Suppose I wanted to finally get into the Shin Megami Tensei/Persona series

Board 8

Board 8 » Suppose I wanted to finally get into the Shin Megami Tensei/Persona series
Nelson_Mandela
01/02/2018
09:17 PM
#1
Best order to play the games





View Results
As someone who enjoys going all-in on canon, what would be the best way to play through the series?

I know next to nothing about the lore, but is there one game that really is required playing to fully enjoy the others?
"Seph's kind of right."~ Jakyl25
"Sephy's point is right."~ Inviso
LeonhartFour
01/02/2018
09:19 PM
#2
Persona and SMT aren't related in terms of plot/canon, so you don't necessarily have to play both.
http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/080/145/638.png
https://imgur.com/hWiEG77
Nelson_Mandela
01/02/2018
09:20 PM
#3
LeonhartFour posted...
Persona and SMT aren't related in terms of plot/canon, so you don't necessarily have to play both.

Then how are they related? And how is MT related to SMT? Wikipedia is too confusing
"Seph's kind of right."~ Jakyl25
"Sephy's point is right."~ Inviso
LeonhartFour
01/02/2018
09:23 PM
#4
They originally stuck the Shin Megami Tensei title on Persona for the English releases just to attach it to an already established series in hopes it would help it sell

now that Persona is way more popular than SMT for English audiences they don't do that anymore

I don't know much of anything about SMT so I can't help you there, but I think they share a lot of the same lore in terms of the types of demons and other spirit beings that are in each series
http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/080/145/638.png
https://imgur.com/hWiEG77
Nelson_Mandela
01/02/2018
09:26 PM
#5
I was under the impression that Persona takes place in post apocalyptic Tokyo and SMT is the story of the apocalypse. Hopefully that's not a spoiler?
"Seph's kind of right."~ Jakyl25
"Sephy's point is right."~ Inviso
LeonhartFour
01/02/2018
09:28 PM
#6
beats me

I just know you can hop right into Persona 3 and be perfectly fine
http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/080/145/638.png
https://imgur.com/hWiEG77
Nelson_Mandela
01/02/2018
09:28 PM
#7
LeonhartFour posted...
beats me

I just know you can hop right into Persona 3 and be perfectly fine

Have you played the first 2?
"Seph's kind of right."~ Jakyl25
"Sephy's point is right."~ Inviso
LeonhartFour
01/02/2018
09:29 PM
#8
I have not.
http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/080/145/638.png
https://imgur.com/hWiEG77
Peace___Frog
01/02/2018
09:29 PM
#9
Persona games all have different settings and have some references to one another but aren't related plotwise. I haven't ever played smt, but i believe they're similar to the persona games without the non-battling parts (so basically just full on dungeon crawler).

I tried p1 after playing p3, before p4 came out.
It hasn't aged well at all. They had some interesting ideas there, but there's a reason that it was p5 that made the series explode in popularity.
~Peaf~
JeffreyRaze
01/02/2018
09:30 PM
#10
Persona is a bunch of high-school students, so...

Persona games are social sims with JRPG combat, the SMT games are straight JRPGs but often with unusual turn mechanics, and then there's stuff like the Devil Survivor stuff which is an SRPG. For the most part, each game is unconnected plotwise to the other games, but they often share similar themes and there's a lot of demons that show up in a lot of games.
JeffRaze , for all your random spellcasting needs
Xiahou Shake
01/02/2018
09:36 PM
#11
Nelson_Mandela posted...
I was under the impression that Persona takes place in post apocalyptic Tokyo and SMT is the story of the apocalypse. Hopefully that's not a spoiler?

This isn't the case, the games are completely separate from one another. The Persona games take place in a modern, (mostly) normal society. SMT games usually have apocalyptic themes, though.

Personally I'd say 3 is harder to go back to after playing 4 and especially 5, but it's still a great game so start there. Then you can play 4 afterward and if you really like both maybe check out Nocturne (SMT3) as a break before playing P5.
Let the voice of love take you higher,
With this gathering power, go beyond even time!
HeroDelTiempo17
01/02/2018
11:15 PM
#12
Nelson_Mandela posted...
LeonhartFour posted...
Persona and SMT aren't related in terms of plot/canon, so you don't necessarily have to play both.

Then how are they related? And how is MT related to SMT? Wikipedia is too confusing


Shin Megami Tensei is the "main series" of JRPGs. They're like the numbered Final Fantasy games.
Megami Tensei is the name of the overall franchise in Japan. This includes games such as Persona, Devil Summoner, and Devil Survivor, which are ostensibly spinoffs of SMT, despite not saying "Megami Tensei" on the box anymore. Except in America, they just translated all the various prefixes of "Megami x" as "Shin Megami Tensei" so it's used in the west to refer to the franchise by most people, in addition to MT/MegaTen. This leads to people thinking Persona isn't part of the franchise, as you see in this topic! Fun and not confusing!

