Board 8 > MAD Mafia Topic 3 - Grr

(+) Yeah! (+)

Dumey has been killed! He was...

Dumey - TOWN MAD Day Vig

Doesnt it grind your gears when Scum tricks you all game in your Neighbor chat?

Take out your anger as a Day Vig. You have one shot. You may use it at any time during day by posting ##Dayvig: [playername]. This will cause a STOP (so make sure you spam it so other people stop!). After the flip of your target, day will continue as normal. You can NOT use your shot in the last 10 minutes of the day.

You win once all threats to TOWN have been dealt with.

Alive and Mad
1. Death
2. Lea
3. SBell
4. Wall
5. Ctes
6. Cody
7. Ulti
8. Crescent
9. Red
10. Abacus
11. Ben
Dead and Probably Also Mad
KD1 - Kirby - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - JC - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - Kanz - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - Peaf- TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - Scare - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KN1 - Dumey - TOWN MAD Day Vig

With 11 alive, it takes 6 votes to reach majority. Day will last 48 hours or until majority is reached. If no majority is reached, deadline is 8pm EST on Tuesday.

GO GO GO

All of the dreams are dead. I'm still my role, I didn't get a refilled vig shot, there's scum out there (unless host just RNG'd it) and worst of all I wasn't the one to get night killed

Was expecting this thread to be titled votes lead to suffering

With only a little over 1.5 topics to read through Im going to try to re-read tonight and see what stands out in light of Dumeys flip (rip Dumey)

Ben what do you mean unless host just RNGd it? I get the idea of using RNG to determine alignment and roles for a normal game (which I realize this game is somewhat atypical) but I seem to be missing your overall point

Crescent-Moon posted...

Ugh fine.

##Vote: No lynch

I better get my damn unicorns and rainbows tonight.

Curious what you thought last night when you made the decision to prolong this game!

wallmasterz posted...

Ben what do you mean unless host just RNGd it? I get the idea of using RNG to determine alignment and roles for a normal game (which I realize this game is somewhat atypical) but I seem to be missing your overall point

I was still joking that there's no scum team and maybe host killed a random person last night. But I do not think that's actually a possibility

Ah okay, thanks. I dont know Han well yet but him (or anyone) creating a game where were all town and hes the somewhat 4th wall breaking villain seems completely farfetched. But I suppose if this game gets down to the final few and no scum materializes, the last few survivors should try dayvigging our host and see if anything happens

Did anyone have anything weird happen last night, or was it just a normal kill? I did not turn into a Pokemon and that's sad.

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


He thought he was shooting scum.

He didn't expect 4 other vig shots to go off and kill 4 other town members.

Why the fuck would you no lynch in a game of all dayvigi.

Burn them all.

Sbell has died! He was...

SBell - SCUM MAD Day Vig

Arent you sick and tired of shooting someone N1 just to die from shooting them?

Take out your anger as a Day Vig. You have one shot. You may use it at any time during day by posting ##Dayvig: [playername]. This will cause a STOP (so make sure you spam it so other people stop!). After the flip of your target, day will continue as normal. You can NOT use your shot in the last 10 minutes of the day.

You win once SCUM is unable to be thwarted in their attempts at victory.

CHANGE PLACES!
1. Death
2. Lea
3. Wall
4. Ctes
5. Cody
6. Ulti
7. Crescent
8. Red
9. Abacus
10. Ben
A Tea Party for the Deceased... a MAD one.
KD1 - Kirby - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - JC - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - Kanz - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - Peaf- TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - Scare - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KN1 - Dumey - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD2 - Sbell - SCUM MAD Day Vig

Day continues, blah blah blah.

WELL WOULD YOU LOOK AT THAT

Now the voters for Nolynch yesterday suddenly look a lot worse now dont they?

Now if only I could be sure scumLea wouldnt sell out her own partner like this, but welp

Though I am gonna give her a decent townlean for that for now

[5]: No Lynch: Ulti, Sbell, Cody, Crescent, ctes
[4] SBell: Dumey, Abacus, wallz, Death
[2] Abacus: Lea, Ben
[1] Crescent: (Ben), Red, (Lea)
[0] Ben: (Ulti)
[0] Ulti: (death)
[0] Red: (Ben)

Might explain why they shot EDumey
That and EDumey hadnt shot yet

Abacus and Wallz looking better too now
Ben is alright since he didnt at least vote NL

Naturally if anyone shoots one of them right now, or me or Lea. Kill them immediately is my suggestion.

Okay I checked
Ben does look a little bad for calling Sbell town, but he still didnt vote NL and stuck to wanting a lynch so I cant say he tried to save Sbell either

Ulti gave Sbell a town soulread which is a convenient and lazy way for him to jump on the NL train, so I dont like that.

Cody I think can be excused for his NL vote since it reads to me like he was deluded into it by the vibe of the more experienced players.

Crescent explained some interest in a NL beforehand, but I would still like her to explain her stance on Sbell at that time.

And Ctes I just need to hear an explanation at all from why he arrived at his vote.

Yeah lol you and your soulread

I would be inclined to kill the C's.

Does that first sentence even need to be said, Ulti?

red13n posted...

I would be inclined to kill the C's.

You will need to be more specific

What explanation are you expecting? I mean, I had much earlier stated I thought SBell was most likely town for making a shot like that. So I was choosing between what I saw as likely town or NL.

