From: VincentLauw | #058
because they weren't
are you for real, do you still not understand the season finale 2 years after. it has probably been explained to you dozens of times.
uh you must be confusing me for somebody else
i'm not saying they were dead the whole time (even though i think they were originally planned to be during season 1)
what i'm saying is, everybody figured out that they were in purgatory, cuse and lindelof said "lol no" and scrambled to show that they were alive the whole time, and then when everybody least expected it they made purgatory the big twist again
--
http://i55.tinypic.com/20t3qfm.png