Good entry points for MegaTen are:
- SMT3: Nocturne
- SMTIV
- Any Persona past 3
- Devil Survivor (Overclocked) if you like SRPGs
- Digital Devil Saga if you want something much more like a traditional JRPG (no monster recruitment)
DPOblivion was far more determined than me.
ninkendo
01/02/2018
11:18 PM
#13
start with SMT don't do MT
http://i.imgur.com/LhGP5E6.gif
https://card.psnprofiles.com/2/CaptainRockman.png
HeroDelTiempo17
01/02/2018
11:18 PM
#14
Oh and since you mention liking going all-in on canon. There is a very loosely established multiverse and most of the games can technically be connected to each other, though it mostly amounts to minor plot elements connecting random games. If you want to go that route then you do want to play the SNES ones at some point, but starting with those will probably just make you hate everything.

and yeah ignore the actual Megami Tensei games
DPOblivion was far more determined than me.
Nelson_Mandela
01/03/2018
05:21 PM
#15
Thanks bros. Expected more debate.
"Seph's kind of right."~ Jakyl25
"Sephy's point is right."~ Inviso
tcaz2
01/03/2018
07:29 PM
#16
The only games that are connected are the Persona games really

But even then they're not like, plot connected, its just references to previous games/character cameos and stuff that makes you go "oooh that's what that character is up to now!" and never ties into anything going on in the game you're playing.

SMT games are, as said, all basically in different worlds in a multiverse and don't really relate at all. There are a few exceptions here and there but even for those they don't really require you to play any other games.
Nelson_Mandela
01/03/2018
08:10 PM
#17
Where the hell am I getting that apocalypse thing from?
"Seph's kind of right."~ Jakyl25
"Sephy's point is right."~ Inviso
foolm0r0n
01/03/2018
08:12 PM
#18
SMT is like Law and Order Criminal Intent and Persona is like Law and Order SVU
_foolmo_
2 + 2 = 4
LapisLazuli
01/03/2018
08:15 PM
#19
Nelson_Mandela posted...
Where the hell am I getting that apocalypse thing from?


Almost all the ACTUAL SMT games are post apocalypse.

Putting SMT in front of Persona is like how they changed a couple of the old Square RPGs to have Final Fantasy in the name in the US.
"I think Cuphead should be higher." - Abby from Brooklyn
Strife2
01/03/2018
08:15 PM
#20
Apocalypse was the sequel to IV.
"Evening caress, Always yearning, I must confess, The stars aren't burning"
Copernicus - Candlemass
Nelson_Mandela
01/03/2018
08:15 PM
#21
foolm0r0n posted...
SMT is like Law and Order Criminal Intent and Persona is like Law and Order SVU

This explains everything
"Seph's kind of right."~ Jakyl25
"Sephy's point is right."~ Inviso
LapisLazuli
01/03/2018
08:19 PM
#22
Also the only actually conundrum here is P3 vs P4 to start. Playing P3 after P4 would be...rough. Mechanically it's an enormous downgrade. People who played P3 before and got invested in the story would cry foul at the idea, but I know people who have bounced off of Persona entirely because of how...unfriendly P3 is to it's players.

That said, P3 has a great story, so it's not like it's a bad game that you should skip. You just have to be aware you're going into a game that is 90% different colored randomly generated dungeons with mechanics forcing you to do sections over multiple days rather than tackling it all at once. It can be frustrating. I never finished and I can never go back.
"I think Cuphead should be higher." - Abby from Brooklyn
Strife2
01/03/2018
08:25 PM
#23
SMT as a whole tends to veer towards dystopia, depressing, and cataclysmic events. Persona (3 to a lesser extent), has a lot more whimsy and slice of life moments of fun. SMT also has a more straightforward RPG/dungeon crawl situation going. Persona does for the first 2, but it got popular following the "daily life/dating simulator" starting with 3.

I wouldn't say Persona is all that hard of a franchise...but it can be cheap as shit. The mobile games and 5 tend to break the difficulty into pieces due to some design choices with the support characters.

I won't say each game in the franchises are good (cause P1 and P2 have some REALLY slow ass battles in the remakes). I think stick with SMT if you want more gameplay, difficulty, and threatening/horror vibes. Persona is great for characters and their daily struggles.

For the spinoffs, Devil Survivor is one of the few SRPG games I liked, and PQ was a good dungeon crawl with a distinctly different flavor (basically a different game franchise with Persona characters instead).
"Evening caress, Always yearning, I must confess, The stars aren't burning"
Copernicus - Candlemass
Strife2
01/03/2018
08:40 PM
#24
Also, playing P3, P4, or P5 first really depends on your thought process.

