Board 8 > Percussion Mafia Topic 7

(+) Yeah! (+)

Happy Easter!

1. Scare
2. Panthera
3. Hb
4. Corrik
5. Lea
6. Tange
7. MZero
8. Death
9. Sultan
10. Uwnim
11. DamionDL
12. Crescent
13. DYL
14. BallaLeonHall
15. Masterplum

Happy Easter?
XD1 - Ben, Precariously-Held Crash Cymbals, MAFIA Hyper Bomb
XD1 - IGCD, Conch Shell, TOWN Taunter
LD1 - Puns, Art Blakey, MAFIA Messenger
LD2 - Red, An Actual Percussionist, TOWN Flavor Cop
KN2 - Chris, The Guy Who Shows Up Early To Help Set Up, TOWN Inventor

Votals
[2] Scare - Tange, Sultan
[1] Plum - Crescent
[1] DYL - Panth
[1] Panth - Corrik
[0] Hb - (Corrik), (MZero)
[0] Balla - (Lea), (DYL), (Scare)
[0] Tange - (Damion), (Scare)
[0] Lea - (Plum)

Day ends tonight at 9pm EDT. 8 votes to reach majority.

---

1. extuplet or Sixtuplet?

Corrik7 4/12/2020 10:18:13 AM
#451

1. Scare - Cop
2. Panthera - Drunk
3. Hb - Jack
4. Corrik - Minesweeper
5. Lea - Stump
6. Tange - Weak Detective
7. MZero - Deathproof 1 shot
8. Death - Noisemaker
9. Sultan - Tracker
10. Uwnim - Motion Detector
11. DamionDL - Vanilla
12. Lolo - ????? / Doesn't move
13. DYL - Night Talker
14. BallaLeonHall -
15. Masterplum - Motion Detector

Sleeping with the fishes
XD1 - Ben, Precariously-Held Crash Cymbals, MAFIA Hyper Bomb
XD1 - IGCD, Conch Shell, TOWN Taunter
LD1 - Puns, Art Blakey, MAFIA Messenger
LD2 - Red, An Actual Percussionist, TOWN Flavor Cop
KN2 - Chris, The Guy Who Shows Up Early To Help Set Up, TOWN Inventor

Figure we should keep that handy.

---

And it still has Lolo's name on it instead of mine~

---

Also that was quite the rebuttal from Plum.

---

I mean its simple. Sultan and Lea dont look good regardless of Panths alignment. They both went out of their way to avoid lynching scum day 1

---

You should be voting Panth.

---

Corrik7 posted...

You should be voting Panth.

Still dont think Puns begs to lynch his scummate

---

Interesting. I wonder if scum has a role to basically turn one of us into a hyper bomb (or just a regular bomb). This makes Chris' present make more sense

Amazingly, I don't think I've been voted yet this entire game!

I feel like I should have been told if I got bomb though

---

MZero11 posted...

Interesting. I wonder if scum has a role to basically turn one of us into a hyper bomb (or just a regular bomb). This makes Chris' present make more sense

Amazingly, I don't think I've been voted yet this entire game!

I feel like I should have been told if I got bomb though

I have theories.

---

Being able to turn someone into a hyper bomb would be... An interesting power.

---

##Unvote
##Vote:Mzero


---

I think this theory is silly and I dont want people not voting Mzero just because they think he might be a bomb

---

Hyper bomb would just be insane. Turning folks into regular bombs, much less so.

---

uwnim posted...

Hyper bomb would just be insane. Turning folks into regular bombs, much less so.

That's my thought on the matter, yes.

I don't think MZero claims "deathproof" as scum anyway.

---

Claiming to be deathproof while actually being a bomb would be the dirtiest trick in the book though.
---

Tag

---

As for what Corrik said about Panth. Didnt Panth say he would only target one player each night randomly?
Yet if he is a redirector, he'd had to target like up to 3 people night1?
His claim doesnt seem very helpful if he were to get caught on a night like that.

Of course, he could still be covering for any other scum night action, perhaps even just a standard old nightkill. Or he just wanted to invalidate the motion detector(s).

