Board 8 > Phoenix Wright Mafia Topic 10

(+) Yeah! (+)

MI isn't a cat
---

Comedy option: Nana is godfather

There goes my entire godfather read strategy!
---

Nanahara715 posted...

MI isn't a cat

This could actually be a valid argument if you took the analogy further
---

Might as well put my name down on something for the first time since day 1

##vote: foolmo
---

##unvote:
##vote: Foolmo
---

Interestingly enough I think that did give us some info
---

im doc tho
---

Stop
---

[6] Foolmo - (Corrik), NewDonker, (Nana), Nana, ColZach, (Corrik), MI, FD, Corrik
[1] MI - (Corrik), Foolmo
[1] FD - (Nana), Death
[0] No Lynch - (Foolmo)
[0] DYL - (MI), (Corrik)
[0] Corrik - (Foolmo)

Sorry I've been way busier than expected, so no flavor tonight.

Foolmo has been lynched. He was Lotta Hart, Town Watcher

Night actions to me by 10 PM EDT etc
---

I also need another replacement so PM me please if interested
---

Panthera has replaced Dark Young Link

Continue with sending night actions etc
---

VeryInsane posted...

Sorry I've been way busier than expected, so no flavor tonight.

wow
---

tag
---

With hammers being banned from the court, you think that the next judge would be a little less strict on objects, but nope, he really wanted there to be absolutely no cameras in the court house

"ARE Y'ALL CRAZY? I SPENT MY OL LIFETIME TAKING PICTURES FOR THE NEWS"

so the defense planned on using her as their major witness to shut down the case from the prosecution and send VI back home, but the lack of cameras and being able to take pictures made her a bit irritable. There also wasn't definite proof that it wasn't Very Insane who shot those people, as there was just some blobs out there doing the work. Seems like the case ended up being still open for any side!

Foolmo has been lynched. He was Lotta Hart, Town Watcher

Meanwhile, it also seems like the judge did not have a thing for whips either! Man, what is with all these Phoenix Wright characters all having so many gimmicks that are conveniently hated on by this new judge! It's almost like this entire match is rigged against poor Very Insane.

Shaduln has been killed. He was Franziska Von Karma, Town Tracker

And just like that, the defense went down from 21 at the start to 10 at the sixth day of the trial. No case in PW history has ever gone this long, but this is certainly no average case. Will VeryInsane just like, be able to go home at some point?

The Living

1. Arti
2. Corrik
3. Crescent-Moon/ShatteredElysium
4. Dark Young Link/Panthera
5. Forceful Dragon
6. htaeD
7. My Immortal
8. Nanahara713
9. NewDonker
10. Sceptilesolar/ColZach

The Dead
[LD1] profDeadpool - Kristoph Gavin, Mafia Roleblocker
[KN1] red13n/Leafeon13n - Phoenix Wright, Town Lawyer
[LD2] turbopuns2 - Matt Engarde, Mafia Kidnapper
[KN2] RogueNoble - Ema Skye, Town Vanilla
[LD3] DoomTheGyarados (Chris) - Manfred Von Karma, Mafia Bulletproof Ninja Vigilante
[KN3] eaedwards - Simon Blackquill, Town Roleblocker
[LD4] HanOfTheNekos - Garan Sigatar Khurain, Mafia Queen (Stronglady)
[KN4] ScareChan - Maya Fey, Town Spirit Medium
[MKN4] Alakazamtrainer - Trucy Wright, Town Magician (Doctor)
[LD5] Foolmo - Lotta Hart, Town Watcher
[KN5] Shaduln - Franziska Von Karma, Town Tracker

@Arti
@Corrik
@ShatteredElysium
@Panthera
@Forceful_Dragon
@htaeD
@My_Immortal
@Nanahara715
@NewDonker
@ColZach

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day ends at 11 PM EDT on Friday, June 8, 2018, or when a majority is reached

GOGOGOGO
---

Personally surprised that Foolmo flipped "watcher" as Town and not "shitty watcher."

If he had more information and just wasn't sharing it, then idk what to say.
---

Panthera scans inno.

