LogFAQs > #972222124

Ben do you have no concept of looking outside your own perspective? Me saying that scum could shoot Sultan is from the perspective that I don't know who scum is and anyone could be a target. That has no bearing on who I think is town or scum at that point. I think you're likely scum, but I also would describe you as a very low chance of being night killed, because you are very much a possible lynch target. Same as Ctes.

So yes, there is value in thinking, "Sultan seems to be one of the people the least in Town's line of fire, and so is dangerous to scum to leave around if he's Town, and would be a likely kill. So him NOT dying is a point against him."

Though obviously with Ulti not being BP and dying invalidates that because it's obvious they would kill him if they hadn't previously shot him earlier.

Lea did bring up Ulti as well as a possible kill, but I thought there was no reason to doubt BP still. Call me naive to still believe it, but I thought the chances of scum leaving claimed doctor alive as long as he was so that he was able to potentially block TWO night kills (First one still unconfirmed) was crazier than just thinking he got an insane role and scum wasted a night shooting him.