Adams.
I'll expound on my reasoning later maybe but I want to make sure I get my vote in before we move on. The Democratic-Republicans continue their general style of paranoia, and supporting the French Revolution as it currently stands is kind of a bad look.
Not to mention he's way better on slavery. Maybe we can actually get some reforms in on that point if he takes office, whereas there's no way abolitionists will get to make any headway at all with the wealthy slave-owning elite Jefferson in power.