Considering the circumstances, I dont fault you for drawing that line of logic.
For gifts you have to consider other variables other than: if A and B are in the category of liked thing then AB will be a good gift
You should try to consider outside factors. Like yeah she likes Pixar and video games but a game with Pixar may be created for little kids in mind. Or may not be high quality. Etc.
You haven't set a signature for the message boards yet