10/14/2025
04:51 PM
#25
zinformant posted...
Nobody over ten years old wants this. While it's not a fundamental game design tenet, most roleplaying games can support eight to thirteen dungeons and something around that many bosses (often less).

Speak for yourself.
And which of you by worrying can add a single hour to your span of life?
It's Guide
Turbam
10/14/2025
04:53 PM
#26
Yeah, they'll complain until the sex update drops
~snip (V)_(;,;)_(V) snip~
I'm just one man! Whoa! Well, I'm a one man band! https://imgur.com/p9Xvjvs
Scintillant
10/14/2025
04:54 PM
#27
Honestly I would like it if it were balanced well... Even in the open world Scarlet and Violet games I felt like I caught all the Pokemon so quickly and just kept getting the same ones... the love of the adventure wore out quick because too many areas had too many Pokemon. The flip side of that is that the Pokemon I would want could be locked away near the end of a region's exploration and I would feel like I didn't get to use them.

It'd be hard to make the adventure seem fun and rewarding when the reality is there just aren't enough Pokemon to make all regions feel "full" without also making each new area/route seem barren.
whats cat up to
Dakimakura
10/14/2025
05:35 PM
#28
Pokemon has a variety of different audiences. One of which is a hardcore competitive scene that will lose their shit if even one Pokemon has a move that it shouldn't or even if it is too strong.
Gamefaqs Community Organizer
Current Events » If GF made a Pokemon with all regions, all Pokemon and the game had great visual