Board List | |
---|---|
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 5 - Anatomy of a Trainwreck |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 5:50:56 PM #265 | Meow1000 posted...
Whatit was a whole arc you missed --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 5 - Anatomy of a Trainwreck |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 5:49:04 PM #259 | I can elaborate in depth on the towniness of anyone in these top two categories, but I literally have no time so if I dont survive the night you can probably find more details in my old posts, but you also probably wont care lol
SUPER TOWN AND THERE IS NO POSSIBILITY OF ME BEING WRONG ABOUT Ulti Kirby Taco (now Mzero but Taco did all the work) INCREDIBLE TOWN VIBES IN EVERYTHING THEY DO Blade Spicy Red IGCD LESSER TOWN VIBES IN EVERYTHING BUT PASS THE DAY 1 VIBE CHECK Chang Peaf MI Isquen THE GLEE CLUB Corrik Ctes Death FD Knightz Sbell Wallz --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 5 - Anatomy of a Trainwreck |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 5:32:33 PM #192 | I disalllow the lynching of Chang.
Unless something has changed in the last 12 hours, I liked MI's analysis and takes early on that I wouldn't support killing him today. As conflicted as I still am about Wallz, I do think the wisest move is to take Knightz off the board. There is a case for him being scum who has made multiple actual slip ups, and worse case its a vanilla. Dont really expect anyone to fight for him either if its not me. --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 5 - Anatomy of a Trainwreck |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 5:23:49 PM #166 | *sips tea*
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 5 - Anatomy of a Trainwreck |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 4:41:19 PM #74 | Kirby321 posted...
(I think Ben meant that everybody at his workplace took the day off...)Yeah its work. You all keep cruisin --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 5 - Anatomy of a Trainwreck |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 4:39:56 PM #73 | Forceful_Dragon posted...
blade returned and things popped off >_>I did see that and i am happy. He is still obv town --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 5 - Anatomy of a Trainwreck |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 4:26:04 PM #54 | If work does not let up then I will not be able to participate in EoD at all. I'm a full topic behind and get off right at deadline. Everyone decided to take today off apparently and I did not get the memo
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 4 - Advanced WIFOM Game Theory |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 11:57:14 AM #206 | Obellisk posted...
in my opinion, his way of walking back in appeared to dress itself in town clothing. Obellisk posted... I just don't see why someone who has the mindfulness to be aware they are being discussed because they've been so absent because of their real life fiascos would think walking in as a cocky asshole would gain town points.???? --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 4 - Advanced WIFOM Game Theory |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 11:48:44 AM #199 | Obellisk posted...
your disappearance matters in THIS GAME because of circumstance and the way you played while here.Does it make sense for a Scum Blade to come back into the game the way he did? --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 4 - Advanced WIFOM Game Theory |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 11:42:42 AM #197 | MZero posted...
well that's unfortunate. There goes my plan of breadcrumbing taunts all dayTown confirmed --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 4 - Advanced WIFOM Game Theory |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 10:19:40 AM #69 | TotallyNotMI posted...
No jokes allowed. Blade already stopped this from being a thing.! *takes notes* --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 8:37:57 AM #450 | UltimaterializerX posted...
So Ben took this long to reach the conclusion I made three hours into the game, huhIf it's right then yes, you win. It is day 1 after all --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 12:52:46 AM #367 | That was for fun. The post literally led into "____ votals"
Like how hosts like to name their votals something cute... it was all an elaborate one of those --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 12:07:27 AM #360 | In conclusion, there is a case there that Knightz is scum, but if he is then it makes Taco super confirmed town. So the order we lynch them does matter.
Knightz, do you yield? --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 12:03:24 AM #358 | ItzKnightz posted...
in my own words:And was decided? By who? the scum team? --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 05/01/24 12:03:10 AM #357 | ItzKnightz posted...
I don't use discord, the only time I used it was when I was 6. Since then I stopped using it and forgot my login. Tacocraft545 posted... He was not 6 he was 9 maybe 10.Knightz also has a few recent posts where he lies in a rush to explain something, and notice Taco corrects them. ItzKnightz posted... I live with my parents thank you very much. Tacocraft545 posted... didn't you just say "apartment" ^ ItzKnightz posted... nice try? we bicker constantly and we don't really get alone.This does feel like a pretty defensive defense. Taco your thoughts? Lol ItzKnightz posted... Taco is blatantly scum and do we see anyone after him? no, because you all have your heads in the ground ignoring what is really happening around you. Taco is clearly scum, he couldn't have known that a Taunter was a thing without scum help, he is playing his first game and already knows what Third-Party people are which is not normal behavior coming from a newbie who just started playing 2 days ago. Tacocraft545 posted... I watched sid die! And I am taunter!Knightz repeats stuff we have said before and Taco has a solid rebuttal here --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 11:54:42 PM #356 | Tacocraft545 posted...
