LogFAQs > #966195190

PunishedBen posted...

Add to that Sheep was really hesitant to give a confident read on Death. Made a whole post ISO'ing Death and calling out scummy posts of his but never comitting.

I woulda been murdering Death days ago if we'd lynched Plum and I've had him on my scumlist since D2. I think on reflection I definitely should have tried to pressure him a lot more, but I kinda tunnelled in on Plum too much when people starting arguing he might be Town. And I definitely fell off after early game, some irl stuff got my activity knocked off and has kinda limited me to an hour or two of catching up and posting walls every day, cause I'm basically sleeping through the active timezones.

PunishedBen posted...

Yo Sheep is it you? If not you then who?

Honestly? I'm kinda stumped right now. Yesterday I couldn't see any realistic scumteam without Tidus on it, and I'm in a similar position to you where I think I have to have cleared a scum player early in the game to have been left alive. I was trying to do what I could to force scum to kill me N1, and that's making me paranoid about who I heavily townread, because that's imo the main reason to kill Chang or MZero over myself, leaving me considering you, Lea and Ulti.

Out of these, I feel best about Lea, actually? I got paranoid for a bit that I was just doing my typical thing and nailing most of the scum team early but hardclearing one and then tunnelvissioning them as Town in every possibility. But I always come back to her being so far outside her Scum meta from last game that I just don't see any scenario in which she's scum.

And then you and Ulti have been scanned, which is obviously a big plus point for you. I need to read those scans back when I can, and check some of the flavour meta because I know literally nothing about any of these shows to be able to tell if they could be flavour traps. That aside, I think both of you have been ridiculously Town so far, and I want to check the D2 votes again to see if it looks like Scum were pushing for Ulti after the Han mislynch.

Yesterday, I thought that the third scum (with Tidus/Death) would be in Kirby/BCT, and I think at least one being here is still likely. There's two scum left beyond Death, and I'll be shocked if there isn't one in those players I've only read as Town, rather than absolutely nailed in. I think BCT is perhaps more likely to be Scum than Kirby, because I've felt less good overall about him throughout the game? But that said, I have a lot of trouble getting past BCT's D1 vote making him look ridiculously towny. Like, he basically threw away his vote if he's Plum's teammate, which strikes me as really odd given Scum clearly wanted Plum to survive past that day specifically. If he's scum then getting him to keep his vote on Ben or Red just to try and swing that lynch makes so much more sense. Kirby's vote, on the other hand, fits the profile of a scummate-saving vote a lot more, but there's been lots of little things that I've liked from him. I've put him under pressure a few times because I'm not entirely sure on him, at least not as I'd like to be, but I've really liked his responses and I struggle to see them coming from Scum.

Which leaves me considering SBell. Who has claimed tracker, and I think I believe? I want to read back his last few days a bit more because I've definitely been kinda detached since D3, but for whatever reason I still feel most unsure on him. I just... really don't think that BCT and Kirby are both scum, and I'm not even sure that one of them would be. I'm a little dubious that we'd have a third strong investigative role in a game with a backup.... But I'm also hesitant to role meta hard, especially considering I think Sultan is a relatively inexperienced host, and the claim and reaction to it just doesn't fit the vibe of a scummate faking a scan on another scummate to manufacture a clear.

I too can feel dead town chat screaming at me for this entire post and I am incredibly sorry for whoever I'm gravely mistaken on but this is not as obvious as you think Han I promise