What will be the six games nominated for GotY at The Game Awards?

Board 8

Page of 3
Board 8 » What will be the six games nominated for GotY at The Game Awards?
Since the deadline for games releasing is November 17, it looks like all the major contenders are out/reviewed by now (Flight Simulator, Stalker 2, and Indiana Jones are all after this). The contenders aren't quite as far ahead of the field as last year, but there are still some big contenders.

Best-reviewed AAA games:
Astro Bot
Metaphor
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
Tekken 8
Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth
Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown

Best-reviewed indies:
Balatro
UFO 50
Satisfactory
Animal Well
Hades 2 (not sure if they'll go for an early access game)
Tsukihime Remake

Best sellers:
Palworld
Black Myth Wukong
Helldivers 2

We've also gotten a token Nintendo game in previous years, so Echoes of Wisdom could sneak in, but Astro Bot may take its place as the family game rep. I believe Shadow of the Erdtree isn't eligible for GotY, but it is eligible for other categories. What's your pick for the top 6? Any dark horses I missed?
All the stars in the sky are waiting for you.
I think the only tricky thing with Rebirth/Metaphor/LaD all getting in would be it would mean half the games are JRPGs and thats a little heavy genre wise

could see Silent Hill 2 remake get in and Balatro too over LaD
I live on, THROUGH THIS SEASHELL!
VeryInsane's mobile account
A potential dark horse you didnt mention is Mario & Luigi Brothership. Also is the cutoff release or in the hands of outlets? Because at least STALKER 2 will probably be being played by then.

Anyway there are imo four locks:

Astro Bot
Metaphor ReFantazio
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
Balatro

A fifth very likely contender is Like A Dragon: Infinite Wealth, which does have the issue of coming out so early but should qualify. So that last spot is wide open and I genuinely dont know. I really dont think it will be (or as a huge Zelda fan whos enjoying the game, should be) Echoes of Wisdom, if theres a Nintendo game it could be Brothership. It seems like it is UFO50 vs Animal Well vs one of the populist choices (maybe Wukong). My provisional guess is:

Astro Bot
Balatro
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
Like A Dragon: Infinite Wealth
Metaphor ReFantazio
UFO50
I just decided to change this sig.
Blaaaaaaargh azuarc
Locks:
Astro Bot
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom

Probable:
Tekken 8
Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth

Indie representative:
Balatro

If one of the probables doesn't make it, it's probably in favor of either Dragon's Dogma 2 or Prince of Persia. Animal Well could be the indie representative instead of Balatro. I don't see both being included. There's also a chance Metaphor takes LaD's spot.
snowpork
azuarc is OP.
As long as FF7Rebirth or Metaphor wins, that's all that matters.
~Silver_Ermine~
http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m9r5hhXQbJ1rbct63o1_500.gif
Tekken 8 reviewed pretty well but both casual and hardcore players have kinda soured on it for various reasons. Not sure whether games media have a finger on that pulse though
http://i.imgur.com/k0v0z3q.gif
The three locks in my opinion are Astro Bot, Final Fantasy, and Metaphor. I think only one indie will get in and Balatro's popularity will get it through. I think Infinite Wealth is well-liked enough to be a solid prediction and the Like a Dragon/Yakuza series in general is overdue for mainstream recognition.

Last slot is really tricky. Helldivers 2 has lost a lot of goodwill since its release but might make it through inertia. Black Myth could be included to attract a Chinese audience. Dragon Age: The Veilguard has a good chance if it can get high sales and general audience goodwill to overcome the Gamergate weirdos' latest Two-Minutes Hate.

Fingers crossed for Mario and Luigi: Brothership to be great enough to be a late contender.
WazzupGenius00 posted...
Tekken 8 reviewed pretty well but both casual and hardcore players have kinda soured on it for various reasons. Not sure whether games media have a finger on that pulse though

Also, its a fighting game and they are the horror movies of the video game medium. They almost never get serious award nominations and when they do its almost always accompanied by is it really a <GENRE>? like Smash Bros or Silence of the Lambs. Not many other ways you can compare those two haha.
I just decided to change this sig.
Blaaaaaaargh azuarc
LightningStrikes posted...
Also, its a fighting game and they are the horror movies of the video game medium. They almost never get serious award nominations and when they do its almost always accompanied by is it really a <GENRE>? like Smash Bros or Silence of the Lambs. Not many other ways you can compare those two haha.

street fighter 6 got in last year right or am I imagining things

that said dont think Tekken 8 is as relevant

edit: ok, it didnt so yeah no chance
I live on, THROUGH THIS SEASHELL!
VeryInsane's mobile account
I assume Astro Bot kinda walks it this year barring a last minute shock release. It's the best reviewed game of the year, a first party Sony title, and most of its major competition is in genres they usually don't go for (though admittedly they aren't huge on platformers either).