Also I may be misunderstanding the word Mine Sweeper, but you dont also remove the bombs: Corrik?
Bombs being in play does explain the bombproof gift from Chris and makes me feel slightly better about Lea or Mzero. (Not sure if both can exist at the same time still tho)
---

Scare wtf
---

htaeD posted...

Claiming to be deathproof while actually being a bomb would be the dirtiest trick in the book though.

Well, if we ever lynch him, we just have someone we think is scum hammer.

..And then MZero explodes, lives, and the scum who hammered him dies.

That would be amazing~

---

htaeD posted...

As for what Corrik said about Panth. Didnt Panth say he would only target one player each night randomly?
Yet if he is a redirector, he'd had to target like up to 3 people night1?
His claim doesnt seem very helpful if he were to get caught on a night like that.

Of course, he could still be covering for any other scum night action, perhaps even just a standard old nightkill. Or he just wanted to invalidate the motion detector(s).

Also I may be misunderstanding the word Mine Sweeper, but you dont also remove the bombs: Corrik?
Bombs being in play does explain the bombproof gift from Chris and makes me feel slightly better about Lea or Mzero. (Not sure if both can exist at the same time still tho)

A multi-target role's only concern right now is the claimed tracker, if the tracker is town, though.

---

Just let Lea do it for extra poetry.
---

htaeD posted...

Scare wtf

If he at least had a vote down it'd make more sense to me that he'd pop in out of nowhere just to tag a topic.

---

htaeD posted...

As for what Corrik said about Panth. Didnt Panth say he would only target one player each night randomly?
Yet if he is a redirector, he'd had to target like up to 3 people night1?
His claim doesnt seem very helpful if he were to get caught on a night like that.

Of course, he could still be covering for any other scum night action, perhaps even just a standard old nightkill. Or he just wanted to invalidate the motion detector(s).

Also I may be misunderstanding the word Mine Sweeper, but you dont also remove the bombs: Corrik?
Bombs being in play does explain the bombproof gift from Chris and makes me feel slightly better about Lea or Mzero. (Not sure if both can exist at the same time still tho)

No. I can only see if there is a bomb when I target someone.

I have so many theories regarding my role that go well into tinfoil.

---

It also explains the lack of roleblocks.

...
Did Balla even respond to the movement question btw?
---

Almost this entire game may as well be tinfoil at this point.

---

Corrik7 posted...

No. I can only see if there is a bomb when I target someone.

I have so many theories regarding my role that go well into tinfoil.

Sounds like a perfect role for you, heh.
---

htaeD posted...

It also explains the lack of roleblocks.

...
Did Balla even respond to the movement question btw?

Balla and Crescent are the only unclaimeds in the entire game tbqh.

Did anyone answer me if Mzero claimed before or after Tange?

The only thing that makes me think Mzero is a bomb just in role is that the likelihood of me finding someone with a bomb night 2 is pretty slim because if they had to place it I would guess they had to of placed it night 1 or night 2 for me to find it? Seems less likely but I guess possible. Unless scum got the same thought I did about Mzero possibly hinting to being a bomb defuser so they put the bomb specifically on him.

---

htaeD posted...

Scare wtf

What?

---

Fastbreak posted...

What?

youve been inactive for hours but make a point to tag this topic

clearly SKULKING

---

Tag is dumb but not scum tell

---

Fastbreak posted...

What?

You have no vote down and your last two posts are "Tag" and "What?". What do you want to do today?

---

Crescent, you asked me to lay out the case against scare. It is as follows:

1) he was extremely lazy day one and was asking me to do his work for him and was offended when I threw it back at him and said do your job
2) he unvoted puns at the last second on day 1 to create a tie. That could have led to someone that wasnt scum being lynched
3) his power claim came under extreme duress
4) hes claimed cop in a game that has a flavor cop (red) a detective (me), and an inventor that gives out cop scans (Chris)
5) when I attempted to visit him last night to scan him, my action failed. However, I was still able to use the scan Chris gave me to prove Balla is innocent. Therefore I wasnt roleblocked.
6) scare still hasnt done any semblance of scum hunting and has largely slunk into the shadows

---

Important thing is that the justification you gave for trying to be a background character was void the moment you claimed cop.

