Gamefaq Mafia Mafia topic 1. Welcome to Sultan's Fun House

Board 8

Page of 9
Board 8 » Gamefaq Mafia Mafia topic 1. Welcome to Sultan's Fun House
red13n
06/21/2023
05:53 PM
#401
htaeD posted...


Because its better for scum to kill me of course.
Oh and because I am town.

Give more than this. Give me some convincing thoughts that make me want to not kill you.
"First thing that crosses my mind: I didn't get any GameFAQs Karma yesterday." Math Murderer after getting his appendix removed.
PeaceFrog
06/21/2023
05:54 PM
#402
Lopen posted...
No I want to lynch you or Isquen tomorrow.
Ok glad we're on the same page. If for whatever reason scum doesn't kill death or Kirby overnight it doesn't automatically mean that the living one is scum. Good talk.
~Peaf~
PeaceFrog
06/21/2023
05:55 PM
#403
htaeD posted...
Its useless statistics because the least possible thing can always happen regardless of what the numbers say.

Its about as dumb as saying 'Sbell cant be scum a 3rd time in a row!'
Nah i do agree with lopen, it's more actionable than what you're going at here
~Peaf~
#404
Post #404 was unavailable or deleted.
#405
Post #405 was unavailable or deleted.
htaeD
06/21/2023
05:59 PM
#406
Well you will need to let the day be long then since I am about to go to sleep and havent been able to get a good overview of the whole game yet.

I am sure some people voting Kirby could be scum trying to get in towns good graces
(Not mine, because I am dead tonight either way)
But I dont know who to pick from that yet. I like Peafs reasoning and Lea's reaction seemed genuine to the whole mess.
Less sure about IGCD, but then again I dont recall how he's felt about me in the past and if that should or should not have helped him come to his current conclusion.
Sbell confuses me since at times it sounds like he is trying to have it go both ways.

I will say that I am shocked that Corrik hasnt taken this chance to yell at Ulti. It feels out of character almost.
Violet IGN: Malta, Sword IGN: Pandora
Home: Pandorian/JBURSQAVTAGA
htaeD
06/21/2023
06:00 PM
#407
PeaceFrog posted...

Nah i do agree with lopen, it's more actionable than what you're going at here


Maybe. But its never a good argument.
Violet IGN: Malta, Sword IGN: Pandora
Home: Pandorian/JBURSQAVTAGA
Lopen
06/21/2023
06:01 PM
#408
Why Death is scum
Doctor claim literally immediately feels more like something scum drawing doctor counterclaim would do
Lightly attacked sbell from the shadows like an imp as he received pressure
Acting like I'm being dumb/crazy when I'm not actually being dumb/crazy

Why Kirby is scum
Completely spineless play for a cop-- should be trying to build a case on Death or at least looking into why Death might be scum rather than just saying "nothing in particular feels scummy" and just wringing your wrists "oh well guys"
Doesn't understand basic probability math and instead goes with trying to say odds of town vs odds of scum
Claims he was joke voting Sbell (who was at 3 votes at the time-- that is not kosher joke voting procedure with 7 to lynch. ha ha great joke dude he's gonna get lynched) while he previously raised some suspicion of sbell along the way

I can POSSIBLY humor Death is town to the point where I wouldn't immediately lynch him if he survived the night. I honestly can't humor Kirby is at this point and would want to lynch him tomorrow if he was alive under any circumstance.

Therefore we should lynch Kirby.
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
htaeD
06/21/2023
06:01 PM
#409
Lea posted...
No, I'm with Lopen on this one. It's perfectly cromulent to consider this. He's not saying you're more likely to be scum than doctor, he's saying Kirby should be thinking you're more likely to be scum than ostensibly 100% town Kirby, from his perspective.


Okay I get that. But I thought Lopen was saying that to accuse me of being scum for his own sake as well.
Violet IGN: Malta, Sword IGN: Pandora
Home: Pandorian/JBURSQAVTAGA
htaeD
06/21/2023
06:03 PM
#410
I did not attack Sbell.
I interrogated him in a nonviolent way.
I didnt see a reason to attack him for the reasons given by IGCD and co.
Violet IGN: Malta, Sword IGN: Pandora
Home: Pandorian/JBURSQAVTAGA
Lopen
06/21/2023
06:03 PM
#411
To set the record straight I am actually saying he's more likely to be scum fakeclaiming doctor than doctor BUT it is more condemning of Kirby than Death yes.
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
Kirby321
06/21/2023
06:04 PM
#412
With all due respect to Ulti, I don't have faith that he pegged one scum and one town with his role, unless he did so on purpose because he himself is scum.

You'd have to draw a link between Ulti and Death being scummates before I could believe Death is scum and not just truthfully claiming Doctor. Could Death be fakeclaiming Doctor as scum? Yes, it's probable. But that's fully operating on the probability of Death being scum, which Ulti had a 3/11 or 4/11 chance of nailing. Again, those odds aren't necessarily high.