So let's see

Scans inno:
Arti
Panthera
FD

Confirmed by scanners:
Corrik

Claimed power, not confirmed but I trust them:
Death
Nana

Remaining:
3. Crescent-Moon/ShatteredElysium
9. NewDonker
10. Sceptilesolar/ColZach

So from my perspective, we can lynch attempting to find the Godfather from the inno scans (I would pick FD from this group)

Or we could lynch from the remaining group to try to find the guilty scan (I would pick Donk)
---

Nanahara715 posted...

Personally surprised that Foolmo flipped "watcher" as Town and not "shitty watcher."

If he had more information and just wasn't sharing it, then idk what to say.

No. There is a reason for this. However, let MI "claim" his info first.
---

##vote: MI

See you day 7.
---

Oh hey I'm in this game now. Good evening.

I've caught up a decent bit on this game but a lot of was skimming, so I'd like to see some people give me the summary of what's going on. Some people like ColZach, Donker, SE, FD and Arti in particular.

So MI, you're an odd one to be alive right now, what do you think is up with that?
---

They had to kill a scanner and Corrik made it obvious he would spend all day trying to lynch me and save scum the action. Doesn't seem that odd.
---

I can't beleive f00l was town. I'm starting to doubt shitty town are scum tbh. FD's vote now makes me feel better about him in retrospect, because he was likely town trying to look good by getting a vote on "scum" that turned out to be town. But does MI really do this often as scum? I REALLY want to beleive MI is town, but I don't want to lose because of unwillingness to lynch scum that has contributed alot to town.
---

What FD vote are you referring to Donk?
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

Might as well put my name down on something for the first time since day 1

##vote: foolmo

---

Does someone have Shad's tracks readily available?
---

Did we seriously fucking lose all the topics?
---

Im having trouble believing MI bussed so thoroughly from day 1. The people being bussed did themselves no favors with their play but it's still an awful gamble. And to claim cop with the ridiculous counter claim potential...

Tracker, neutered watcher and cop i can still buy though. Odd one out is Death who i think actually targeted Corrik on night 2.

2 scum 8 town. Mislynch makes 2 vs 6 tomorrow and then 2vs4 the next.

That Makes today the correct day to NL.

Either scum kills the actual information role and tips their hand or scum kills a vanilla and the real info gets one more action in. It will be an even night so death will have to come up with something.

##Vote: No Lynch
---

My Immortal posted...

They had to kill a scanner and Corrik made it obvious he would spend all day trying to lynch me and save scum the action. Doesn't seem that odd.

Corrik's hate boner is one thing but a cop living extra nights is a lot more likely to blow up in scum's face than a tracker.

NewDonker posted...

FD's vote now makes me feel better about him in retrospect, because he was likely town trying to look good by getting a vote on "scum" that turned out to be town.

Why do you think a town player would be trying to look good as opposed to trying to lynch scum? Particularly with him making a point of how him taking a stand like that is something he hasn't done much this game (thanks to that little early hammer parade), doesn't that make you feel a little paranoid? "Hello fellow townies, of which I am one, allow me to make a very town vote that only town, like me, could make".
---

Log
FAQs

It's slow but it works

Shad tracked

N1: Red
N2: Han
N3: DYL
N4: Han
---

Nanahara715 posted...

Did we seriously fucking lose all the topics?

The logs still exist.
---

N4 is Nana, not Han again <_<
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

Im having trouble believing MI bussed so thoroughly from day 1. The people being bussed did themselves no favors with their play but it's still an awful gamble. And to claim cop with the ridiculous counter claim potential...

Tracker, neutered watcher and cop i can still buy though. Odd one out is Death who i think actually targeted Corrik on night 2.

2 scum 8 town. Mislynch makes 2 vs 6 tomorrow and then 2vs4 the next.

That Makes today the correct day to NL.

Either scum kills the actual information role and tips their hand or scum kills a vanilla and the real info gets one more action in. It will be an even night so death will have to come up with something.

##Vote: No Lynch

##Vote: FD

We aren't No Lynching. If we need to NL at some point, it's at 8 when it could be 5-3, but even then it's not optimal.
---

Panthera posted...

Corrik's hate boner is one thing but a cop living extra nights is a lot more likely to blow up in scum's face than a tracker.