---

masterplum posted...

Tag is dumb but not scum tell

This feels like such an obvious thing to say at this point.
---

Let me try something...
Mzero, if you are a bomb, last chance to say so!
---

?

---

Just wanted to eliminate the slight chance that Mzero was hiding a bombrole because he thought he was being clever in some way.
I feel like scum getting two bombs is too much, so if Mzero was a bomb I would expect a townbomb sooner.
---

DoubleTangicide posted...

Crescent, you asked me to lay out the case against scare. It is as follows:

1) he was extremely lazy day one and was asking me to do his work for him and was offended when I threw it back at him and said do your job
2) he unvoted puns at the last second on day 1 to create a tie. That could have led to someone that wasnt scum being lynched
3) his power claim came under extreme duress
4) hes claimed cop in a game that has a flavor cop (red) a detective (me), and an inventor that gives out cop scans (Chris)
5) when I attempted to visit him last night to scan him, my action failed. However, I was still able to use the scan Chris gave me to prove Balla is innocent. Therefore I wasnt roleblocked.
6) scare still hasnt done any semblance of scum hunting and has largely slunk into the shadows

This is... Actually a really well done summation that I've been spending 10 minutes trying to think of a counterargument for without much of one.

The only thing I have is going against #3. He hinted scanning Damion way before he claimed cop, though Damion has done absolutely nothing since claiming vanilla.

---

That definitely is the weakest argument of them all, to be honest, but in context of everything else, I felt it was worth bringing up

---

Deja vu.
(I also said point 3 was not that strong, but moreso because a cop claim would not come that easily if you only had 1 townscan so far)
---

Panth lynch makes the most sense because all you guys care about solving is night actions

But as much as I liked 5star plum lynch list involved lea and balla who both have inno scans and we are not at a godfather hunting stage

Damion, let, balla all have inno scans and I am lumping tange there too. He could have sat on it being cow bell as scum.

Thats 4 people you don't lynch until there's only gf left

---

the motion dectors are not that big of a deal to me and more of a distraction to the game if anything

If that is your main concern though, corrik is right you have to lynch panth. He was scummy day 1 as it was, there is still scum equity there anyway so its a good lynch.

If you don't care about that you should lynch plum who wants to lynch 2/3 of inno scans today

The big brain play is lynch corrik because he hasn't exactly been getting any results, he has caused more confusion in trying to lead, he has been open to lynchinh the cop (biased here what can I say) and Red insisted that if Chris was town that corrik had to go. I haven't harperd on this because last time I listened to dead red it didn't work out well, but corrik coming up with bomb detector after everyone else has claimed seems sketchy to me

---

It is true scum likes to wait til as late as possible to claim...

*Looks at the 2 who still haven't claimed*


---

Gee I wonder if 1, 2, 3 and 4 are because I'm the funding cop and 6 is because I'm tired of slamming my head into a wall talking to you

5 sure, go nuts, I have no idea why

---

So, scare you think I am scum then?

---

If tange is tiring, just pretend he doesn't exist for a bit while you go look for the words that show people are scum. Tange alone couldn't lynch you no matter how much he might want to and showing the rest of us that you want to try to figure things out would go a long way towards making sure we don't start listening to him.

Corrik being confusing and doing whatever the hell he wants is how I remember him from back when I used to play.

---

Corrik7 posted...

It is true scum likes to wait til as late as possible to claim...

*Looks at the 2 who still haven't claimed*

I've already said my power is confirmable. I've been pondering on it and just don't see a need to claim it yet. I don't see what there is to gain.

The moment I saw this role I immediately thought confirmable town, so I feel like it's better to let scum stew on it and shoot me if they want to.

---

uwnim posted...

Corrik being confusing and doing whatever the hell he wants is how I remember him from back when I used to play.

This sums up Corrik pretty well most of the time.

---

Corrik7 posted...

So, scare you think I am scum then?

Its crossed my mind

---

Fastbreak posted...

Its crossed my mind

Do you have an argument besides I claimed late when a detective is in the game?


---