Nominated by Bitto
If I distinguish between "Super Mario" and just "Mario," it's technically not a tie, but I imagine that would not be a popular decision.
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/b/b9451424.png
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/e/eece6eca.png
Recent top results:
Day 283: Tie --
The Blues
Brothers AND
Super Mario
Bros. (22%)
Day 282: Dream
Team
(17%)
Day 281:
Monsters
, Inc. (56%)
Day 280:
Point
Break (24%)
Day 279:
American
Pie (38%)
Day 278: Blood
Rayne
(8%) (redo 2nd place)
Day 277:
Cat
Dog (22%)
Day 276:
Black
Cat (28%)
Day 275: The
Girl
From
Ipanema
(21%)
Past results:
https://board8.fandom.com/wiki/Fill_in_the_Blank_(Series%29
My response: Fail, followed by MegaGames
Only the exceptions can be exceptional.