Questionable (need people who nominated them to give some feedback):
Basil Hawkins (One Piece) - This seems a little hokey; does he do much more than prognostication?
Erika Furudo (Umineko no Naku Koro ni) - I can find nothing to indicate this character even has magical ability. Has she really never even cast a spell?
I'm on the fence with both Bayonetta characters as well. Having magical ability or being classified as a witch doesn't really mean much. Like with the Sephiroth example... simply possessing the ability but never using it will disqualify you. Anyone want to comment?
--
:>