Lurker > TidusOfTheX

It's not as complicated as it looks

Blue mage seems frickin awesome(plus free lunch)

You devour enemies alive in FF8 for something else, so it can't be that bad to eat enemies to get your skills

Oh i see why, well, I was lower activity because I simply did not have much to say

Less activity doesn't necessarily translate to scum, I don't see how it could possibly be that way at all

MikeTavish posted...

That cat looks like Mafia to me.

well, it can't, because it is not in the game, and because it is headless

masterplum posted...

I know! Not an insult! But it does make me nervous leaving you in a final 5

Well, our goal is to get rid of potential mafia, not get rid of newbie towns, so it will do no good to lynch me if that is what you are trying to say

mafia will probably not get rid of me due to being a vanilla and being a newbie player that probably won't help that much though

masterplum posted...

I don't think you are very good at mafia

Well, this is my first game, so obviously i am not very good

TidusOfTheX posted...

It means there is pretty much no clear answer I can give that would make town want to lynch me less.

Forgot one part of this

MikeTavish posted...

Also, what does this mean?

It means there is pretty much no clear answer I can give that would make town lynch me less.

I'm back! I see not much happened
masterplum posted...

My biggest issue with killing mike is I don't trust Town Tidus in a 3v2 honestly

Why is that plum?

Ipad 1%
see ya

I just realized that my ipad probably did not charge last night, currently at 17%, I will not be able to charge it until about 3:00

saying this in advance just so that you know I may not be able to answer some questions later in the day

(went down to 15% just from typing this, WHY)

Crescent-Moon posted...

For the record, I think we have to lynch Mike here

I agree with this

##Vote: Mike

MikeTavish posted...

Explain why we shouldn't lynch you today, Tidus. Tell us what you think about everyone.

I can't answer that first part clearly without looking more sus, so let's just say... it's because other people are more sus and more likely to be scum

you look pretty sus right now, along with Isquen, Mzero playing his role well is a good point, but why the sudden switch from not playing his role well, to playing his role well? He is still on my sus list, but lower now. Crescent seems fine. I am still not sure about Red. Nothing changed with what I think of plum.

MikeTavish posted...

Scare was doing nothing and had hammered the day before. It's not impossible that the plan was for Mzero to bus him to look great but you're right, I just read back through Mzero's day 3 and I'm not ready to jump into that conspiracy just yet. I am also curious to see what Mzero does tonight so I'll give it another day and we'll see where we land tomorrow.

##Unvote
##Vote: Tidus

On to the next most likely scum IMO. Even when you give an opinion I feel like you hedge every single time with a "it's this or the complete opposite" type of comment to make sure you leave your options open and I think it's late enough in the game now where you should have a little conviction in your choices.

What's your reasoning for Plum being at the bottom of your sus list, Tidus? He hasn't claimed anything but Roleblocked multiple nights and hasn't really done anything worth noting. I need to read back on him myself tbh but maybe you can save me some time and explain why he's so townie to you.

didn't chris already almost clear him? It's just the last few posts that made me a bit sus of him

MikeTavish posted...

Very concerned by how split we are as a town right now.

Hey Tidus, you say one of Mzero and I are scum along with "probably Red or Isquen" yet your vote is on Isquen which makes it seem like you think he's the most likely scum. Is he the person you think is most likely to be scum right now, then?

That means you think he is a Godfather on top of Scare who was also capable of scanning innocent with his ability?

I forgot that my vote was still on isquen when we were discussing this, but yeah, still a potential godfather.

##Unvote

i don't know which of you two to vote yet, so leaving it unvoted for now

my order of susness, from highest to lowest:

1. Mzero and Mike
2. Isquen
3. Red
4. Plum

Also, could you potentially be winning with the mafia rather than the town? I guess that is what everyone thinks is the possibility, considering your transformation requires anti-town shenanigans

I know one of you is probably scum, Mike, you seem to be figuring out if you can NK Mzero or not, Mzero, you seem to not want to reveal more of your role

I don't think both of you are scum, the other is probably red or isquen, not sure about plum after his last few posts, he seemed fine until now though, so he is likely town, but the possibility arises

Along with Mike

Mzero just keeps on getting more sus.

masterplum posted...

