Board 8 > [BOST] Best OST Contest 5 - Nomination and Support Thread
| Topic List | |
|---|---|
|
Zigzagoon 07/23/19 5:27:49 PM #152: |
I would probably considering supporting that Diamond and Pearl with 209 night instead of day.
 --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
| #153 | Post #153 was unavailable or deleted. |
|
MC_XD 07/23/19 6:27:00 PM #154: |
Based on feedback I have received, I've revised some things about Tangledeep. Changes are:
* Lost Relics of the Ancients, Bandit Boss Battle and Eternal Verdant Waltz, the old 4-6, have been dropped * Clash With a Mighty Foe has been moved from 3 to 4 * Mirai the Heroine has been moved from Alt to 6 * Land of Blooming Mushrooms, Exploring the Shifting Stones and Mysteries of Time have been added as the new 3, 5 and Alt respectively. Game: Tangledeep 1: The Final Battle -  2: Earthen Labyrinth -  3: Land of Blooming Mushrooms -  4: Clash With a Mighty Foe -  5: Exploring the Shifting Stones -  6: Mirai the Heroine -  Alt: Mysteries of Time -  --- aka DireKrow ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Hannyabal 07/23/19 6:27:02 PM #155: |
Took some input from the commenters - removed 3 of the vocal songs for 1 instrumental version and two non-vocal songs to add more variety. Not 100% sure on the ordering here and would like to fit Whims of Fate into the 6 but not sure how.
UPDATE: Persona 5 1: Rivers in the Desert -  2: Life Will Change (instrumental) -  3: Blooming Villain -  4: Last Surprise -  5: Keeper of Lust -  6: Beneath the Mask -  Alt: Whims of Fate -  ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Arti 07/23/19 6:35:27 PM #156: |
... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
MoonRunes 07/23/19 7:14:28 PM #157: |
saw the ff8 nom and i was like, oh shit another game is turning 20 this year!!
Nomination: Chrono Cross 1. Times Scar -  2. Dream of the Shore Bordering Another World -  3. Home Times Grasslands -  4. Dreamwatch of Time -  5. People Imprisoned by Destiny -  6. Drowning Valley -  Alt: Chronopolis -  lets see how this setup fairs ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
dowolf 07/23/19 7:33:17 PM #158: |
lack of radical dreamers and girl who stole the stars make me sad. Would prefer one or both of them over Grasslands or Drowning Valley. i'm also not a chronopolis fan but that one seems to be well-liked in discord so.
also would request that you call the fourth song "The Dream that Time Dreamed" --- Nonsense. "Testing" is for when you're still guessing--and now, I have no need to guess. -- Agatha, Girl Genius ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
azuarc 07/23/19 8:14:27 PM #159: |
MoonRunes posted...
saw the ff8 nom and i was like, oh shit another game is turning 20 this year!! Historically on the board, your 1, 2, and 4 are the strongest. In the original contest, CC was considered the de facto favorite simply because of how those songs crushed in the first VGMC and then the Tournament of Champions. The difficult part with CC is finding the tracks that complement them. Life:ADP is my personal favorite, but it's also the song that lost the contest for CC in that first year in a stunner against Shatter. (That started with one of the Dreamers and I forget what round 2 was.) --- Video Game Music Contest 13 winner: Ar Nosurge - CLASS::EXSPHERE_NOSURGE; ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
kaonashi1 07/23/19 8:21:02 PM #160: |
So Caravan Stories has eight soundtrack volumes. And you might be sitting there thinking 'wow that's a pretty huge soundtrack this side of Granado Espada'.
Game: Thousand Memories 1: The Duo of Wing and Star -  2: Theme of Lancelot -  3: Quest of Holy Grail -  4: Vertex Cradle -  5: Lord of the Returners -  6: A Little Witch Struggles -  Alt: A Sisters Story -  (quick note - this game was actually localized as Soul Linker, which apparently I didn't realize until just now) The third entry-- Quest of Holy Grail-- comes from volume 10. Ten! I guess we should be relieved the game didn't think it needed one track per memory. I didn't do the 'one track per volume' approach with this one, as I had a more specific list of tracks I really liked. Each volume does seem to have something of a theme to it, though. The entire soundtrack was composed by Keisuke Ito. This nomination is somewhat loosely constructed-- I haven't listened to the Thousand Memories volumes nearly as much as the Caravan Stories volumes. Different opinions on ordering and the like are welcome. Mycro was a contributor to this list, notably with the inclusion of Lord of the Returners. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
GameBopAdv 07/23/19 9:36:33 PM #161: |
Haven't had the best days these past couple of days but I'm getting this in before I lose nomination.
