Paper Mario Mafia Topic 5 - I swear that I, Kooper, will follow you anywhere!

Board 8

Page of 10
Board 8 » Paper Mario Mafia Topic 5 - I swear that I, Kooper, will follow you anywhere!
TheSultanOfSlam posted...
Your only 2 suspects are the people calling you scum? Is Death next?
I have not called HB scum. I just think he has overstayed his town credit for being aggressive when it seems to be his normal standard of play anyway.
my links broke. :(
Peace___Frog posted...
Jc I'll be honest, you haven't looked pristine today. I was waffling on you even while my vote was on you.

I think ctes certainly looks worse than han in that pair, though.
Doesnt change anything about my question though! I asked you specifically because I think youre the most town of the 3 people who voted me and I was curious if you thought it was an all-town effort.
we're all buds ~jc~
<DeathChicken> you are my hero for being the first person to cite National Geographic in Mercs
EDumey posted...
I actually don't have a problem with most of the other things you listed there, but I don't think the role is that useless. It is definitely a weak scanner, but it could still verify people's claims.

Not really.

What info does Ben get that benefits Town as a whole?

Townies aren't gonna lie about their flavor. Scum will lie, but it's entirely contingent on them claiming a Star Spirit on the safelist and Ben scanning them.

It's possible that Ben is telling the truth, but I just find it very difficult to believe he has such a role given its interactions with Sbell's role. And when there's a stinky role interaction that's not clear, it usually means somebody is lying. And it can't be Sbell who's the liar!
Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
I hate to say it... but i was considering voting for hb before death did. Now I'm less sure, because i honestly thought death was scum.

Hb has done a great job of being here without drawing a ton of attention to himself. But he did the same thing when he was a power role last game, and he followed the scum team to the lynch they wanted basically every single day.
~Peaf~
TheSultanOfSlam posted...
Your only 2 suspects are the people calling you scum? Is Death next?
well my initial push today was for ben, but i've decided to back off of that for obvious reasons. IDK Ctes has also looked bad today.
:)
Chaeix posted...
ctes so what youre saying is your reads are so weak that you dont have any suspects you want lynched more than claimed town power (and as death pointed out you have not pressured me to claim fully)

No, I'm saying that you claiming that didn't suddenly revert evetything else you have done. I did not say I absolutely have to stay there or anything like that, just that I don't immediately unvote a suspect the darn moment they say they moved. I'm not sure I want your full claim either, still not entirely sure what to make of Ben and I doubt you're both scum so that's relevant.
Guinness Book of World Records is the name of the diary that belongs to azuarc , the winner of the Game of the Decade II guru contest.
Kirby321 posted...
Tell me where Ben breadcrumbed it on Day 1 .

Because I don't care if he breadcrumbed it on Day 2. That role can be easily faked after seeing Isquen's flip.
True... but with my conditionals earlier, and previous impressions, scum ben really doesn't check out for me.
~Peaf~
Peace___Frog posted...
Hb has done a great job of being here without drawing a ton of attention to himself. But he did the same thing when he was a power role last game, and he followed the scum team to the lynch they wanted basically every single day.
That is categorically not true! I didn't lynch Red OR Lopen, and Red dying like that was what cost Town the game in the end.
:)
Chaeix posted...
Doesnt change anything about my question though! I asked you specifically because I think youre the most town of the 3 people who voted me and I was curious if you thought it was an all-town effort.
I could see one of han and ctes being scum, yes. I think han looks pretty damn good from d1, less so on d2 but still good, so that leaves ctes.

I do think you are town for now.
~Peaf~
Hbthebattle posted...
That is categorically not true! I didn't lynch Red OR Lopen, and Red dying like that was what cost Town the game in the end.
I don't remember there being a lot of resistance to the lopen lynch, and you joined Chang in telling him that at least the topics would be easier to reread with him gone. And the last day was a steamroll, but i don't remember specifically if you voted for igcd or not.
~Peaf~
Hbthebattle posted...
That is categorically not true! I didn't lynch Red OR Lopen, and Red dying like that was what cost Town the game in the end.
Also you're arguing that you are not a town power role. Curious.
~Peaf~
These conditionals, Peaf?

Peace___Frog posted...
Scum Ulti wouldn't go this hard to defend scum ben unless they were in a "one more mislynch and we win" kind of deal - which they obviously are not.

Scum Ulti might go this hard to defend town Ben, in the way that sbell hard cleared Sultan.

Scum ben would have had to get extraordinarily lucky to get town Ulti to go along with this.

So i think they're either town/ town or Ulti is scum and Ben is town. Either way, Ben is town for me.

The only conditional that mentions Scum Ben is the third one. And frankly, I don't see the weight of it. Why are you assuming Scum Ben was banking on somebody believing him just because they're a Star Spirit?

We know that there are Star Spirits in this game due to Isquen's flip. If anything, a Scum Ben would be banking on people seeing Isquen's flip and believing him. Anyone else outing themselves as a Star Spirit would just be a bonus.

Ulti's defense for Ben is weak, anyway. "I'm a Star Spirit, so Ben must be telling the truth!" Like... no? Isquen is a confirmed, flipped Star Spirit, but that doesn't mean Ben is telling the truth.
Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
Topic 6 coming very shortly sorry y'all
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
Peace___Frog posted...
Also you're arguing that you are not a town power role. Curious.
I have made no comments on that one way or the other. You know that's not what I was referring to.
:)
Go here and don't hate me for terrible topic titles:

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80347229
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
Board 8 » Paper Mario Mafia Topic 5 - I swear that I, Kooper, will follow you anywhere!
Page of 10