LogFAQs > #966066607

Jakyl25 posted...

So your theory is that the 6 that overturned Roe and Casey here:

1.) Believe that abortion is murder
2.) Contrived an unrelated originalist reason to repeal Roe and Casey to further that belief, a line of reasoning that could be copy/pasted to lots of decisions
3.) Dont believe that those decisions are immoral enough to be worth repealing

Just making sure that this is where your argument stands

1 seems reasonable - maybe not for all of the 6 but at least a majority of the 6 and maybe all 6. 2 is reasonable although I wouldn't use the word "contrived" which generates the feelings that the originalist explanation is somehow not legitimate. 3 is also reasonable, although it doesn't apply to all 6.