Granted, that may be where I disagree with some of you. I don't consider sales to immediately be indicative of being overrated.
Fair enough, I agree it's a "different" way at looking at it than something like, OoT/FFVII/Xenogears where you have notable poritons of their fanbases claiming it's the greatest of all time. If we factor sales out of this, I agree CoD probably doesn't belong in this discussion. In which case I'd be back to saying it's something like OoT/LttP/FFVII/Xenogears/RBY (some more unpopular choices here I'm sure). Not that any of those are bad or anything, of course.
Not sure whether I'm willing to group Shadow of the Colossus in there. If we go by the whole "true art" section of the fanbase, I'd say yeah, sure. But...
--
xp1337: Don't you wish there was a spell-checker that told you when you a word out?
GotD (219/384) Melee v FFX