Board 8 > A Dance With Dragons Mafia - Topic 13: The North Remembers

(+) Yeah! (+)

Remembered (THE LIVING):
1) DoubleTangicide
2) dowolf
3) htaeD
4) IfGodCouldDie
5) masterplum
6) Meow1000
7) Neablis
8) ScareChan
9) Shaduln
10) Viserion

Forgotten (THE DECEASED):
LD1 - red: Varys, TARGARYEN Role Swapper
MKD1 - ben: Barristan Selmy, TARGARYEN Bulletproof Roleblocker
KN1 - Chris: Qyburn, TOWN Protector
KN1 - MI: Jon Snow, TOWN Warg
LD2 - Sheep: Arya Stark, TOWN Vanilla
MKD2 - Harris: Night King, TOWN Dead Empowerer
KD2 - ImGhostWoofWoof: Ghost, TOWN Direwolf
KN2 - Han: Three-Eyed Crow, TOWN Greenseer
LD3 - MZero: Wyman Manderly, TOWN Rolecop
KN3 - SBell: Melisandre, TOWN Jack of all Glamors

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch! Day ends at 10 PM CST tomorrow, slightly more than 24 hours from this post!
---

Meow1000 posted...

Hey Dowolf there's still like a 10% chance you're town are you going to lynch Scare tomorrow y/n

tbh you've given me no real reason not to lynch you.
---

also i will never forget ghost.

woof woof in wolf heaven, ghost.
---

ScareChan posted...

I have literally attacked someone for saying they were going to chic fil a on a Sunday

Dont even try and come at me blade lol

...What?

And people make fun of me for claiming a chair. And Tails Doll.
---

in my defense though i got scanned tails doll n1.

dammit tom.
---

not at 450 yet but I want this for everyone to see in this topic too

ScareChan posted...

Additionally, ben admitted to intentionally posting after when he knew deadline would be. I would like to genuinely thank him for his honesty. Unfortunately, this means he has been modkilled.

so scum knew that Red was going to vote right away

the only other people to post besides Ben and Red was Chris and Blade

If Blade were scum he should have been modkilled for the same reason that Ben was

Blade is 100% town and if he is not then this game doesnt even matter

---

Hey guys

Anyone around?

I just got caught up

I dont think Blade is scum
I dont know it scare is scum, but I dont think he is

##Vote: Death
---

I'm here ish
---

I am here too,

Havent caught up yet, but from what I can tell...nobody has claimed the shot on Puns?

Oh and Tange, boo
explain youself
---

also when did we learn that the deadplayer chat gets avote?
---

htaeD posted...

also when did we learn that the deadplayer chat gets avote?

...does no one read flips
---

ScareChan posted...

htaeD posted...

also when did we learn that the deadplayer chat gets avote?

...does no one read flips

figured it was one of those
but i forgot who it was
---

Well it was also covered

Pirate but no way his modkill rewards dead village
---

Will say I dont like people who dont read flips. Its scummy in nature
---

Hey I did read the flip, I just forgot that bit came from a flip.
(You keep saying I am scum without actually saying it)

You're probably right about Pirate though.
---

Shaduln posted...

But yeah, leaning more towards the Scare is scum side of this Scare/Blade fight.

Comedy option is both are scum.

Double comedy is both are town and we really are so fucked.

I dont think this is a comedy option that it is scum/scum. I think thats possible. The way blade disappeared then reappeared with fervor today makes me think its possible.

But I completely agree with your take that it looks like scare sees that his lynch isnt going to happen so he abandoned it, which is a total scum move at myfo (mifo? Been a while)

##vote:scare very confident again in this. Blade is so sure of this lynch he could be scum bussing, but even if that is true.... well, he still is giving us scum.

By the way I liked shads questions. Made me feel good about him. Scum might not pay attention to claims that closely. (Regarding my flavor)
---

At this point I am wary of any unified front, and not knowing who to trust.
Scum has potentially enough sway now to control town if they want, and of course they do want that.

Why does it have to be between Scare and Blade?
Why are we okay with IGCD still?
---

htaeD posted...

At this point I am wary of any unified front, and not knowing who to trust.
Scum has potentially enough sway now to control town if they want, and of course they do want that.

Why does it have to be between Scare and Blade?
Why are we okay with IGCD still?

Im not. IGCD is the only not scare lynch I would possibly consider today
---

I do like Scare less because I feel he could have at least said something, anything, about having commuted night2
---

htaeD posted...

At this point I am wary of any unified front, and not knowing who to trust.
Scum has potentially enough sway now to control town if they want, and of course they do want that.

Why does it have to be between Scare and Blade?
Why are we okay with IGCD still?

Considering we are likely mylo, depending on how viseron works, we are going to need a fairly general consensus.
---

which is kinda BS honestly.

Town shouldnt be at Lylo after 2 mislynches
---

don't really have time to fully catch up right now.

but showerthought was: if it is lurker scumteam, can we draw any conclusions?

would appreciate someone doing the research for me while I'm at work.
---

ScareChan posted...

not at 450 yet but I want this for everyone to see in this topic too

ScareChan posted...