The entire fact you are being hyper defensive screams sus. Taco's first real accusation is this, and the only comment that is defensive at all that Knightz made is this. ItzKnightz posted... Why me? So, Taco was the initiator and it seems may have read into something Knightz is doing that we all weren't seeing >_> Take that as you will. Tacocraft545 posted... Yeah, and if you were town you would not ever be this defensive. --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 11:45:30 PM #354 | IfGodCouldDie posted...
Ben honest question, why are you so interested in having either of them live?Because they're players in a game and my job is to find town and scum? The meta game of them being brothers only makes this easier to figure out. --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 11:43:27 PM #353 | they should be better at reading each other than they are.
My first guess is that one of them has been legitimately suspicious of the other (probably the initiator), and the other has had to just pretend the other is obvious scum to defend against it. IIRC, Taco was the initiator, but thats what I'm looking back at right now --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 11:33:32 PM #350 | I will note that with them being brothers there is more to extract from the fact that they are attacking each other. That does point to them not being town together.
I will re-read with that in mind, and see if it lines up where Knightz is scum and Taco is town, because that is my first assumption here if one is scum --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 11:29:21 PM #349 | I know some of you just want to close your eyes and make this go away, or some of you are scum capitilizing on the easy way out, but we can easily work through this. None of this changes the fact that they will be easier to figure out the ALIGNMENT of than anyone. I feel like no one cares about that.
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 11:28:13 PM #348 | Knightz, is Taco older or younger than you?
Can you just make a same time post or something to prove you aren't the same person since that's a ridiculous thing some people here believe --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 11:27:07 PM #347 | *WEREN'T trying very hard
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 11:26:42 PM #346 | wallmasterz posted...
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/7/7c19ec9c.jpgI mean you can tell by the italics they were trying very hard to hide that they were close friends at the very least, and Knightz made it clear he asked Taco to come play. The "deception" also has nothing to do with their alignment --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 11:23:29 PM #345 | Tacocraft545 posted...
If you must know we are brothers. Now back off isn't this a invasion of privacy?https://y.yarn.co/394e938d-a24f-4a6e-beee-8248b6ba87db_text.gif --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 7:24:19 PM #243 | Forceful_Dragon posted...
Ben without giving any context... Is that deliberate?Ah. No --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 7:23:17 PM #241 | If they were clearly scum I would see it too
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 7:17:52 PM #236 | I would challenge us NOT to lynch any of the new players today unless one is clearly scum. They're the easiest people to read in the game. Especially the longer it goes on. Catch my drift, Taylor Swift?
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 7:11:52 PM #232 | Forceful_Dragon posted...
omg that would actually be incredible, if Lopen just "transferred to city college" for a semester and them comes back tomorrow. --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 6:55:19 PM #222 | I thought the last thing he did was vote for me. That's why I had to kill him
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 6:25:30 PM #214 | Kirby321 posted...
A dead town is a dead town, even if it's Lopen. Assuming he's dead, at least.Fair --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 6:20:59 PM #207 | Kirby321 posted...
How can you say that so confidently? "Vanished" is quite an ominous thing to describe a player. Janitor daykill is the most natural assumption to make here.Would you? --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 6:18:07 PM #202 | oh my god what happened to lopen. I just noticed he was gone
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 6:08:23 PM #182 | That's my most optimistic take. But there is no way of knowing.
Corrik7 posted... What more do you want. I town cleared myself and took a mislynch off the board day 1.If you didnt shoot Lopen then what do you mean by this? --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 6:07:06 PM #179 | https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/0/0f3cacbd.jpg
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 5:57:12 PM #157 | Does anyone here plan to prevent IGCD from completing his sidequest?
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 5:52:34 PM #150 | Lopen posted...
I have a strong town lean on IGCD now actually. Interesting it gave you nothing.Hard agree, Avril Lavigne The logic does not 100% clear Knightz, but I think IGCD was trying to 100% prove Knightz is town with information he thought would seal the deal, with information only IGCD has, that I dont think scum provides the game with. --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 5:36:22 PM #145 | Lopen posted...
