8:00 PM: iCarly
8:30 PM: Victorious
Even if you hate Dan Schneider and his shows with the passion of a thousand burning suns, you don't realistically get SNICK back without these two shows. They're reminiscent of the earlier eras of SNICK (shows like Clarissa Explains It All and even Roundhouse to some extent) and they'd bring huge ratings, ensuring the block's survival.
9:00 PM: The Legend of Korra
9:30 PM: Power Rangers Super Samurai
--
I chose poorly. Black Turtle chose wisely.