LogFAQs > #910403751

CasanovaZelos posted...

RDR is in this weird position for me where I feel like I didn't adore it as much in the process of playing it, but I think about it in retrospect a lot more than a lot of other, similar games?

It probably is just what I said above, by the time I played RDR, no matter how great it was, I had the same type of experience many times before. So even if I can recognize it as one of the best open world games, that doesn't hit me as hard as something like Dark Souls which feels entirely fresh.

Same thing with FPS games when I look through that list for the 2000s. Halo 2 and 3 being there just feels excessive, even if they clearly were both huge and had a lot of impact on their own.

Halo 2 being on any top 100 list that isnt top 100 worst is certainly excessive.

Halo 2 is a bad game. Please understand, Im not saying Halo 2 wasnt a good game, nor am I saying Halo the series is bad. I am saying its an ACTUAL bad game. Not mediocre, not disappointing, bad. Combat Evolved is one of the best (maybe the best) FPS ever and 3 was a very very good game in its own right.

2 is shit.