Zigzagoon posted...
As long as FF7Rebirth or Metaphor wins, that's all that matters.
I very much doubt either of them will!

MacArrowny posted...
Hades 2 (not sure if they'll go for an early access game)
I think it's up to the devs if they want to push it this year or not. Personally I think they're likely to have a better shot next year, can't see it winning this time.

For GotY noms, I'll guess:
Astro Bot
FF7
Zelda
Animal Well
Silent Hill 2
Helldivers 2

Maybe swap out Animal Well for Balatro, I'm not sure which is bigger within the games media. And I may be way off with Helldivers, we'll see!
Yeah people thought it would but Alan Wake II coming out is likely what stopped it. Otherwise Id say it probably would have made it in.

Also I will use this topic as my soapbox to say: Geoff Keighly if youre reading this please divide Best Performance into Lead and Supporting. It doesnt make sense to put small roles in with leading roles, and the end result is either all big leads or one game dominating the category with multiple nominations. Plus the other big awards have done it already!
I just decided to change this sig.
Blaaaaaaargh azuarc
Astro Bot and 7 Rebirth probably. Does DLC get to count as a GotY? If so Elden Rings probably has a shot. Zenless Zone Zero probably has mobile game won, but none of those are gonna be GotY contenders Id assume. Not really sure for other stuff since I rarely touch new games
Astro Bot
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
Metaphor: ReFantazio
Tekken 8
The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom
Balatro
:)
Also, my hunch is that The Game Awards would never shut out Western AAA studios entirely, even though Japanese and indie titles dominated this year, so that's promising for Helldivers and Dragon Age. Heck, maybe even Black Ops 6 has a shot given it's the best reviewed Call of Duty since Modern Warfare 3.
Not sure Silent Hill 2 has a shot considering the TGA's antipathy for Konami ever since the Kojima split.
All the stars in the sky are waiting for you.
I will go

Astro Bot
Metaphor
Rebirth
Balatro
SH2Make
a sixth game that I dont know, if you want to put LaD here sure?

what was the board verdict on Zelda? Feels like it dropped out of consciousness pretty quickly for a Zelda game
I live on, THROUGH THIS SEASHELL!
VeryInsane's mobile account
MacArrowny posted...
Not sure Silent Hill 2 has a shot considering the TGA's antipathy for Konami ever since the Kojima split.

its been a decade though and lets be honest: Konami has basically done nothing between then and now so its more just a industry thing

if Delta somehow gets shadow dropped I would probably have to consider seeing it for the sixth spot
I live on, THROUGH THIS SEASHELL!
VeryInsane's mobile account
man i dont wanna watch this for 3 hours just to see ff7 rebirth win goty
Hey TomNook play me in smash for your account
Mythiot posted...
Heck, maybe even Black Ops 6 has a shot given it's the best reviewed Call of Duty since Modern Warfare 3.

Which MW3 though
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
Astro Bot
Metaphor ReFantazio
Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth
Silent Hill 2
Animal Well
I've decided to put my fears behind me. I'm not going back.
If you're gonna scream, scream with me
FF7 Rebirth
Astro Bot
Metaphor
Balatro
SH2
Dragon Age (I guess...?)

Hades 2 GOTY2025 and ideally a Game Awards trailer with a release date (or even better a stealth "1.0 now available", oh baby...)