P3

- "Older" characters (they do not act like teenagers)
- Setting is more urban (in line with the typical SMT environments)
- Main character can change weapon types (swords, bows, clubs, spears, boxing gloves)
- Story is tragic/more mature/darker in tone (thought SMT bends way further)
- AI-controlled allies can be a pain, but I appreciate it as a change of pace
- Great/Good/Tired/Sick mechanics (extra status based on daily choices/battle; adds to realism)
- one main (procedural-generated) dungeon
- Better at "pacing" than P4 and P5 (this game kinda runs in a symmetrical pattern)

P4

- Better party/characters (they feel like a group, and act like a group...but are total morons)
- several themed dungeons (still weak in the actual style department)
- Better gameplay than P3 (full party control/better at describing skills/S. Link abilities affect battles)
- Funny as shit (so many great moments)
- Story slows down about halfway, going into filler for a "month," before picking back up

P5

- A mix of P3's tragic and P4's comedic tones
- GREAT soundtrack (not saying the others are bad...this is just REALLY good)
- Amazing style
- Best dungeon design (because they were themed rather than randomly generated)
- Characters suffer (less world building - a lot of the game is done via text)
- Same pacing problems as P4 (Here's a major plot point. No fun time for you. Go to bed loser)

I like P3 for the darker tone and story moments, P4 for characters, cutscenes, and comedy, and P5 is just dripping in style, music, dungeon design, and ambience.
"Evening caress, Always yearning, I must confess, The stars aren't burning"
Copernicus - Candlemass
HeroDelTiempo17
01/03/2018
08:52 PM
#25
Strife2 posted...
PQ was a good dungeon crawl with a distinctly different flavor (basically a different game franchise with Persona characters instead).


Strange Journey is much better if you want a dungeon-crawler. PQ is fine but it's too much of an "easy" Etrian Odyssey game with Persona fanservice. And SJ is getting a 3DS remake soon too!
DPOblivion was far more determined than me.
GranzonEx
01/03/2018
08:58 PM
#26
P3 is brutal if you've only play stuff like Final Fantasy

Persona games also have a lot of missable stuff so if you're OCD about getting EVERYTHING in a playthrough then you need a guide to plan your days
2 line break(s), 160 characters allowed
Strife2
01/03/2018
09:00 PM
#27
HeroDelTiempo17 posted...
Strife2 posted...
PQ was a good dungeon crawl with a distinctly different flavor (basically a different game franchise with Persona characters instead).


Strange Journey is much better if you want a dungeon-crawler. PQ is fine but it's too much of an "easy" Etrian Odyssey game with Persona fanservice. And SJ is getting a 3DS remake soon too!


But that fanservice is great...for one dungeon anyway. It's too bad most of the other dungeons are terrible. Dungeon 3 can fuck off.
"Evening caress, Always yearning, I must confess, The stars aren't burning"
Copernicus - Candlemass
colliding
01/03/2018
09:35 PM
#28
If you start with P3, I suggest starting with P3P. You have greater control over battles and it's overall a pretty swell interface.
Nelson_Mandela
01/03/2018
09:36 PM
#29
colliding posted...
If you start with P3, I suggest starting with P3P. You have greater control over battles and it's overall a pretty swell interface.

Yeah I think this was the consensus I've heard over the years. This version includes the epilogue or whatever too right?
"Seph's kind of right."~ Jakyl25
"Sephy's point is right."~ Inviso
Mobilezoid
01/03/2018
09:47 PM
#30
Nelson_Mandela posted...
This version includes the epilogue or whatever too right?

You probably mean P3: The Answer and no, P3P doesn't include that, but you can easily watch the cutscenes on YouTube and from what I've heard about the gameplay that's a superior experience than playing it
**R.O.B.A.Z.O.I.D** (On mobile)
SaveEstelle
01/03/2018
09:48 PM
#31
Personally I'd recommend the PS2 version of P3. The gameplay is better in P3P but losing the anime cutscenes isn't worth it.
"Piece of cake!"
"We're good to go!"
Strife2
01/03/2018
09:48 PM
#32
I mean, after 100-120 hours, you can't be blamed. Every time I replay The Journey, I say I'm going to play the Answer at least once, yet never do.
"Evening caress, Always yearning, I must confess, The stars aren't burning"
Copernicus - Candlemass
Mr Crispy
01/03/2018
09:49 PM
#33
Persona is a spinoff of smt if, which is a spinoff of smt 1. but nu persona just kind of takes a dump all over the existing persona concepts and lore and whatever and does its own chuunibyou themed thing so it isn't necessary to play the older games before p3 on, or smt before persona.

