Combing them both into one makes it really difficult for me. I think this is about how I'd rank them. The only 100% locked spots are the top 3 and bottom 4.
Aigis
Naoto
Chie
Kanji
Shinjiro
Akihiko
P4MC (Mostly due to the anime)
Teddie
Junpei
Yosuke
P3FMC
P3MC
Fuuka
Metis
Koromaru
Mitsuru
Yukari
Rise
Yukiko
Ken
--
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/swordz9