Neat.
And...I'm generally ok with highly discretionary systems for moderators, provided you have a solid bunch of moderators. I admin a forum where the rules are something along the lines of....
1. Don't post anything illegal that would get our hosting revoked (ROMs etc)
2. Don't be a spam bot.
3. Don't be stupid. We're looking for intelligent conversation--what you talk about and what words you use aren't important, but the "intelligent" part is.
Granted, the discretionary system does mean in-practice there's an implicit fourth rule of "Don't openly antagonize every single moderator and admin, especially if your account is 3 days old." But realistically that was true on GameFAQs as well >_>
--
Cats land on their feet. Toast lands peanut butter side down. A cat with toast strapped to its back will hover above the ground in a state of quantum indecision