I guess I should have listened to the suspicion I got when SBell "read" me as town. But yeah.

SBell made a post within the last minute desperately asking me for help too because he knew I had earlier said he was probably town. I guess SBell being right about someone based on nothing is a scum tell of his. It was the same thing with Sultan last time.

htaeD posted...

You will need to be more specific

Also this is obviously just referring to the three last people to vote NL.

I am a bit worried about clearing anyone on scum day 1 because I just had a game of everyone doing exactly that and almost only me speaking against it. At least saying Ben looks more alright for not voting for any two candidates out of principle but stating support for the one that basically was winning without him is BS.

htaeD posted...

Cody I think can be excused for his NL vote since it reads to me like he was deluded into it by the vibe of the more experienced players.

This is also really weak.

ctesjbuvf posted...

Also this is obviously just referring to the three last people to vote NL.

I mean yes probably, but I want to know if there's more reasoning behind that and why not include Ulti as well?

The rest of what you said was fair Ctes. That and timezones I guess
Though whats less fair is that you didnt seem to push anyone before that.

ctesjbuvf posted...

This is also really weak.

I am just telling it as I see it.
Though dont take that as more than a nultell then.

Timezones weren't actually an issue since it was Saturday and 1am. It's 2am from now on though.

It's true I didn't know where to push yesterday. I had tried to town read people more instead because of it. I am currently right on 2 and wrong on 1 based on flips so maybe just start from scratch again.

red13n posted...

I would be inclined to kill the C's.

At this point no one should be treated as town cleared by anyone and everyone who voted no lynch deserves a heightened amount of scrutiny. Can I ask why youre so convinced of ultis innocence that he is the only surviving no lynch voter who gets a pass when hes the one who started the damn no lynch?

Here are some recent highlights:

1.423: SBell shouldnt be lynched for that. Mistakes happen.

2.108: Yeah this game is clearly all town day vigs with maybe 1 scum member.

2.307: If the lynch is SBell vs Abacus then thats bad.

2.312: I think the best play is actually

xxVote: No Lynch

See if anyone dies tonight before making any decisions. I think the game is all day vigs and whoever is alive after everyone shoots, wins.

2.348: SBell is town. Soul read.


To be clear I dont think ulti is definitely scum, but this stuff needs to be called out and properly answered for beyond lol whoopsies, Im too nice and trusting a team player

What do you make of Ulti and SBell suggesting NL basically simultaneously?

It doesnt look great. Definitely not damning as an isolated occurrence imo, but deserves to be taken into consideration alongside everything else.

So does scum ulti claim very first thing? Looks like everyone may be day vig, so they would clearly know. Could just be trying to get ahead of the curve.

What also has me looking harder at ulti is the defense of SBell after the Kirby kill of "mistakes happen" which is true... But also, didn't try to pry into why all that much.

Only thing that gives me a bit of pause is does scum ulti pair that closely with another scum player? Not sure how Ulti usually plays.

Ctes, can you give a little more info about your thought process when you voted no lynch as the deciding vote? I think ulti, crescent and Cody all provided rationale (the validity of it, very much up for debate) but with you I believe the extent of what we know is you thought no lynch was better than lynching sbell. What brought you to that conclusion?

Oh yeah this is a thing. I forgot about it, then looked and only saw 13 posts, so I didn't bother, then I forgot about it again.

What was my read on SBell? Hell if I remember. The only thing that comes to mind is that the timing of his post after shooting Kirby was fairly iffy.

But really I was hoping I would be like, Espeon or something right now and have magical psychic kitty powers and that never happened.

Why did you do this to me Lea?

Crescent, you either missed or half answered a post from Ben (3.005) and Ive got the same question. Youve been very vocal about disliking this game and not having much fun, but you voted no lynch. I know Lea suggested the game may turn on its head and that didnt happen, but Im struggling to understand why a bored participant who finds this game meaningless and (almost certainly) has an unspent vig shot wouldnt just use it, advocate for a lynching etc.

Im open to hearing you out but it feels like your words arent really matching your actions

In other words I guess why are you bored and yet prolonging the game instead of being an agent of chaos

I think I am going to do something I may regret...

I am. I finished my ISO, and I will channel Lea.

Ctes has been shot!
He was...

Ctes - TOWN MAD Day Vig

Doesnt it frustrate you when you have a really good breadcrumb of your Jack role and nobody picks up on it?

Take out your anger as a Day Vig. You have one shot. You may use it at any time during day by posting ##Dayvig: [playername]. This will cause a STOP (so make sure you spam it so other people stop!). After the flip of your target, day will continue as normal. You can NOT use your shot in the last 10 minutes of the day.

You win once all threats to TOWN have been dealt with.

Alive
1. Death
2. Lea
3. Wall
4. Cody
5. Ulti
6. Crescent
7. Red
8. Abacus
9. Ben

Dead
KD1 - Kirby - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - JC - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - Kanz - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - Peaf- TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD1 - Scare - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KN1 - Dumey - TOWN MAD Day Vig
KD2 - Sbell - SCUM MAD Day Vig
KD2 - Ctes - TOWN MAD Day Vig

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to reach majority

CONTINUE

go

Whelp.

There was a ton of them and Sbell defending/clearing each other in the previous day. That combined with no lynch, figured I'd take the chance.