Re-posting from last topic...
TidusOfTheX posted...
I want to lynch Ben today, not only because he is scummy, but also because lynching him would also give us lots of info. ##Vote: Ben
I love this response. I am always in favor of lynching Ben Day 1 just for the memes lmao
But nah, I don't think this is the same scum Ben from last game. Could've been Chrisfear last game, but Ben struck me as more "chummy" or willing to buddy up to people rather than go on the offensive/be so assertive. He's definitely more of the latter this game.
Nonetheless, I feel good about this response from Tidus. I don't know how scum Tidus plays, but I feel like throwing out an opinion like this (even if it's about Ben) is a bold move that a cautious scum wouldn't really take.
IfGodCouldDie posted...
I'm still not convinced that Plum is scum. I don't really agree with the attacks on them because I don't necessarily belive his behaviour is scum behaviour, it comes across more as just anti-town behaviour, and the attacks all feel cyclical on him. Its like people are using each others attacks to feel justified in their own attacks and then people are using the other attacks to justify their own attacks.
Interesting observation. So if Plum flipped town, would you say any of his aggressors would be scum? If so, who would be the scummiest?
Leanansidhe posted...
Weren't you someone voting DYL "to get more content". I saw Tidus answer like one direct question about death and that's about it all. I expect more after posting "gonna get back to this soon" multiple times. Besides, I don't consider choosing to play video games to the exclusion of this mafia game to be legitimate busy-ness. It feels phony. Regardless of whether you think it's petty or not I'm not satisfied with his content so far.
What on Earth are you talking about? It's not difficult to Ctrl + F through Tidus's posts and see he did more than just that.
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80061692/965918074
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80061692/965918129
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80061692/965918558
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80061692/965925181
Sure, it might not be a whole lot of content or huge walls or such. That's just Tidus's posting style, but it's not like he's posting fluff (though I personally think saying stuff like "I agree" isn't fluffy unless there's no supporting reasons behind it).
DYL literally only had three posts by the time I voted for him (technically four, but I didn't see the fourth one while drafting my messages). Tidus may not have that many more points, but pinning it on inactivity because he wanted to play games is horrid reasoning. I hope I wouldn't have to stop playing Final Fantasy XIV just because I signed up for mafia!
If you don't like his content, that's fair. But this argument of him being busy playing games is frivolous. It's grasping at straws and frankly gives me the same uneasy vibes I had about you last game on Day 1. Though I'd still like to believe your claim about (hopefully Town) Invisible being true.