Johns though, Johns is a 5. Everything about his writing appeals to me. He's not perfect, Blackest Night The Flash and (uh...oh god I actually have to stretch here, uhhh....) Beast Boy show that, but if you had to be perfect to get a 5 the only people there would be Lemire, Heinbgerg, and Synder, and they haven't done enough to write something bad yet (some would argue that Brightest Day The Atom was meh, but I still enjoyed it).
--
~LtM
http://img.imgcake.com/1312163320349pngag.png