This is true. I might not have scanned the GF yet and they could be trying to get that inno scan to further delude the waters? I don't know.
---

NL today leads to them killing a scanner and we are in no better position tomorrow compared to if we lynch a vanilla claim today and they kill a scanner.
---

The correct time to NL is when there are no scanners left and scum has to kill a potential mislynch target.
---

If you leave MI today, he magically comes in with a guilty scan tomorrow to try and convince you to mislynch and lose. You mislynch today, then lynch MI tomorrow. He has successfully put the last scum in a position to be gone.

If you lynch MI today, you either hit scum or confirm a bunch of town can't be the second scum.
---

You confirm no one by nislynching me because there is a godfather out there
---

My Immortal posted...

Log
FAQs

It's slow but it works

Shad tracked

N1: Red
N2: Han
N3: DYL
N4: Han

DYL is town OR GF, no other options.

If MI is town, then the moving scum is not Arti, FD, or Panthera.

Err I guess Panthera is DYL, so MI's scan last night is actually really fucking stupid of him and he should have scanned ColZach or Crescent's spot instead.

Rationale:

We know scum has another moving piece and targeted Corrik N2. Chris and Han were both killing powers and Corrik wasn't saved, meaning that another moving scum targeted Corrik. This is probably not the GF because the GF is probably claiming Vanilla here.

So the other scum moves and isn't GF. Since DYL didn't move on n3, he isn't the non-GF but moving scum, so he could only be GF.

So MIs scan tells us absolutely ducking nothing we werent already able to deduce from Shad's tracks. To be fair, MI [theoretically] didn't trust Shad, but in that case should have scanned Shad.
---

Really cant tell if MI played me all game or scum chose not to kill him for some odd reason

Yesterday Corrik convinced me that lynching MI after this made sense but why MI? Is there a particular reason why the attention was never on death?

Foolmos words make a lot more sense, is no lynch the way to go today???

Corrik posted...

If you leave MI today, he magically comes in with a guilty scan tomorrow to try and convince you to mislynch and lose.

Which would still just be 1 if 3 necessary mislynches at the coat of MIs life. I think that's still a winning play.
---

Nanahara715 posted...

Err I guess Panthera is DYL, so MI's scan last night is actually really f***ing stupid of him and he should have scanned ColZach or Crescent's spot instead.

Yeah I realized that when I pulled shad track. I was gonna scan crescents spot but then we had another replace and I went with them. :/

The no move scan didbt clear dyl but putting those together I doubt he's godfather
---

Tbqh if MI was Town and had scanned and he scanned either of Colzach or SE, we basically won the game (rather, would have caught the moving scum by POE). I'm actually really salty about this.
---

Actually, I'm ignoring Death, it's totally possible he's moving scum in this scenario as well. So, we wouldn't be fully solved.
---

You deserve to be salty. That was a fuck up by me. I'm salty at me.
---

Anyways im at my cousins hs graduation which is starting to call names now. Back later
---

Nanahara715 posted...

Actually, I'm ignoring Death, it's totally possible he's moving scum in this scenario as well. So, we wouldn't be fully solved.

Death will die tonight. MI will be here regardless tomorrow. Stop being scared.
---

ColZach posted...

Really cant tell if MI played me all game or scum chose not to kill him for some odd reason

Yesterday Corrik convinced me that lynching MI after this made sense but why MI? Is there a particular reason why the attention was never on death?

Foolmos words make a lot more sense, is no lynch the way to go today???

You replaced into this game a bit earlier than I did (you took over for Crescent, correct?), so you can tell me who the scum are, right? What's been going on in this game Zach?
---

Im lost on scum tbh. Corrik still seems like (bloodthirsty) town, I thought DYL was scummy but you scan inno according to MI and I feel like hes NOT scum.

This idea that it could be somewhere within FD/arti is becoming more reasonable to me given the options left

I think my gut is saying donk today but I want to iso donk and crescents slot tomorrow
---

Col took sceptiles slot who I feel pretty confident is town
---

Now my mind is going back to I thought one of dyl and fd had to be scum and dyl is more confirmed now so I should probably iso fd too.
---