Apologies if I'm stepping on anyone's plans by nominating this, I'm open to suggestions & criticisms if you guys feel some ways about it Game: Super Paper Mario 1: Castle Bleck -  2: The Ultimate Show -  3: Brobot Battle -  4: Super Paper Mario (Title Screen) -  5: Floro Sapiens Caverns -  6: Pit of 100 Trials -  Alt: I'm Not Nice -  --- luigi says: "and" ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
pyresword 07/23/19 9:51:49 PM #162: |
Some other Super Paper Mario songs I really like: Lineland Road, It's Showtime, Birth of the Chaos Heart
I don't really have a sense for how strong any of the songs from this game are though, really. The top 3 of your list is probably the right top 3 but beyond that I'm lost lol. --- Oh woops. Putting Advokaiser in my sig like this until I think of something more clever ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
rwlh 07/23/19 9:58:22 PM #163: |
Done with Day 2.
SVs: Theresa Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles Acceleration of SUGURI 2 (I encourage you to change your alt song) Resident Evil 2 (I have a hunch your 4-6 would do much better than your 1-3) Sonic R On the fence, might come back to later: Spark the Electric Jester (said this already) Gurumin Persona 5 (havent listened to the new setlist yet) ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Place 07/23/19 9:59:21 PM #164: |
Game: VVVVVV
1. Potential for Anything 2. Piercing the Sky 3. Pressure Cooker 4. Positive Force 5. Pacing Energy (Max Confidence) 6. Predestined Fate Alt. Passion for Exploring Open to suggestions, and I'll add links in a bit. --- Hi. I wanna play you something. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
banshiryuu 07/23/19 9:59:37 PM #165: |
Day 3 has ended! If you did not nominate a game's OST for Day 3, you may still make it up during Day 4, which ends 24 hours after this post. Any makeups for Day 2 are now closed as well.
Game: Zakuzaku Actors 1: Battle of Marion -  2: Battle of Alleyoop -  3: Battle of Mao -  4: Glass -  5: Oriental Piano Attack -  6: Shell Pass ~Long Version~ -  Alt: Natureends -  mozzeeeellllllll ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
| #166 | Post #166 was unavailable or deleted. |
|
UF8 07/23/19 9:59:50 PM #167: |
Game: Radical Dreamers Nusumenai Houseki
1: Ending ~ Le Tresor Interdit -  2: The Girl Who Stole the Star -  3: Day of Summer -  4: Frozen Flame -  5: Snakebone Mansion -  6: Gale -  Alt: Far Promise ~ Dream Shore 1 -  No I totally didn't just do this because of what Dowolf said. Definitely not. Open to rotating anything in for 5 or lower if people feel strongly about any of the more atmospheric stuff, or indeed this nom at all. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Zigzagoon 07/23/19 9:59:57 PM #168: |
I really really like Champion of Destruction tho I'm not sure if adding it to the list would be enough to make me supp the nom anyways D:
--- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
PIayer_0 07/23/19 10:00:02 PM #169: |
Guess day 4 seems like a good time to post the other one!
Game: Etrian Odyssey IV 1. Battlefield - Storm -  2. Labyrinth V - City of Radiant Ruin -  4. Labyrinth IV - Library of Puppets -  3. Battlefield - The Fall of the Final Enemy -  5. Battlefield - Faith Is My Pillar -  6. Town - A Town Embraced by the Azure Sky -  Alt: Battlefield - With Eyes Blazing -  Previous versions of this list had: Misty Ravine, End of Raging Winds, Land Beyond the Clouds Support Votes: Drakengard 3 Persona 5 DEADBOLT --- -Abraham Lincoln ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
NFUN 07/23/19 10:00:02 PM #170: |
Game: Rhythm Thief and the Emperor's Treasure
1. Phantom R's Theme ||  2. The Real Chevalier Diabolique ||  3. Escape on a Glider ||  4. Escaping the Courtyard Garden ||  5. The Bond of a Parent and Child ||  6. Battle! Chevalier Diabolique ||  Alt. I Can Dance for You ||  --- Video Game Music Contest 14 winner: Terraria Calamity - Scourge of the Universe ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
MC_XD 07/23/19 10:00:42 PM #171: |
Game: Chrono Trigger
1: Chrono Trigger -  2: Corridors of Time -  3: World Revolution -  4: Battle With Magus -  5: Frog's Theme -  6: Wind Scene -  Alt: Undersea Palace -  HM: Boss Battle 1, Memories of Green, Schala's Theme... and the entire rest of the OST, really Open to negotiation if people want things changed or shuffled around, but people on the discord seemed pretty happy with this lineup. --- aka DireKrow ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Zigzagoon 07/23/19 10:00:42 PM #172: |
NFUN posted...
