Lurker > Leafeon13N

That is to say, you are both 100% scum but Ashe dying first is the one i would be most confident i could keep town in the right direction.

Arguing that i am lynching one of you over the other is literally an argument that goes nowhere right now.

Corrik posted...

pjbasis posted...

I don't get why he wouldn't try to kill stronger players if he's fabricating the BP excuse.

You should be killing your most surefire scum. Which is why red calling me 100% scum and voting Ashe is hilarious.

I would literally lynch either of you at this point. Ashe is however the one that will open up the most eyes.

Btw the entire idea of throwing up an argument that i am somehow slipping the scumteam size when it is literally just going off of the highest number it could possibly be is literally the most pathetic argument anyone has made in this game.

pjbasis posted...

Why are you even so sure it's endgame yet

Error on the side of it being endgame. Because if you play like it isnt theres a better chance there is no tomorrow.

pjbasis posted...

Pulling together a venn diagram of scum lists isn't scumhunting either. Smells like noncommittal bait throwing to see if a member of town decides to head in that direction

This board in general needs a serious endgame lecture. Cast your lot with the people you think are town.

Especially in a scenario like this where no scan is coming. Our power is all dead, no one is coming out with a foolproof answer.

Bolt
Rocket Raccoon

Corrik posted...

You just said prior that red was inconsistent in his comments. Now you are saying they make sense. What???

You think hes confirmed town and just tried to throw shade on him. This post should be very clear to everyone.

Leafeon13N posted...

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Okay so here comes my first post in a while after catching up. So it seems like everyone is kind of thinking that. Pj or ashe is scum. And a few people are also on scare but the real question who is the scummiest scum of the scum?

I'm going to again remind you any sort of split of votes in all likelihood ends in a town loss. We have to lynch together.

The other part of this i guess I'll add... Most of the game is in agreement on ashe at this point, including multiple players you will eventually have to trust just due to numbers.

We still have to likely go 4 for 4 after but I'm telling, and eventually I'll probably have to start begging and pleading, that it is the best start we've got.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Okay so here comes my first post in a while after catching up. So it seems like everyone is kind of thinking that. Pj or ashe is scum. And a few people are also on scare but the real question who is the scummiest scum of the scum?

I'm going to again remind you any sort of split of votes in all likelihood ends in a town loss. We have to lynch together.

Ashethan posted...

At all. Now it really does seem like you were setting up my mislynch, followed by mislynching Scare. Of

This is extremely high on the bullshit scale. Hell ive gotten scare mislynched as scum recently and it went absolutely nothing like this.

Ashethan posted...

Which is why I said it's entirely null. Like... if you're town here your logic makes no sense. Maybe Nana/Scare ARE scum. Like I said, that's possible (it's like you aren't even reading posts tbh) but the fact that we were all lynch leaders, and one was town, doesn't make it likely or probable that one of the other two are scum. At all. Now it really does seem like you were setting up my mislynch, followed by mislynching Scare. Of course, that depends on Scare being town.

I never said it wasn't possible. I wanted Scares thoughts to get a better read on him for one thing.

That said, the fact that in some realities he literally died day 1. That put a heavy town lean on him for me.

##vote: Ashe

I'm confident enough to start the chain in this direction.

(also im going to be at Disneyland the rest of the day).

Going to remind town we need literally every vote or risk losing today.

Ashethan posted...

If scare is town, then it's 100% town/town/town. You either know this as scum, and use it to toss suspicion on me, or you are town with poor logic here. I know this because I know my own alignment. Now, you could be right--Nana/Scare could be scum. But I take the results of the lynch on day 1 as entirely null.

This is more disingenuous posting. I am telling Scare that if hes town its town town ??? and that i want to hear his thoughts on it. Your perspective is still flawed in this because even if you were town, to you it is the same as it would be to scare, two town and an unknown.

Ashethan posted...

I think your paranoia was fake. Or you wouldn't be so easily sated that Chris is town because he didn't kill you yesterday.

If my paranoia was to chris alone it would be one thing. It was chris, blade, and Corrik.

pjbasis posted...

That is a lot of town on red's list.

Without a scum lynch yet I can see anybody on either side

You get them all right or you lose right now pj.

Corrik posted...

Lol I dunno why red is even being so salty right now. It isn't like anyone is going to listen to me. Is it really such a shot to your ego that I figured the game out before yinz won? I love it.

Salty was me yesterday when i had to claim.

This is me finding your implosion laughable. That is pretty far from salty.

Rocket Raccoon
Bolt

kateee posted...

that has no bearing on whether i stop or not

Keep going kate

They all suck horribly

##vote:fd

Lets move.

pjbasis posted...

opinion of zach is he feels like town. A little arrogant, but I kind of see some of my own faults that usually come out as town when he feels like he's being unfairly pressured

Zachs logic has gotten pretty flimsy, hes dropped a bit on the town scale.

ScareChan posted...

Corrik being kind of absent is different. He didnt call me town yet and he usually does by now, but he did try to get me to lynch chris with him. Probably town

I still dont know what to think of inactive corrik.

I'm leaning we should off pj

FD is an intriguing option but also the learn nothing option.

Also i was sleeping on it and had a growing opinion that the 5 of us deserve to live.

We really do need our own wiki or whayever of board 8 roles and modifiers one of these days.

Forceful_Dragon posted...

I read this and spent a hot second wondering why red listed himself as scum. Who puts town at the bottom?

My usual habit is to delete myself for safety but i was autopilotting my cut and paste routine pretty hard.

Alakazamtrainer posted...

Other then that I see pj is also in the limelight, perhaps I should go reread what he's said

This wont take long.

Ashethan posted...

Then it also feels (contrary to what Corrik says) more like he's trying to out town protection roles with this whole "Plum was an SK kill" thing.

This is just not true btw.

Ashethan posted...

In which case how is that still not true when I'm also town? 3 town lynches (or even 4 if you count Tony if he's town too) and scum could do whatever they wanted. It allows them to hide. My lynch being the third viable lynch means nothing for my alignment.

I don't think you really ended up in danger at the end though. I'm not entirely sure when you got the third vote but i dont think anyone actively tried to kill you at the end.

Breath of the Wild has some flaws but i know i read an article forever ago that explained what makes it great pretty well: The game never tells you no. It gives you all these abilities and they always interact the way you might think they do. You'll look at a puzzle, see something that doesn't look like the intended solution but think it should work anyway. Guess what, it will.

There is almost no way any two people who played the game blind completed it in the same way.

The game doesn't limit you, stuff works because its there.

Scare for what its worth i was leaning town on colzach as well.

The Playerlist
1. Alakazamtrainer
2. Ashetan
3. ChaosTonyV4
4. ColZach
5. Corrik
6. DoomTheGyarados (Chris)
7. FakeAccount3000
8. Forceful_Dragon
9. IfGodCouldDie
10. Meow1000 (Blade)
11. Nanahara715
12. pjbasis
13. red13n
14. TheSultanOfSlam

THE DEAD
[LD1] 5tarscream - Elmyra Duff, TINYTOON Hugger
[NK1] masterplum - Dizzy Devil, TINYTOON Dizzy

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch. Day will end Tuesday at 11pm EST.

Bringing this for reference.

Rocket Raccoon
Bolt