This topic prompted me to listen to the entire soundtrack and rank as I went.
From best to worst:
Defying Gravity
As Long as you're Mine
Dancing through Life
For Good
No Good Deed
One Short Day
March of the Witch Hunters
Thank Goodness
The Wizard and I
I'm Not that Girl
What is this Feeling
No One Mourns the Wicked
Popular
Finale
Dear Old (CENSORED)
Wonderful
Something Bad
Sentimental Man
I'm Not that Girl (reprise)
It makes me want to see Wicked again.
--
http://img.imgcake.com/pinkygifuh.gif