I'd have put Courtyard Garden higher, Ermine, but I don't like putting songs with the same motif in the same tier Fair --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Baconus_Yum 07/23/19 10:01:32 PM #173: |
Welcome to "Baconus' Biased Bonanza" where Baconus nominates a game that you have probably never heard of ever.
Game: Terratech 1. Safety Measures |  2. Large & in Charge |  3. Spoilers & Seatbelts |  4. Heavy Gauge |  5. Gun Running |  6. Twangs & Bangs |  Alt. Ordnance |  ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
UF8 07/23/19 10:06:15 PM #174: |
rwlh posted...
Acceleration of SUGURI 2 (I encourage you to change your alt song) For what it's worth, the other song I was going to swap in for the alt was this one.  I still might do it but I'm not sure. I'm also definitely not feeling inclined to bring back Remember Me or Accelerator over it. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Snake5555555555 07/23/19 10:08:09 PM #175: |
Support Vote:
Hollow Knight Unreal Tournament Rewrite rwlh posted... Resident Evil 2 (I have a hunch your 4-6 would do much better than your 1-3) I will definitely consider swapping the order, thanks for the feedback! --- I've decided to put my fears behind me. I'm not going back. https://i.imgtc.ws/2Q88rI4.gif - https://i.gifer.com/E07R.gif ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
rwlh 07/23/19 10:08:43 PM #176: |
Game: YU-NO: A Girl Who Chants Love at the Bound of This World
1: Activation -  2: Other World 1 -  3: Impatience -  4: YU-NO -  5: Fate -  6: Girl -  Alt: Elly -  Not too sold on Girl, open to other suggestions. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
pyresword 07/23/19 10:12:08 PM #177: |
Game: Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3
1. The Battle for Everyone's Souls -  2. Memories of You -  3. Heartful Cry -  4. Mass Destruction -  5. Wiping All Out -  6. Brand New Days -  Alt: Danger Zone -  Other considerations: Time, Soul Phrase, The Snow Queen, Living With Determination, Burn My Dread, Master of Shadow (I really don't want to include Master of Shadow but if there's enough demand I might) According to Deo mixing Portable and FES songs in with the base game is still okay. --- Oh woops. Putting Advokaiser in my sig like this until I think of something more clever ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
rwlh 07/23/19 10:12:38 PM #178: |
UF8 posted...
For what it's worth, the other song I was going to swap in for the alt was this one. I like that a lot better than what you had. For what it's worth, I really like Accelerator. (I used it in a guessing game!) Snake5555555555 posted... I will definitely consider swapping the order, thanks for the feedback! Sure thing! You and I seem to have a lot of taste overlap based on the VGMC compatibility sheet, and I liked pretty much everything in that set. But I think the appeal is broader for songs 4-6. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Janus5k 07/23/19 10:21:28 PM #179: |
re: FF8 - WOW I actually forgot Only a Plank Between One and Perdition, yeah I might use that and/or Force Your Way in the bottom two slots though I'd welcome more feedback.
re: TX - Seize the Day seems like a very polarizing song, and the long version would probably just amplify that. Might use that as the alt anyway though - I certainly prefer the long version. -- Alright, time to go back to my roots even more: Skies of Arcadia 1: Battle 1 -  2: Military Facility Dungeon -  3: Little Jack -  4: Last Battle ~ Opportunity -  5: Air Pirate Isle -  6: Delphinus -  Alt: Armada Battle -  HMs: Kingdom of Ixa'taka, Armada (would probably be an bad choice but I personally love it), probably others Honestly have no idea how to order these and I'm probably forgetting something oh no --- "Those who cast the vote decide nothing. Those who count the vote decide everything." ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
azuarc 07/23/19 10:27:00 PM #180: |
Place posted...
Game: VVVVVV Oh shit, I'm sorry. --- RIP Mithra (2010-2019) -- https://imgur.com/BPHmoKM ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
dowolf 07/23/19 10:33:47 PM #181: |
Nominate:
Game: Pharaoh Rebirth+ 1. Extra Stage: Las Vegas -  2. Stage 4: Luxor -  3. Prologue: Amshear -  4. Stage 5: Sinai Mines (Mine Cart Ride) -  5. Stage 7: Amarna -  6. Stage 2: Aswan High Dam -  alt. Stage 1: Temple Sect -  Honorable mention: the rest of the stages. also some boss stuff. willing to swap either of the last two tbh. also: yay i'm an influencer --- Nonsense. "Testing" is for when you're still guessing--and now, I have no need to guess. -- Agatha, Girl Genius ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
cakophon 07/23/19 10:36:01 PM #182: |
Game: Gravity Rush
1. Douse Shinundakura -  2. Bloody Claws -  3. Downtown -  4. Pleasure Quarter -  5. Discovery of Gravitation -  6. Ruined Paths -  Alt. Assault Cnida -  Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMWM_py_nlNFqzQRySyE420oKaTwtvOQp i miss the start of the day (3).jpg --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
UF8 07/23/19 10:56:00 PM #183: |
rwlh posted...
