Yeah, the thing is that Andrew sometimes plays things out in the most obvious way, and sometimes he goes in a completely different direction. All these hints make uu being Lord English seem suspicious, but that could also be why he actually goes through with it. That's the beauty of it. If he did too many twists you'd start to become certain not to take things at face value, while being completely predictable would be bad for obvious reasons as well. But anyways, the result is that you become paranoid, like me.
--
I finally believe it. This is not butter. And I know deep down in my heart that I must become butter atheist.