LogFAQs > #969548563

Safe 30/50
Billy Chapman (Silent Night, Deadly Night)
Bonestorm commercial Santa (The Simpsons)
Chris Kringle (Team Starkid's Black Friday)
Creature (Love, Death, & Robots: All Through the House)
Delibird (Pokemon)
Giant Metal Santa Claus With Glowing Red Eyes (Jonathan Coulton - Chiron Beta Prime)
Greatfather Winter (World of Warcraft)
Hogfather (Discworld)
Jack Skellington (The Nightmare Before Christmas)
Jingle (Animal Crossing)
Klaus (Klaus)
Koopa Klaus (Super Mario Bros Super Show)
Kris Kringle/Santa (Miracle on 34th Street)
Mall Santa (A Christmas Story)
Mall Santa (It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia)
North (Rise of the Guardians)
Old Tim/The Ice Moose (PB&J Otter)
Robot Santa (Futurama)
Sandy Claws (The Nightmare Before Christmas)
Santa Claus (Coca-Cola)
Santa Claus (I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus)
Santa Claus (Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer)
Santa Claus (South Park)
Santa Claus (Violent Night)
Santa Claws (Yu-Gi-Oh!)
Santa Suit Maniac (Tales from the Crypt)
Scott Calvin (The Santa Clause)
SCP-4666/The Yule Man (The SCP Foundation)
Sumo Santa (ClayFighter 63 1/3)
Toy Santa (The Santa Clause 2)

2
Aru (QP Shooting/Xmas Shooting series)
Father Santa Christmas Kringle Claus the December Giver (Fairly Odd Parents)
Frost Gigas (Secret of Mana)
Omega-Level Mutant Santa Claus (X-Men/Marvel Comics)
Santa (M&Ms Commercial)
Santa (Santa's Slay)
Santa (Weird Al Yankovic - The Night Santa Went Crazy)
Santa Claus (Elf)
Santa Claus (Epic Rap Battles of History)
Santa Claus (Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer Animated Special)
Santa Claus (The Christmas Chronicles)
Santa Claus (The Killers Christmas song trilogy)
The Grinch (How the Grinch Stole Christmas!)
The Santa who fell off the roof (The Santa Clause)
Willie T. Stokes (Bad Santa)

1
Angus brother, Santa (Middlemost Post)
Chris (Fatman)
Clawz (Saints Row IV: How the Saints Saved Christmas)
Henry Corwin (The Twilight Zone - The Night of the Meek)
Jesper Johansen (Klaus)
Joe Carruthers (Ernest Saves Christmas)
Noelle Kringle (Noelle)
Ricky (Silent Night Deadly Night 2)
Rouge (Astra Superstars/SANTACLAUS company mascot)
Saint Nicholas (Folklore)
Saint of Nymeia (Final Fantasy XIV)
Santa (Recess Christmas: Miracle on Third Street)
Santa Claus (American Dad!)
Santa Claus (Jackie Chan Adventures)
Santa Claus (Santa Claus Conquers the Martians)
Santa Claus (The Simpsons: The Christmas That Almost Wasn't But Then Was)
Santa Clod (The Powerpuff Girls)
Santa Suit (Invader Zim)
St. Niklas (Sint)
The Winter Festival Envoy (Fire Emblem: Heroes)

Right now I think I'm leaning against the F/GO nominations. I've tried to be pretty lenient with nominations, and I kinda get the arguments for them, but it ultimately just kinda feels like an alternate skin with some flavor text, especially since it gave basically the same things to a bunch of other characters in the game. Not to mention it hurts the contest imo if over 10% of the entrants are just F/GO skins