UF8 posted...For what it's worth, the other song I was going to swap in for the alt was this one. Hm. In that case... TIME FOR ANOTHER (more minor) Acceleration of SUGURI 2 REVISION Swap Alt: Nazca for Begins - Also Move Stratosphere (SUGURI the Best) back down to slot 6 (and move Shine up to 4 and Rendezvous (Realism) up to 5) I only put it up to 4 on a last-minute whim so yeah ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
banshiryuu 07/23/19 10:56:28 PM #184: |
Amongst the beginning flood of Day 4... I finally have Day 2 done lol. Fell a little behind yesterday, and had to get to the last few OSTs tonight. Some really, really good lists nominated during Day 2 so I don't feel so bad about tossing out quite a few supports already.
Supports: Theresa Gurumin Tangledeep Murasaki Tsurugi Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles Project S-11 Sonic R Einhander - The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky: Like the list a lot so far, but I think it could go a bit further. Wandering in the Darkness is pretty cool but it comes off as pretty weak to me, where similar feeling songs like Secret Green Passage give me stronger similar feelings. Grancel is pretty whatever; I heard some others mention Ancient Makes and Ancient Makes Me Crazy so there's that. I actually think Ruan as an alternate is a very nice fit tbh. Will likely support even without changes - Tokyo Xanadu eX+: Love it so far, but the order could be changed up a bit maybe? Song 2 and 3 are the weakest imo; Vesper Umber being song 6 of all things is kinda crazy lol. Supporting this for sure probably, but I wanna relisten to the OST and see if there's any other suggestions I can give. - Persona 5: Others have already weighed in but yeah, it really needs Blooming Villian lol. Layer Cake is a rather weak song compared to the likes of Days When Mother Was There, which is something that made me care more about the non-vocal P5 songs personally. WUGUGOT is good, but it's rather weak, especially for a goddamn 1 spot, so it can probably go to put Villian in the top 3. LWC should still be top 3 though, so... Rivers/LWC/Blooming - Surprise/Mask/Whims - Mother is what I'd go for. OH GEEZ THIS ONE GOT UPDATED TOO BEFORE I POST AAAAA okay this list is looking a lot better. just gotta ponder over it a tad bit more - Einhander: Already gave my blessing to the list, but I actually have one more question to pose! Would there be merit to using the in-game version of Shudder, which loops once and has no rap the second time around, leaving just the sick beat? I like it a lot lot lot because I like using it as a "sing it yourself" round lmfao even though I can't speak that fast half the time but regardless god this game absolutely owns thermosphere is one of my 10/10s just augh amazing ost Also from Day 1, still thinking a lot about the TCG games, Vision Soft Reset, FE Fates (hopefully @Team_Rocket_Elite saw my feedback ???), and the new and very improved Ys III list. ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Team Rocket Elite 07/23/19 10:58:14 PM #185: |
I saw the feedback. I'm going to make post with proposed changes soon.
--- Link isn't the only one who kicks ass. Congrats to Advokaiser for winning the CBX Guru Contest! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
NFUN 07/23/19 10:59:07 PM #186: |
strongly disagree with deo's trails suggestions
--- Video Game Music Contest 14 winner: Terraria Calamity - Scourge of the Universe ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Haste_2 07/23/19 11:00:14 PM #187: |
I will go and head change Route 209 to the night version, and I will note that NFUN does not want the legendary battles taken from the list, though I'm still open to opinions.
NEW SUPPORTS Rockman 4 Minus Infinity - rwlh, I think Toad Man should be at the top. I'm not really into Wily Capsule. LaTale - as soon as I saw SCDH, I got pretty excited! Remixing that is like cheating! Hey, cakophon, what happened to your vg ranking topic? Hoping nobody would notice? Hrhrhr. Prinny: Can I really be the Hero? Ys III: Wanderers of Ys s VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana Yeah, it's gonna take some take for me to catchup. --- Congrats to Advokaiser on pwning me in CBX! ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
banshiryuu 07/23/19 11:09:31 PM #188: |
Team Rocket Elite posted...
