LogFAQs > #965674935

ViolentAbacus posted...

It's more that the Ditto role seemed to be there partially to trip up/have a watcher call it out.

Also the reason I'm not going after Kirby is the fact that Ulti didn't die until after the doc claim, and Kirby saw someone go to Chris the same night that Ulti went. You'd figure if he did swap Kirby would be like "hey this happened" or was scum. I've not heard a good argument against it.

Also seemed to have a cop call it out. Again, it's a role that would make the player have questions, why not answer them in the role regardless of setup.

Ulti wasn't necessarily doctor to scum either and they probably thought he was a likely mislynch until the claim. I'm not saying that this is necessarily a great play to kill plum instead, but death and Sultan were confirmed townspeople. Youre basically saying it's less likely the scum team that didnt backup poison made another misplay than that 2/6 scum are godfathers. A misplay that in this case didn't actually end up as one because even if they thought Ulti was doctor, they were right that he didn't protect the people they wanted to kill.