Update:
*Atomsk (FLCL) - Gen
*Blackbeard/The Thing (Fantastic Four) - cyan
Captain Fargus (Fire Emblem 7)
Captain Nemo (Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea)
*Captain Syrup (Wario Land) - whipper
*Cortez (Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door) - mcflubbin
*Faris Scherwiz (Final Fantasy V) - charon
*Gangplank (League of Legends) - Articuno
Jack Shandy (On Stranger Tides)
*Johnny (Guilty Gear) - Pirateking
*Pirate Man (Mega Man and Bass) - Bakusai
*Pirate Penguin (Legend of Mana) - Gen
*Ruby Heart (Marvel vs. Capcom 2) - charon
*Smee (Peter Pan) - 521
*Steve the Pirate (Dodgeball) - flubbin
*Tetra (The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker) - Evillord
*Tron Bonne (Mega Man Legends) - Bakusai
--
:>