Additionally, ben admitted to intentionally posting after when he knew deadline would be. I would like to genuinely thank him for his honesty. Unfortunately, this means he has been modkilled.

so scum knew that Red was going to vote right away

the only other people to post besides Ben and Red was Chris and Blade

If Blade were scum he should have been modkilled for the same reason that Ben was

Blade is 100% town and if he is not then this game doesnt even matter

This is factually incorrect for one reason.

My post was clearly meant to be the first post in the tiebreaker (Red just barely beat me to it). Ben waited until Chris was hammered to change his vote to Sheep.
---

By the way, town is incredibly weak for this to be a 6/18 with the two scum roles we've seen flip + a scum doublevoter.

So if this actually is Mylo then **** it.
---

I think scare has two votes currently correct?

It's why I lean towards buying Neablis btw. Town is weak enough even if he's telling the truth.
---

Meow1000 posted...

It's why I lean towards buying Neablis btw. Town is weak enough even if he's telling the truth.

This is why I have Scare over IGCD. I still think there is a chance he is town lying about something.
---

If IGCD is lying about something, now is the fucking time to tell it
---

I'm not though, believe me if I had something incriminating to give us to move us in a more solid direction I would. I don't even have a gambit to use because of volitile the situation we are in.
---

Ok, Im good with lynching god then
---

I refuse to believe in a game with this much thought and detail put into it, that penny is a ninja that gains powers.

If god isnt town lying, the only other possibility is he grabbed penny off the safe list and invented a claim without bothering to make the flavor work.

god, if this is real there has to be some flavor justification for this you havent shared right?
---

The flavor for Neablis doesnt match that well either. But IGCD's case is pretty egregious, even considering that.
---

masterplum posted...

I refuse to believe in a game with this much thought and detail put into it

I barely even have flavor text at all and gave no paraphrase because I didn't want to get MKed.

This might not be the best meta angle.
---

What was neablis character again?
---

masterplum posted...

I refuse to believe in a game with this much thought and detail put into it, that penny is a ninja that gains powers.

If god isnt town lying, the only other possibility is he grabbed penny off the safe list and invented a claim without bothering to make the flavor work.

god, if this is real there has to be some flavor justification for this you havent shared right?

The flavour justification is that in the game of thrones there are mighty players and players so insignificant there actions don't matter.
---

I think the real problem with this game is half the power centers around a graveyard chat which I'm betting saw some use but not a whole lot.This is why town is so weak as a result.
---

And let's be frank at it's most useful didn't justify three "power roles" revolving around it.
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

masterplum posted...

I refuse to believe in a game with this much thought and detail put into it, that penny is a ninja that gains powers.

If god isnt town lying, the only other possibility is he grabbed penny off the safe list and invented a claim without bothering to make the flavor work.

god, if this is real there has to be some flavor justification for this you havent shared right?

The flavour justification is that in the game of thrones there are mighty players and players so insignificant their actions don't matter.

---

Oh wait it's only 3 if Dowolf is town. I forgot one of the claims is alive"lol"
---

Hey Scare I just provided you with an opportunity to say I perspective slipped get to it and amuse me some more.
---

Though also with town being so hilariously weak it lends credence to Dowolf's claim too, somehow.

Literally a chair.
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

masterplum posted...

I refuse to believe in a game with this much thought and detail put into it, that penny is a ninja that gains powers.

If god isnt town lying, the only other possibility is he grabbed penny off the safe list and invented a claim without bothering to make the flavor work.

god, if this is real there has to be some flavor justification for this you havent shared right?

The flavour justification is that in the game of thrones there are mighty players and players so insignificant there actions don't matter.

So you are super insignificant..

And can become a ninja
---

Also wondering if being part poison doc was a red herring which technically made us even weaker aw yeah.
---

Meow1000 posted...

Also wondering if being part poison doc was a red herring which technically made us even weaker aw yeah.

Blade stealing my thoughts
---

By the way Plum, nothing to say about the hint I thought I saw?

Also yeah Scare backed off hard because it wasn't working and he's trying to feed Plum's "they're both scum" thoughts.
---

Blade being this mad (no offense of course) does seem like its coming from town
---

htaeD posted...

Blade being this mad (no offense of course) does seem like its coming from town

So is this where scum changes tactics to defending me and shooting me tonight
---

masterplum posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

masterplum posted...

I refuse to believe in a game with this much thought and detail put into it, that penny is a ninja that gains powers.

If god isnt town lying, the only other possibility is he grabbed penny off the safe list and invented a claim without bothering to make the flavor work.

god, if this is real there has to be some flavor justification for this you havent shared right?

The flavour justification is that in the game of thrones there are mighty players and players so insignificant there actions don't matter.

So you are super insignificant..

And can become a ninja

I feel like you are treating the role mechanics like they are inherently linked to the name of the role. There are no ninjas in Game of Thrones that I am aware of, if there are literal ninjas in the books that is news to me.
---

Meow1000 posted...

htaeD posted...

Blade being this mad (no offense of course) does seem like its coming from town

So is this where scum changes tactics to defending me and shooting me tonight

You gotta trust someone at some point
---

Meow1000 posted...

By the way Plum, nothing to say about the hint I thought I saw?

Also yeah Scare backed off hard because it wasn't working and he's trying to feed Plum's "they're both scum" thoughts.

Not really no
---