Think about the optimal way to play this role as scum. You activate the faux janitor when you are the last scum left. You could have the result be a day where there are zero scum. You can't put a town in that situation where no matter who they lynch its a mislynch

If there are zero scum after using his ability, wouldn't the game be over?

MZero posted...

You're right

Mike is 3rd party

Turned town

masterplum posted...

##Vote:Isquen

Though decent chance scum knew mzeros role and red claimed his real flavor. I really think it's those 2

Yeah I'm thinking we should vote Isquen too. Like I said before, if Isquen is a town, and not a godfather, it is definitely one of those two, if not both. They look fine so far though.

You two seem fine, but if isquen is actually town, and not a godfather, then you two are the most likely suspects.

Boss fights don't generally have to be against bad guys. Mother porxie is proof of that right there

anyway, red is cleared, unless Mzero and him are teamed and trying to fake prove. Unlikely unless isquen is town(assuming a 3 mafia game)
when did you hint at impostor WoL Scare scan?

red13n posted...

Which should have been fairly obvious from most of these topics.

I kinda forgot you already played FFXIV, well, I guess everyone knows what it is now.

I am still sleepy after just waking up

red13n posted...

Also I don't know what the hell "tempering" does, but I feel fairly safe in assuming its not death.

In-game, tempering is when a Primal pretty much takes over the body of a mortal in order to have them pray for it so that it grows more powerful. The reason they do this is because the more it is prayed to, the more powerful it becomes. So no, tempering is not death.

MikeTavish posted...

Who do you think the remaining scum are and why, Tidus?

woke up to this question

I am less sus of red now, but he is still a potential scum, just general sus. I am thinking Isquen is a potential godfather due to his two claims and Mike's scan. Mzero is also one, but it's also a confirmed ability. We just don't know his alignment yet, and he is in no way a godfather(that seems OP as shit).

my sus list in order of sus to least sus

1. Isquen
2. Red
3. Mzero

There is a chance Mike is setting us up with faking aether scans and then saying dark aether on a town. I doubt it though.

Okay, probably red,(unless pure aether is not what we think it is)mzero might be bussing though, they voted immediately right at the start for seemingly no reason

red has not claimed yet

They get simply nothing, no cool abilities or anything

Crescent-Moon posted...

Also town vanilla is the best role in the game~

Why?

Crescent-Moon posted...

Maybe they should both claim?

Sure, I'll claim my boring role

I am a boring vanilla, Tataru

I would say either red or isquen are scum, it seems like it is a very low chance of neither

Isquen seems more sus

Mzero was y'shtola, the memeified catgirl

Probably WIFOM right here

It might be isquen wanting us to think that and therefore make us question why, or an attempt to make him look sus by someone else(probably red)

3/10 its just there just for you to have a reason for your adventure

I'm just putting my vote back, nothing's happening

##Vote: Scare

NO MORE POSTING

##unvote

I want more discussion without the risk of someone randomly voting

I don't like how isquen pretty much copied Chris's claim

Guys, hades is not town
just google "is emet selch hades?" Because i googled if hades was a good guy and it popped up in the people also ask section

nice try scare

No, only because I had no place in the conversation. I also had nothing to contribute.

Also, it was fine there with the hades part, I have no idea who hades was anyway

Zero doesn't seem that sus, scare really does though.

##Vote: Scare
Fastbreak posted...

Miz not Mike

Autocorrect

Who are you?

Endwalker

didn't play anything else

UltimaterializerX posted...

Oh I agree, but this is the main character were talking about here and I claimed it LONG before this dumb third party garbage happened.

You are saying you did not claim day 1, but now you aare saying you claimed long before, so which is it, because it wasn't very long before Mike started this whole mess on day 2

It's what ulti wants us to think.

MikeTavish posted...

Also @TidusOfTheX you didn't unvote me so your vote won't count.

Sorry

##Unvote
##Vote: Ulti(for real this time)

Less scum is better, even if it is only a chance

Okay then, after that, it seems it will be better to vote out ulti instead

##Vote: Ulti

for the entire town winning, if there are 3 mafia, like, does the amount of town stay the same or decrease if ulti dies? 6v3(9 left with 3 mafia 6 town no 3rd) or 5v3(9 left with 3 mafia 5 town and 1 3rd)?

Hey Ben, is Mike considered town for the victory condition if he survives today and becomes the new warrior of light?