Though Ben, you quoting something from around there reminded me of the PoE argument I presented Wallz the next day.
EDumey posted...
Let's look at the votals again. [7] Sheep - Han, Lea, (Ulti), (BCT), (Sultan), (Wallz), Wallz, Ulti, Sultan, JC, Isquen Han had explicit reasons for voting Sheep. Lea had explicit reasons for voting Sheep. BCT unvoted earlier on to chase other rabbit holes. You voted because I guess if I'm being charitable, you didn't like that Sheep wasn't defending himself very well or in a town fashion. Ulti is as close to confirmed town as we can get. Sultan had reasons for voting Sheep, though granted I don't think they're as strong, but Sultan has other things going in his favor outside of this context. JC has a claim that we're currently evaluating. And Isquen is also likely scum due to PoE and made a bad unnecessary hammer before day ended naturally. If it makes you feel better, I will amend my statement to say that Isquen's vote looks worse than yours. But your vote is clearly the other one that stands out as "why is that there?"
Let me frame this another way. There were 11 people alive that could vote for Sheep there. There is most likely 3 scum remaining. We know that one of the votes that wasn't on Sheep was Crescent, who flipped town. Either ALL THREE PEOPLE who did not vote Sheep (Dumey, Ctes, BCT) are scum, or there is at LEAST one scum more likely two, on the Sheep lynch. My PoE leads me to think that is Wallz and Isquen.
I know I'm town, so it still stands to reason that someone on that Sheep lynch was scum. I previously thought it was Wallz and Isquen who had the worst votes on the lynch. But now I'm looking at Han riding the vote the entire day from start to finish, or Sultan jumping on the day that I criticized him of not playing the way I thought of Town Sultan.
This doesn't really change anything, but just interesting that the logic looking at that lynch still applies here. Was Sheep lynched by almost entirely town and that's why the D2 was so dead? Because BCT and Ctes felt zero pressure to post or change anything?