LogFAQs > #983119431

DodogamaRayBrst posted...

I don't really enjoy that History Buffs guys's channel. The way he talks about the history strikes me as if he doesn't know that much about it, like he doubled checked something from a movie against wikipedia or a pop history book, saw it didn't fit and declared it history unbuffed or whatever he does. I think in the past I've also seen people who comment on history youtubers rate him very low. Like Extra Credits low, but I don't remember too much about that.

I've watched a couple of actual historians' take on Gladiator 2 that I enjoyed, though.

was he wrong about anything? how do you know he isn't an "actual historian"? what makes someone an "actual historian" to you? you just going on vibes, or what? i just don't understand this criticism.