Nominated by Anagram
Did not expect that my answer would hang on for the win, but everything was so split up it only took a few like-minded people to prevail. That said, ATLA would have won out if I had combined all the various Avatar answers.
I'm normally against first-name prompts, but "John" was okay. Maybe we'll get enough "boy," "Dick and Harry," and "& Jerry" to outweigh all the real people that will show up today.
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/3/3ec0ab6d.png
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/a/a809e924.png
Recent top results:
Day 262: Water
Temple
(9%)
Day 261: Sir
Lancelot
(16%)
Day 260: Tie --
Pink
Lady and
First
Lady (10%)
Day 259: Tie -- Lady
and the Tramp
and Lady
Luck
(17%)
Day 258: San
Francisco
(42%)
Day 257:
The Sound of
Music (16%)
Day 256:
All
In (20%)
Day 255: Tie --
Wipe
out and
Fall
out (10%)
Day 254:
South
Park (32%)
Day 253: Blood
Money
(10%)
Day 252:
Die
Hard (67%)
Day 251:
Square
Soft (30%)
Day 250:
Ace
of
Spades
(9%)
Day 249:
Ogre
Battle (14%)
Day 248: Battle
Royale
(25%)
Day 247: The Battle of
The Bulge
(26%)
Day 246: Metal
Gear
(35%)
Day 245: All-Star
Game
(28%)
Day 244: Ice
Ice Baby
(29%)
Day 243: Fire
Emblem
(20%)
Day 242: Holy
Shit
(34%)
Day 241: Thou Shalt Not
Kill
(47%)
Day 240: Princess
Peach
(49%)
Past results:
https://board8.fandom.com/wiki/Fill_in_the_Blank_(Series%29
My response: Bombadil
Only the exceptions can be exceptional.