Alright, I was hoping this thread would go longer than it has so far. Y'all can continue giving opinions after I bump it here, but I'd already been leaning towards ICO before making this thread and Pyro sold me on it (if ICO is "short" (or even "shortish"), then it only makes sense to play it first. Not to mention, it's best to get the slower gameplay out of the way before the action. I love me some puzzle games something fierce, but it's hard to move from a faster-paced action game to a slower puzzle game).