Well, for one thing you said the singer would be better off in a different genre. That says a lot, and well you dislike power metal, symphonic elements, various stuff you describe as unnecessary and whatnot, gives the vibe that there's a lot you don't like mixed with this particular, well, narrow zone that is your metal hotspot.
Just sayin', somebody's gotta comment on the comments. =P
And I didn't say you're narrowminded, just that you seem to have a fairly particular or narrow view of what metal should be. Considering the ratings in the topic are on the negative side, I mean that doesn't seem like a far fetched claim.
And speaking of, for your rating system how would a song you enjoyed get a 4/10?
--
One Piece: Pirates with style!
-= Metal Gear Solid: Tactical Espionage Action =-