LogFAQs > #978689379

LurkerFAQs, Active Database ( 12.01.2023-present ), DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	Simpsons Mafia topic 2: D'oh, here's your new topic!
Kirby321 02/06/24 1:47:45 PM #287:	Enchantress posted... Why does your mind jump to me being scum with a renamed role, and not just...town with a renamed role, exactly? People are genuinely confused all the time just because they misread things, or don't pick up on sarcasm or jokes, or simply can't parse certain player's writing styles. I don't agree with people reading into "oh JC has a regular named role so he's not informed scum" instead of just like, JC doesn't pick up on FD's oblique hinting. I stand by it not being valid, because again, it's either an ironic second simpsons mafia hosting error, or a total waste of time. The game of mafia is not "nitpick people's PM structures". It's incredibly annoying, ineffective, and to me, not at all fun. My mind immediately jumped to scum because you showed indifference toward something that should've been new information to any ordinary townie. Just because your role is renamed doesn't mean everyone else's is. You couldn't have known that. No one could have realized that Death's Vanilla role was renamed until FD pointed it out... because they have the same functional role. Think about why Ulti didn't grilled despite full claiming. Or Red. They both claimed power roles that obviously wouldn't be counterclaimed this early. Only Death got prodded for his true, full claim. So let me ask you this... if FD isn't also a Town Vanilla, how did he deduce that Death was missing something in his claim? --- Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failure Soo... how was your day? <cite>Kirby321 posted [p:978689379] in Simpsons M... [t:80689033]...</cite> <quote>Enchantress posted... </cite><quote>Why does your mind jump to me being scum with a renamed role, and not just...town with a renamed role, exactly? People are genuinely confused all the time just because they misread things, or don't pick up on sarcasm or jokes, or simply can't parse certain player's writing styles. I don't agree with people reading into "oh JC has a regular named role so he's not informed scum" instead of just like, JC doesn't pick up on FD's oblique hinting.I stand by it not being valid, because again, it's either an ironic second simpsons mafia hosting error, or a total waste of time. The game of mafia is not "nitpick people's PM structures". It's incredibly annoying, ineffective, and to me, not at all fun.</quote>My mind immediately jumped to scum because you showed indifference toward something that should've been new information to any ordinary townie.Just because your role is renamed doesn't mean everyone else's is. You couldn't have known that. No one could have realized that Death's Vanilla role was renamed until FD pointed it out... because they have the same functional role. Think about why Ulti didn't grilled despite full claiming. Or Red. They both claimed power roles that obviously wouldn't be counterclaimed this early. Only Death got prodded for his true, full claim.So let me ask you this... if FD isn't also a Town Vanilla, how did he deduce that Death was missing something in his claim? --- Kirby321 is 60% epicsauce, 40% epic failureSoo... how was your day?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1