I saw the feedback. I'm going to make post with proposed changes soon. Cool cool, just makin' sure haha. Looking forward to it!! NFUN posted... strongly disagree with deo's trails suggestions ancient makes me cry ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
Zigzagoon 07/23/19 11:18:53 PM #189: |
Nominate: Pyre
1: In the Flame -  2: Grand Ceremony -  3: Forbidden Knowledge -  4: Bound Together -  5: Path to Glory -  6: Knights of the Sea -  Alt: Never to Return -  Dire and I put this together mostly. Pyre is good good! --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
pyresword 07/23/19 11:20:18 PM #190: |
Updates to my Trails in the Sky list from day 2:
1: Silver Will -  2: The Whereabouts of Light -  3: Hollow Light of the Sealed Land -  4: Sophisticated Fight -  5: Ancient Makes -  6: Wandering in the Darkness -  Alt: Royal Capital of Grancel -  Changes: --Seaport City Ruan removed from list --Ancient Makes added to list in position 5 --Wandering in the Darkness moved down to position 6 and Grancel moved to Alt --- Oh woops. Putting Advokaiser in my sig like this until I think of something more clever ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
banshiryuu 07/23/19 11:22:33 PM #191: |
Support:
The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
pyresword 07/23/19 11:29:05 PM #192: |
Supports:
Fire Emblem Fates Aurora Memoria - Philosophical Data Session: 2093 Prinny: Can I really be the Hero? LaTale Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana Rewrite Pokmon Trading Card Game Little Busters! Supports from day 1 now that I've finally finished listening. And also Little Busters because there is a 100% chance I support that. (A few others out there are near 100%, but I'll hold off on those) --- Oh woops. Putting Advokaiser in my sig like this until I think of something more clever ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
azuarc 07/24/19 12:14:27 AM #193: |
Support:
Granado Espada (everyone is SHOCKED, I know) Xenoblade Chronicles X Xenoblade Chronicles Final Fantasy VIII Bean Dreams Close to supporting: Koumajou Densetsu II: Stranger's Requiem Double Dragon Neon --- RIP Mithra (2010-2019) -- https://imgur.com/BPHmoKM ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
NFUN 07/24/19 12:42:16 AM #194: |
probably not gonna actually listen to stuff
sv: pokemon dppt trails in the sky vvvvvv --- Video Game Music Contest 14 winner: Terraria Calamity - Scourge of the Universe ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
FL81 07/24/19 12:57:24 AM #195: |
Game: Yu-Gi-Oh! Forbidden Memories
1: Seto Kaiba -  2: Final's Match -  3: Free Duel -  4: Sea Shrine -  5: Mage Duel -  6: Library Menu -  Alt: 3D Battle -  HMs to the other Shrine themes, this one was the hardest one to pick out a setlist for --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
| #196 | Post #196 was unavailable or deleted. |
|
FL81 07/24/19 1:41:03 AM #197: |
Support Vote:
Etrian Odyssey IV YU-NO --- ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
| #198 | Post #198 was unavailable or deleted. |
| #199 | Post #199 was unavailable or deleted. |
|
UF8 07/24/19 2:22:30 AM #200: |
About dpp since i have opinions on it too
I like the battle themes but i really don't think the set needs em for the most part Also while we're mentioning route themes, i feel a little responsible for accidentally making Route 216 more of a thing than it needs to be (it isn't even necessarily my favourite, it was just my favourite one that added up to 9 (2+1+6) in vgmc9 lol) but i still wanna motion to include it. Night > day Also would super like to see literally any of the major Platinum songs like giratina and battle frontier stuff. Also, postgame route themes, they're top tier. Also also galactic base. I like way too much of the dpp ost argh Also strongly seconding the suggestion to streamline the links for it because those are all over the place lol ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
|
banshiryuu 07/24/19 2:29:56 AM #201: |
giratina would make me CRAZY but I don't think it'd do that well. Frontier Brain, on the other hand, should definitely be a big consideration. I'm also not a fan of Champion at all, and while I wish I could find a way to drop it... Frontier Brain would almost make me think dropping it is not that bad.
Justice for Canalave City (Night) Justice for Champion Cynthia (the piano one ammmmmmmmmmm) Justice for uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh idk not dropping Mt. Coronet I like AMU and Cyrus a lot lot. Route 209 is definitely the strongest route. Dialga/Palkia is pretty meh but NFUN has already expressed that he really wants the legends Also, been getting a bit of lukewarm reception on Aruella/Qualia's inclusion for Blue Reflection, so I should ask if those two are holding back anyone on the list, or just if they're hindering the list in general at all? ... Copied to Clipboard!
|
| Topic List |
