Sure, just ignore a potential solution >_>;;
Still, my point was that it is not hard to think of potential ways things could still be permissible. All it would take to cement something as a thing would be to run it by the DM and get his approval. Sure, we would like it to make sense in the story, and it would be ana's task to make it able to happen. If there is a goal, there will be a path to that goal. Being overly negative about it does not further that.
It could even be that Quentyn will be chosen by Oa to become the new god of brothels in the future, but needs to have this demigod transitory period or something to prove his worth etc and could thus gain that ED and all it would entail.
No, it's our task. Because last time we left things up to Ana, we got the flash teleport mess. This isn't a knock against him, but rather that it's unfair to ask one person to think about how an entire world works. The responsibility should be shared. So yeah, expect me to be critical if something doesn't work. It's my job to make sure it all runs smoothly, just as much the DM's, and yours.
From: Sceptilesolar | #327
Or you could just say that since Quentyn was already like a prophet for Borden, that's kind of different from your 'I just met Edash this instant and am trying to save him'. The circumstances are more in favor for a lenient interpretation.
Alright, so explain to me how it works then. I'm curious.
--
Twostuck, Homestuck RPG: http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/63360266