What's a good controller for PC?

I've been using a Switch Pro Controller generally, but the left stick is having issues because the plastic of the joystick erodes and gets stuck under the joystick as dust. I'm looking at an Xbox One controller, but the price seems a bit steep. I've used third party controllers from Gamestop before, but the face buttons got stuck after a year.

Basically I've narrowed it down to either a 360 controller or Xbone, but I'll hear out any other suggestions.