Would you rather have been raised in a sheltered utopia, or a gritty ghetto?

Poll of the Day

Poll of the Day » Would you rather have been raised in a sheltered utopia, or a gritty ghetto?
Which would you rather have been raised in?


The utopia would produce happy, innocent people who were probably rich.

The ghetto would produce tough, rugged people who were probably not as rich.
given that just about every conception of a sheltered utopia involves the removal of basic human rights and freedom, anyone who votes for the utopia is stupid
I forgot to mention that people raised in the ghetto would probably have better social skills.
berniepanders posted...
given that just about every conception of a sheltered utopia involves the removal of basic human rights and freedom, anyone who votes for the utopia is stupid


Uh, by definition, a utopia is perfect. I think you're mistaking utopias with dystopias.
If you want to make the world a better place
Take a look at yourself, and then make a change
minervo posted...
I forgot to mention that people raised in the ghetto would probably have better social skills.


i mean when you're adult do you leave said environment? because better social skills wouldn't really matter if everyone in your utopia has the same social skills.
http://i.imgur.com/4ihiyS2.jpg
"I am not gay! Can't you get that through your head? I am very much aroused at the site of a naked woman!" - Dan0429
Jen0125 posted...
minervo posted...
I forgot to mention that people raised in the ghetto would probably have better social skills.


i mean when you're adult do you leave said environment? because better social skills wouldn't really matter if everyone in your utopia has the same social skills.


Yep, as soon as you reach adulthood you leave the environment and have to make it on your own.
minervo posted...
Yep, as soon as you reach adulthood you leave the environment and have to make it on your own.


so how is there anyone in either environment if there's no adults there to have families and continue populating the areas?
http://i.imgur.com/4ihiyS2.jpg
"I am not gay! Can't you get that through your head? I am very much aroused at the site of a naked woman!" - Dan0429
PMarth2002 posted...
berniepanders posted...
given that just about every conception of a sheltered utopia involves the removal of basic human rights and freedom, anyone who votes for the utopia is stupid


Uh, by definition, a utopia is perfect. I think you're mistaking utopias with dystopias.

you're making the mistake of there being any difference between the two
PMarth2002 posted...
Uh, by definition, a utopia is perfect. I think you're mistaking utopias with dystopias.


Isn't "sheltered" usually seen as a negative trait though? How can it be perfect if some damaging negativity comes with it?
Jen0125 posted...
minervo posted...
Yep, as soon as you reach adulthood you leave the environment and have to make it on your own.


so how is there anyone in either environment if there's no adults there to have families and continue populating the areas?


I made this topic to find out which environment people think would produce a better person. So lets just assume that you're the only one who has to leave, for some applicable reason.
minervo posted...
I made this topic to find out which environment people think would produce a better person.


but you only asked which we'd rather be raised in. not which we felt would produce "better people."
http://i.imgur.com/4ihiyS2.jpg
"I am not gay! Can't you get that through your head? I am very much aroused at the site of a naked woman!" - Dan0429
Jen0125 posted...
minervo posted...
I made this topic to find out which environment people think would produce a better person.


but you only asked which we'd rather be raised in. not which we felt would produce "better people."


Well most people would rather be a better person, right?
I want to be better at being the worst person
http://i.imgur.com/M489ly5.jpg
the White-Sounding Black Chick
minervo posted...
Well most people would rather be a better person, right?


idk i think you messed up with your topic. sorry bro.
http://i.imgur.com/4ihiyS2.jpg
"I am not gay! Can't you get that through your head? I am very much aroused at the site of a naked woman!" - Dan0429
It makes sense to me, i stand behind my topic.
EightySeven posted...
Isn't "sheltered" usually seen as a negative trait though? How can it be perfect if some damaging negativity comes with it?

Fair point, but being sheltered is still a long way from claiming utopia is the same thing as a dystopia. Personally, I would say sheltered, but otherwise perfect is a lot better than the total removal of human rights and freedom like bernie was saying.

berniepanders posted...
you're making the mistake of there being any difference between the two


There is. They're literally opposites. A lot of dystopias in fiction masquerade as utopias, but that doesn't mean they're the same thing.
If you want to make the world a better place
Take a look at yourself, and then make a change
PMarth2002 posted...
There is. They're literally opposites.

nope, there isn't, they're literally not.

the concept of a dystopia is merely an honest look at what a utopian society would require. they are one and the same. the only difference is whether you're looking at one through rose-colored glasses or not.
Sheltered utopia.

There must be a lot of flexibility to the term "sheltered" for it to be a utopia, which makes it an easy pick.
A plethora of DKC-related fanart to numb your mind:
http://kjsteroids.deviantart.com
Ghetto

What are the specific perks of the utopia?
What are the cons?
Mains: Xiaoyu/Zafina (Tekken)-Dhalsim (SF)-Jax (MK)
Luong/Yamazaki/Joe (KoF)
Utopia.
Donald J. Trump--proof against government intelligence.
Poll of the Day » Would you rather have been raised in a sheltered utopia, or a gritty ghetto?