LogFAQs > #973488689

RuneterranSnap posted...

I mean, they all but objectively did. Both visuals and practical effects were on point throughout.

No they weren't. TPM in particular has some really shoddy effects on some of the aliens. Cinematography wise the most memorable shot is the long take when Kenobi fights Maul. The camera is often way too wide and pulled back from the action(this is a problem with a lot of the pt shots actually). AOTC has a similar issue with too much going on on screen and a lack of focus. I personally think the scenes with anakin and padme romancing are kinda ugly and poorly colorized, but the stuff with kenobi fighting jango looks good imo. I dont have a problem with Yoda being a flipping ball of lightsaber slashing energy but they didn't really seem to know how to implement it all that well.

ROTS has some great shots in its last 30 minutes and almost nothing else of particular note.

Meanwhile TLJ boats some of the best action sequences and shots of the entire saga, and even TROS has some iconic imagery and the entire trilogy is just shot better as a whole. The final fight in TFA is gorgeous to look at and the reds of kylos saver against the blue of everything else is awesome. Nothing like that in the PT except the final battle even even then its wierd the way they shot some of that.

The moments of Vader birth have some really great visuals however.