TomNook7 posted...
man i dont wanna watch this for 3 hours just to see ff7 rebirth win goty

https://imgur.com/a/T4sBakg
I said it for Street Fighter last year and I'll say it for Tekken this year, Game Awards doesn't care about fighting games. It's like the Oscars and animation

Infinite Wealth was about as well received as Like a Dragon, which also had like no chance. Double for Prince of Persia

Final Fantasy
Astro Bot
The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom
Black Myth Wukong
Helldivers 2
Metaphor (iffy on this one - might be Animal Well or even Persona 3 Remake instead)
Khal Kirby , warlord of the Super Star Khalasar
PSN/Steam: CheddarBBQ https://goo.gl/Diw2hs
Best Indie predix:
Animal Well
Balatro
Palworld
UFO 50
Neva
The Plucky Squire

(Maybe Lorelei and the Laser Eyes instead of one of the latter bunch)

Hm, I wonder who's likely for Best Performance? They didn't go for the FF7 crew last time around, maybe one of the Yakuza guys can do it though. Perhaps the Hellblade actress. Feel like I'm missing someone obvious.
Astro Bot
Metaphor
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
Tekken 8
Balatro
Satisfactory
http://i.imgur.com/l7xxLh1.jpg
PSN/Steam - RoboQuote ; NNID - TazzyMan
andylt posted...
Best Indie predix:
Animal Well
Balatro
Palworld
UFO 50
Neva
The Plucky Squire

(Maybe Lorelei and the Laser Eyes instead of one of the latter bunch)

Hm, I wonder who's likely for Best Performance? They didn't go for the FF7 crew last time around, maybe one of the Yakuza guys can do it though. Perhaps the Hellblade actress. Feel like I'm missing someone obvious.

If Luke Roberts doesnt win Best Performance (or Best Performance - Lead!) for playing James in Silent Hill 2 then what are we even doing here. I was watching one of the endings and genuinely thinking I think this is the best acting Ive ever seen in a game. I couldnt even tell you the last time I thought that.
I just decided to change this sig.
Blaaaaaaargh azuarc
LiquidOshawott posted...
its been a decade though and lets be honest: Konami has basically done nothing between then and now so its more just a industry thing

if Delta somehow gets shadow dropped I would probably have to consider seeing it for the sixth spot
Delta's the same kind of remake as Demon's Souls, so I'm a bit skeptical on how well that one will do.
All the stars in the sky are waiting for you.
LightningStrikes posted...
If Luke Roberts doesnt win Best Performance (or Best Performance - Lead!) for playing James in Silent Hill 2 then what are we even doing here. I was watching one of the endings and genuinely thinking I think this is the best acting Ive ever seen in a game. I couldnt even tell you the last time I thought that.
You're correct but horror traditionally struggles at media award shows because much of the voterbase is literally too scared to watch/play it.
It's Reyn Time.
I was unaware SH2's VA is supposed to be great, that's good to know.

KamikazePotato posted...
You're correct but horror traditionally struggles at media award shows because much of the voterbase is literally too scared to watch/play it.
Lady Dimitescu's VA won the category a few years ago >_>
At the risk of sounding elitist, RE doesn't count. It's really not that scary, with a much stronger focus on action than fear. I think SH2 Remake managed to bring in more casuals than most horror games, but there's still a large number of people who would never touch it (or try it and then drop off, which is what the Steam achievements indicate) because it's very spooky.
It's Reyn Time.
KamikazePotato posted...
At the risk of sounding elitist, RE doesn't count. It's really not that scary, with a much stronger focus on action than fear. I think SH2 Remake managed to bring in more casuals than most horror games, but there's still a large number of people who would never touch it (or try it and then drop off, which is what the Steam achievements indicate) because it's very spooky.

what about Alan Wake 2 or does that not count either

I live on, THROUGH THIS SEASHELL!
VeryInsane's mobile account
I actually forgot about Alan Wake 2. Haven't played it yet, is it legit a scary game?

I'd be happy to be wrong about SH2, hope it gets some nods at the awards.
It's Reyn Time.
Yeah the genre bias is real, especially in acting categories for films funnily enough. You could, right now, literally make a worthy Best Actress category for this years oscars using only performances in horror films, and almost certainly none will get nominated (Demi Moore if were lucky). However I think it is not as bad for games due to younger demographics.

andylt posted...
I was unaware SH2's VA is supposed to be great, that's good to know.

Not just VA but full performance capture! And it really shows in game.