I'd probably start with Nocturne if you think you can handle it, most of the pre Nocturne games aren't terribly worth playing if you aren't interested in the series and it introduced a lot of the base mechanics than later games refined. if it doesn't click maybe try one of the newer persona games or others.
The only certain death in the universe is Mother Hitton's Littul Kittons.
Not changing this line until I beat Seven Heroes (2/24/07)
LeonhartFour
01/03/2018
10:12 PM
#34
GranzonEx posted...
P3 is brutal if you've only play stuff like Final Fantasy


As someone whose JRPG experience is like 50% Square stuff, it's not that bad.
http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/080/145/638.png
https://imgur.com/hWiEG77
LapisLazuli
01/03/2018
10:34 PM
#35
Not having control of the party is just a hard no for me.

I would hate it even if the game was super easy.
"I think Cuphead should be higher." - Abby from Brooklyn
LeonhartFour
01/03/2018
10:37 PM
#36
It's annoying, but I got used to it.
http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/080/145/638.png
https://imgur.com/hWiEG77
Mr Crispy
01/03/2018
10:48 PM
#37
eh as far as p3 goes.

difficulty in dungeons against randoms are basically nonexistent.

dungeon bosses are pretty obnoxious either mostly because you can't control the entire party (sleeping table) or are deliberately designed to spite you (world balance or fes in general.

story bosses are mostly easy, but can get long. particularly the final if you don't just armageddon it at the last phase
The only certain death in the universe is Mother Hitton's Littul Kittons.
Not changing this line until I beat Seven Heroes (2/24/07)
Tom Bombadil
01/03/2018
11:16 PM
#38
Mr Crispy posted...
sleeping table


https://assets.vg247.com/current//2017/09/Flashback-600x338.jpg
I have the power of God AND anime on my side
G O O D N O G
LiquidOshawott
01/03/2018
11:34 PM
#39
P3 spoilers

man the table was annoying

Nothing came close, not even 3 Hulk Hogans
I live on, THROUGH THIS SEASHELL!
VI
foolm0r0n
01/04/2018
12:13 AM
#40
LeonhartFour posted...
GranzonEx posted...
P3 is brutal if you've only play stuff like Final Fantasy

As someone whose JRPG experience is like 50% Square stuff, it's not that bad.

Same except it's more like 75% square

That 25% non-square stuff is so insanely terrible (and some square stuff too) that P3 is very easy to get into. Also P3 has one of the strongest openings of any game, it's only really the middle that can drag, but you're already hooked by then.
_foolmo_
2 + 2 = 4
ninkendo
01/04/2018
12:27 AM
#41
just don't play The Answer

never play The Answer
http://i.imgur.com/LhGP5E6.gif
https://card.psnprofiles.com/2/CaptainRockman.png
Punnyz
01/04/2018
12:47 AM
#42
Why is Megami Tensei off limit? is it that hard or bad or something?
https://i.imgur.com/qBpLe47.png
http://i.imgur.com/25MHSn1.gif
Mr Crispy
01/04/2018
01:00 AM
#43
Megami Tensei is a licensed game, not made by Atlus, and doesn't really have anything to do with smt besides the whole edgy high school student with a demon summoning program on his computer concept.
The only certain death in the universe is Mother Hitton's Littul Kittons.
Not changing this line until I beat Seven Heroes (2/24/07)
WazzupGenius00
01/04/2018
03:05 PM
#44
Mr Crispy posted...
Megami Tensei is a licensed game, not made by Atlus, and doesn't really have anything to do with smt besides the whole edgy high school student with a demon summoning program on his computer concept.

The Famicom version is absolutely made by Atlus. There was a different Megami Tensei game also based on the book made by a different company for PCs, but the Famicom one is developed by Atlus, published by Namco.

If you decide to play regular Megami Tensei (which is more similar to classic SMT than people are leading you to believe, they're just not plot-related) then you should forget the Famicom version and look into Kyuuyaku Megami Tensei, which is a remake of MT1 and 2 for Super Famicom with many quality of life improvements. It has a translation patch
http://i.imgur.com/k0v0z3q.gif
BlackMageJawa
01/04/2018
04:10 PM
#45
As far as I'm aware, pretty much every game in the franchise is more or less standalone- there are cross references, recurring themes, and a fairly consistent cast of demons to fight/recruit, but only a handful of games whose plot can be considered a continuation of an earlier one to the extent that they have to be played in order.

In other words, find one that you like the look of and try it. If it doesn't click, try another one.
The shattered stage is set and there's a role you must fulfil
Board 8 » Suppose I wanted to finally get into the Shin Megami Tensei/Persona series