It's pretty excellent all around. This is honestly the best fighting game in a long time on most fronts. The biggest weaknesses I see so far are the Online is merely SF4 (Not SSF4. Just SF4.) level. Except on Xbox you wont have enough people online for that to really work out for you. I hear the PS3 version definitely has more people. The other Weakness is pretty much the execution barriers on a lot of stuff is pretty high compared to every other new-age fighter. I think that will hurt it with casuals even more then being Not Capcom will hurt it. Pretty much everyone oldschool loves the game tho. At least that I've talked to. Guys who like CVS2 seem to adore this game.
Personal complaints with the game for me are like... Superflash restricting inputs is pretty weird for me. I don't think it's a bad thing but I miss super flash>Input your Super to beat it style moments. I wish Adel or Rugal made the cast and hearing Adel was the next character they were making is a downer that they didn't finish him. Terry Bogard I think is pretty bad in this game which also makes me sad. I think his Brother stole all of his powers or something because Terry is just kinda weak compared to everyone else in the cast.
--
Whatever...