From: Panthera | #035
Every single discussion of morality in the context of religion disagrees with you. Some of the central aspects of Christianity (morality being derived from God, people "deserving" damnation if they aren't "forgiven" via faith in Jesus) are obviously extremely offensive to people who disagree with them (the "forgiveness" aspect is exactly what you describe as not being acceptable - "everyone who is outside this group should suffer"). Conversely, to a Christian, if I attempt to explain how a non-Christian system of ethics can exist and try to convince people why I don't believe in Christianity, I am trying to turn people to evil and make them suffer eternally. Thus, Christianity must be banned, as must anyone who disagrees with it (or rather, the expression of any position on Christianity must be banned)
Christians don't believe that "everyone who is outside this group should suffer". They believe that everyone who is outside their group WILL suffer. And arguing what a non-Christian is trying to do from a Christian perspective is absurd logic.
--
Therefore; flawed conclusion.