The only thing that might suggest an Ulti and Death scum team is that Ulti used this ability so early on and so recklessly that there's not nearly enough content to even try to pair the two together.

Call me crazy, but I really don't think I'm wrong here for not immediately thinking Death is scum.
Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
htaeD
06/21/2023
06:06 PM
#413
I am starting to think that Ulti could be town regardless, because what scum would risk a partners life like that so early in the game?
I mean I am me sure, but I'd like to think that even if I were something like a mere nilla, I would not be a certain mislynch
Violet IGN: Malta, Sword IGN: Pandora
Home: Pandorian/JBURSQAVTAGA
Lopen
06/21/2023
06:07 PM
#414
Kirby321 posted...
Call me crazy, but I really don't think I'm wrong here for not immediately thinking Death is scum.

I'm not saying you should immediately think Death is scum

I'm saying you should actually investigate him instead of shrugging and saying "well I haven't got a scum read on him guys!!" when you're gladiating with him.

You know you're town. You know scum would have no qualms fakeclaiming doctor here to ensure your doom. You still give this claim all the credibility of an doctor claim under different circumstances in spite of that despite it being more likely he's lying scum.

It's either the mindset of scum vs scum or scum who knows too much and knows he's telling the truth.
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
TheSultanOfSlam
06/21/2023
06:09 PM
#415
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80485085

Move here
YOU WILL BOW DOWN TO THE SULTAN
Hello Here is a pineapple
Kirby321
06/21/2023
06:09 PM
#416
Like, forgive me for being grumpy, but I'm seriously annoyed at this horrible play from Ulti. It's Day 1, and I already struggle with making reads on Day 1, no matter how weak those reads are, and I'm basically consigned to die either by lynch today or by nightkill. Which is cruel irony that I rolled Cop again and once more I'm not gonna live to see a Day 2.

So I'm not exactly feeling the most motivated to actually do any scumhunting when I have absolutely nothing to go off of and Ulti singlehandedly killed off whatever other discussion could be spawned from this day. Really, this day is dragging on for way longer than it needs to. Death and I are both gonna be dead before Day 2, so why bother drawing this out pointlessly?
Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure
Soo... how was your day?
Lopen
06/21/2023
06:10 PM
#417
Like if Death claims doctor under pressure, yes, let it be, live to fight again.

If Death claims doctor immediately to start a gladiator match-- does a real doctor do this or does he try to keep his role secret as long as he can and win through conventional terms first? Kirby had some murmurings about him being scum-- it seems absurd that a town doctor would immediately want to claim rather than just trying to determine and convince people his opponent his scum first.
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
htaeD
06/21/2023
06:13 PM
#418
Lopen posted...
Like if Death claims doctor under pressure, yes, let it be, live to fight again.

If Death claims doctor immediately to start a gladiator match-- does a real doctor do this or does he try to keep his role secret as long as he can and win through conventional terms first? Kirby had some murmurings about him being scum-- it seems absurd that a town doctor would immediately want to claim rather than just trying to determine and convince people his opponent his scum first.


I just thought it would end with both of us claiming regardless, so I didn't want to keep town waiting and I also was selfish/impatient and wanted the day to not go on forever.

Probably should have waited to gather more reaction data though I guess.
Violet IGN: Malta, Sword IGN: Pandora
Home: Pandorian/JBURSQAVTAGA
htaeD
06/21/2023
06:17 PM
#419
Also this is where I sign off. Another reason for me to claim when I did. I wasnt gonna let the 'secret' go on for another 8 hours and I was not gonna reveal it right before midnight and not be around to see the reactions.
Violet IGN: Malta, Sword IGN: Pandora
Home: Pandorian/JBURSQAVTAGA
Lopen
06/21/2023
06:17 PM
#420
I'm not even saying you have to be scum by doing that.

People misplay whatever.

I'm just saying if I was Kirby there is already data to suggest you're scum just by the fact that he knows you're doctor already. That should immediately ping him and make him consider "is no lynch best or should I get scum here"
No problem!
This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
htaeD
06/21/2023
06:18 PM
#421
People misplay whatever.


As I said. Cursed protector.
Violet IGN: Malta, Sword IGN: Pandora
Home: Pandorian/JBURSQAVTAGA
TheSultanOfSlam
06/26/2023
11:45 PM
#422
Keepers
YOU WILL BOW DOWN TO THE SULTAN
Hello Here is a pineapple
TheSultanOfSlam
07/01/2023
09:46 PM
#423
Up
YOU WILL BOW DOWN TO THE SULTAN
Hello Here is a pineapple
Crescent-Moon
07/02/2023
06:47 PM
#424
Red never placed a single vote the entire first day in Smash. The afforementioned vote on Chris is the only vote Red ever made in the game before replacing out on day 2.
So a planet's somewhere out there, their history the same as ours is written. The only difference is that... Everyone's a kitten!
Board 8 » Gamefaq Mafia Mafia topic 1. Welcome to Sultan's Fun House
Page of 9