LogFAQs > #979108278

SirChris posted...

Btw death and I discussed this. You misunderstood my post I was offering to towncase myself during the night

I knew this was a possible interpretation of your post, but I still didn't like it as a "Hey Lopen, protect me, I swear I'm good for it, haha" ploy. Promising future value and then dipping for the rest of the day is not a great look.

But as should be clear from my other posts today, post Death flip I've moved you down in priority and am looking elsewhere. But you're still strongly in my suspect list.

Enchantress posted...

Did Dumey ever expound on his thoughts regarding dating and undating Peaf? Why he broke up with Peaf not expecting Peaf to actually do it, etc. I only catch up on jokes.

Not sure what extra context you're asking for. I pretty much said it as it happened. And still stand by those posts.
When I originally dated Peaf I didn't have much of a read on him one way or the other. I thought it was funny because of my argument with Lopen at the time, and I thought I could get a player read seeing how Peaf would use the date later on. (Technically this played out, because he didn't do the Town Peaf thing I would expect of him starting to distrust me later in the day!)
When we got to what was starting to look like a settled end of day, with the options being what looked like a genuine Vanilla Kirby, JC who I liked in general, and a Lea who put herself in that situation with no offramp, I thought that it was probable that everyone on the chopping block was town. So when you asked me to switch it up, I went for it, not really expecting that Peaf would put himself in danger. Even as Town, he would have little motivation to do so. But my read of Peaf at that point was still 50/50, he hadn't provided enough content for me to think of him as town or scum. So putting the neutral Peaf in the pool over the three people I had at least some reason to think was town was okay with me. Upside is that if scum Peaf left to save someone, that feels pretty damning.
Then Peaf actually took the breakup, and went for Kirby, and had his "oh I forgot JC was trying to date Kirby too. Awk." moment. I don't know how much of that is true, and how much is an excuse. I THINK it makes the most sense that Kirby is town, Peaf thought it was an easy way to score some town cred for "saving" Kirby, and it just didn't go as he planned in his head. There is a far offshoot world where Kirby is scum, and refused Peaf's plan because it would look WAY too suspicious if he took the date while other people like JC had an open date invitation already. Add in the Lea offer and FD making himself available, and there was 0 chance that Kirby went for Peaf in that scenario, dooming him.

TL;DR Town Read > Neutral Read, and a "Why not?" attitude.