I really didn't like how he picked out mentions of "joke phase" and ran with it as a theory to suspect wallz (leading lynch suspect) and Isquen (perpetual scum take an extra turn card). Felt like setting up free votes on easy lynches than an actual thought process that makes sense (why would scumchat be talking about joke phase) That would only be relevant if one of the two flips scum. But, it doesnt make either of them more likely scum in a vacuum. I never said that. --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 5:18:25 PM #132 | IfGodCouldDie posted...
I'm definitely not saying he can't be scum lol, just that if he is, he isn't getting help unless free forums etc.https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/7/7cfd90e7.jpg --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 5:10:50 PM #119 | IfGodCouldDie posted...
Just add to this, I am balancing a game with knightz and he will not get discord and has been asking if scum teams can be on free forums so unless something has changed knightz is not getting help from a scum team.https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/c/c954b254.jpg --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 4:15:06 PM #88 | Even Ulti who once said there is nothing Taco can say to convince him that he is town, has realized that Taco is town. Be like Ulti
--- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 4:13:11 PM #86 | Forceful_Dragon posted...
Fake what? You just claim it and if you know who a vanilla is you say they targeted them at night.If you know who a vanilla is then the rest of town probably does too. And then its a bad choice that would be questioned. And yeah I'm sure Taco is capable of making bad choices but that's not what scum aims to do >_> --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 4:02:00 PM #78 | Forceful_Dragon posted...
Oh then I guess he can't EVER be scum. I didn't realize that's all it took to be permanently town cleared, I can delete discord right now.Sometimes its really that simple. Oh to be young! If you ever hear us reference "Chang taunts Lopen mafia", it was from that. I think its too hard for Taco to fake that role and his scum mate would know that before coaching him to select it --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 3:59:24 PM #73 | UltimaterializerX posted...
Post 2 of the signup topic is interesting if you want to use I dont have discord logic.https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/b/bc5b6be9.jpg --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 3:52:40 PM #70 | Forceful_Dragon posted...
I'm back, it was just a drillReally? I mean with Taco he has no access to discord. He's too innocent to lie about that. Ignoring that, he's also claimed an obscure role that mafia never claims and only comes from the mouth of Lea in direct to PM box form Knightz you can try to lynch. If he is town he'll probably make it clear before it happens. IMO He's been UNDERSTANDABLE so far as town for me --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 3:48:50 PM #69 | I think the sentiment that Blade skipped the joke phase is an interesting one. Wallz was the first to mention it in his response to Blade, and Isquen is the second I see mention it as a major element of this game so far. Then Wallz is again the third to bring it up, also as a major element of the game. Maybe it takes more flips for this to mean anything, but there are some potential links here. It coming up in two separate recaps was weird, almost like its been said on the scum board. Maybe thats just want I want to be true because it would mean Blade is town and I was right.
wallmasterz posted... I can practically smell Leas teardrops at someone being criticized for not having content on the very first page of the game, but we are on page 2 now so its time for zero jokes, fun or pleasantries. Isquen posted... Yes, how dare I go to bed when I'm low-key sick, exhausted and not wanting to catch up beyond "Kirby randomly voting me for ??? reason." wallmasterz posted... Your first post came less than 10 minutes after I called out you being the only person left to check in. Slight paranoia about a scummoning here >_> but you just checked in so we can cross that bridge later. --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 3:27:40 PM #60 | PeaceFrog posted...
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs- contests/80758440/980158593He said it was a purely joke post, so why would it be in his favor? --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 3:13:01 PM #54 | PeaceFrog posted...
Kirby always has weird entrances into games. That's not what I'm poking at here. It's the way he commented on sbell and not Blade, and the way he called me town and based HIS ENTIRE READ OF BLADE on my very brief smart-assery towards him, and the way he said a bunch of nothing about ben? None of it feels genuine whatsoever.I went back because I am trying to find this for myself, and i am not seeing it. Are you getting mixed up with Sbell? Sbell certainly had that reaction to Blade much more than Wallz did. If not then I need you to point me to the posts you are referencing --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 2:58:49 PM #47 | PeaceFrog posted...
I think neither fd nor Wallz are scum, but feel more strongly about wallz.By your wording of rather, does this mean you would even consider Taco? --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Topic | Community Mafia Topic 3 - Symbolism of Modern Board 8 Specials |
PunishedBen 04/30/24 2:18:23 PM #38 | Lopen posted...
I can vote as many as I want on separate players. I am triple voting currentlyOh my god its the perfect Lopen role. He never has to unvote! --- https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/26864890/ |
Board List |