Anyway heres what the Golden Joysticks nominated for performance:

Lead -

Kaiji Tang as Ichiban Kasuga, Like A Dragon Infinite Wealth

Humberly Gonzales as Kay Vess, Star Wars Outlaws

Melina Juergens as Senua, Senuas Saga: Hellblade II

Luke Roberts as James Sunderland, Silent Hill 2

Cody Christian as Cloud Strife, Final Fantasy VII Rebirth

Sonequa Martin-Green as Alvilda, Asgards Wrath 2

Supporting -

Abbi Greenland & Helen Goalen as The Furies, Senuas Saga: Hellblade II

Dawn M Bennett as Aigis, Persona 3 Reload

Debra Wilson as Amanda Waller, Suicide Squad

Matt Berry as Herbert, Thank Goodness Youre Here!

Briana White as Aerith Gainsborough, Final Fantasy VII Rebirth

Neve McIntosh as Suze, Still Wakes the Deep

If they split the category it may look like this. If they dont just take Lead and replace Sonequa Martin-Green with Matt Berry because they like a celebrity.
I just decided to change this sig.
Blaaaaaaargh azuarc
Alan Wake 2 is definitely scary even if it has some light hearted moments too.
I've decided to put my fears behind me. I'm not going back.
If you're gonna scream, scream with me
KamikazePotato posted...
I actually forgot about Alan Wake 2. Haven't played it yet, is it legit a scary game?

I'd be happy to be wrong about SH2, hope it gets some nods at the awards.

yeah, its not campy as the original if thats what you are thinking.

the other thing it has in its favor is its length: I can see it going in over 3 80+ hour JRPGs

I live on, THROUGH THIS SEASHELL!
VeryInsane's mobile account
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/5/5c5177c6.jpg

I got 6/6 on my prediction last year, but I'm not quite as confident here. I could also see Dragon Age or Infinite Wealth making it. Or even Shadow of the Erdtree if they want to nominate an expansion. Tough call, but I think this is my prediction.
Video Games are pretty cool.
LiquidOshawott posted...
yeah, its not campy as the original if thats what you are thinking.

the other thing it has in its favor is its length: I can see it going in over 3 80+ hour JRPGs
JRPG LFF is also why I think Astro Bot is the big favorite to win it all. Was just too good of a year for the genre.
It's Reyn Time.
I'm guessing:

FF7
Metaphor
Balatro
Astro Bot
Silent Hill 2
Wukong

This is assuming DLC is off the table (ie SotET)
XBL GT: Demon Ninja X2
"There comes a time in every man's or woman's life where they have to make **** up to cover their ass." - Hazama
Pirateking2000 posted...
I'm guessing:

FF7
Metaphor
Balatro
Astro Bot
Silent Hill 2
Wukong

This is assuming DLC is off the table (ie SotET)

Going by the Golden Joystick Awards, I think Helldivers is probably a nominee. It got a lot of nominations there. That and it just generally being super popular with both fans and critics even though it didn't score super high.

So I would put it over Black Myth: Wukong.
Video Games are pretty cool.
MacArrowny posted...
Since the deadline for games releasing is November 17, it looks like all the major contenders are out/reviewed by now (Flight Simulator, Stalker 2, and Indiana Jones are all after this).


It's actually November 22.

"Games eligible for The Game Awards this year must be available for public consumption on or before Friday, November 22, 2024 at 9pm PT."
https://thegameawards.com/faq

So Flight Simulator and Stalker 2 are in. Indiana Jones is still out.
My bracket looked like random picks compared to his.
Congrats to azuarc for winning the GotD 2020 Guru Contest!
Oh weird, Polygon had it as the 17th. Thanks for the correction!
All the stars in the sky are waiting for you.
The deadline last year was November 17. So some wires probably got crossed somewhere.
My bracket looked like random picks compared to his.
Congrats to azuarc for winning the GotD 2020 Guru Contest!
Polygon have an article with predictions:

https://www.polygon.com/awards/450195/game-of-the-year-game-awards-frontrunners

Currently saying Astro Bot, Metaphor ReFantazio, Final Fantasy VII Rebirth, Balatro, Silent Hill 2 and Dragon Age: The Veilguard.
I just decided to change this sig.
Blaaaaaaargh azuarc
LightningStrikes posted...
Polygon have an article with predictions:

https://www.polygon.com/awards/450195/game-of-the-year-game-awards-frontrunners

Currently saying Astro Bot, Metaphor ReFantazio, Final Fantasy VII Rebirth, Balatro, Silent Hill 2 and Dragon Age: The Veilguard.
The one quibble I have with their article is that they say multiplayer games never get nominated or win, ignoring that Overwatch did, in fact, get nominated and win. It may have been a while ago, but it's not like there's been many of these shows. Helldivers 2 is a really hard one to figure out, because its critical reception isn't quite universal enough (I think it has an 84 metacritic which is a bit low but not unheard of for a TGA nom), but it also just seems like it makes sense for it to be here. I kinda suspect it gets the nod over SH2 or Veilguard, not sure which - I'm not really sure how critical acclaim has shaken out for either game just yet.
Having looked at Veilguard's reviews again, I sort of suspect it's going to go the way of Starfield here, even though this is a less stacked year overall. I think its reception is just too mixed and they'll go with something that has proven to have more universal appeal even though it also had kind of 'eh' reviews, like Helldivers.
LightningStrikes posted...
Polygon have an article with predictions:

https://www.polygon.com/awards/450195/game-of-the-year-game-awards-frontrunners

Currently saying Astro Bot, Metaphor ReFantazio, Final Fantasy VII Rebirth, Balatro, Silent Hill 2 and Dragon Age: The Veilguard.

I could easily see that being the list. To me, it seems like it's Helldivers vs. Dragon Age for that sixth slot.

Paratroopa1 posted...
Having looked at Veilguard's reviews again, I sort of suspect it's going to go the way of Starfield here, even though this is a less stacked year overall. I think its reception is just too mixed and they'll go with something that has proven to have more universal appeal even though it also had kind of 'eh' reviews, like Helldivers.

Despite being lower rated, I think Dragon Age is more beloved by major critics than Starfield was. At least, that's how a lot of the major critics are talking as well as the general vibe.
Video Games are pretty cool.
UberPyro64 posted...
Despite being lower rated, I think Dragon Age is more beloved by major critics than Starfield was.
Starfield has an 83 on metacritic. Veilguard has 84.

The Dragon Age subreddit went from being very hopeful/positive about Veilguard to voicing big complaints in like a day, so I don't think the long-term fan reception is going to be great for this one. It won't be nearly as negative as Starfield or early Cyberpunk, but yeah. Steam reviews are at 77% positive, for whatever that's worth.
It's Reyn Time.
KamikazePotato posted...
Starfield has an 83 on metacritic. Veilguard has 84.

The Dragon Age subreddit went from being very hopeful/positive about Veilguard to voicing big complaints in like a day, so I don't think the long-term fan reception is going to be great for this one. It won't be nearly as negative as Starfield or early Cyberpunk, but yeah. Steam reviews are at 77% positive, for whatever that's worth.
Dragon Age Inquisition only has 75% positive reviews on Steam, haha.
All the stars in the sky are waiting for you.
If you want another comparison point, the Silent Hill 2 Remake had big shoes to fill, months of negative press from a series of bad trailers, released to an insanely nitpicky fanbase, and was also targeted by chuds for dumb reasons (although not nearly as much as Veilguard). It still has a 95% rating on Steam, and the subreddit has been extremely positive.

It's not impossible for these kinds of 'doomed' games to make their fans happy. And while I think Veilguard has a bigger handicap to overcome than SH2 Remake, it's also just not up to the same standard of quality.* A lot of people will still like it, and I think sales will be decent, but this isn't going to be the slam dunk Bioware was likely hoping for.

*From what I've read. Haven't played Veilguard yet.
It's Reyn Time.
MacArrowny posted...
Dragon Age Inquisition only has 75% positive reviews on Steam, haha.

Implying it should be higher? I tried DA:I earlier this year and ran into crap with the Ubisoft launcher that effectively kept me from playing. I bought the game mega-on sale, and I literally returned it for $3.
Only the exceptions can be exceptional.
75% seems about right for a AAA, bestselling, GotY-winning WRPG that lost to Ori and the Blind Forest on GameFAQs.

I say that as a fan of Inquisition.
It's Reyn Time.
Board 8 » What will be the six games nominated for GotY at The Game Awards?
Page of 3